Case Study on "Yahoo! Summative Assessment Family Name"

Case Study 8 pages (2817 words) Sources: 20

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Yahoo! Summative Assessment

Family name, Given Name

Student Identifier

The decision making on the part of Yahoo! CEO Yang and the pre-Icahn board of directors is blameworthy as the group utilized overly optimistic future financial prediction on growth and intangible assets to respond to a very reasonable buyout offer by Microsoft. In so doing the group, led by Yang demonstrated bad faith toward shareholders. The thinking proved very narrow as the stock and cash buyout offer, by Microsoft was expanded to an even higher number. In short the heads of the company, overvalued the company to such a degree that the offers were refused and the stock fell, over the short- and long-term to less than half the pre-offer value. (Summative Assessment Case, 2009-2010)

Additionally Yang and the Board demonstrated bad faith when they attempted to retain the company through the divulging of potential, other cooperative offers, none of which would serve the shareholders, or company as well as a Microsoft buyout. None of the other cooperative offers, or potential acquisitions would serve the company interests of growth and the national and financial interests of creating a real and potential competitor to Google. (Summative Assessment Case, 2009-2010)Google was and remains the largest internet search engine and Yahoo! And Microsoft's largest competitor, which completely overshadows the smaller company in market share for search engines. (Stockport, 2010) Finally, Yang showed bad faith in his veiled threats to deliberately devalue the company, with bad decisions such as unwise acquisitions and/or collaborative non-gain contracts, to reduce the risk of a Microsoft or shareholder takeover.

There is some sense that the internal actions and decisions making of Yang's biggest critic, shareholder Carl Icahn, who rapidly began buying massive dollar amounts of Yahoo! In an attempt to exercise shareholder's rights to vote in a new board of directors is praiseworthy if he acted as he stated on the urging of other shareholders and excusable if he acted in collusion with Microsoft, as the deal in retrospect really was one that should have been more seriously considered. Yang's antagonists were clearly Icahn and his proposed board replacements and Microsoft's CEO Steve Ballmer, who sought to buy the company for less than what Yang believed it was worth. Yang's protagonists include all those shareholders who offered Yang and the existing board of directors a vote of confidence in the annual board vote. (Summative Assessment Case, 2009-2010)

Task 2

Yang frequently claimed in the press that Microsoft had undervalued Yahoo! In both its first and second cash/share offers. The language Yang used both during the deal and after was far to optimistic, claiming that his intention to stave off the offer or at least raise it to 37$ a share (as compared to Microsoft's 33$ a share final offer 70% above stock value before the offer came in) was based on his belief in intangible assets such as investments and userbase as well as proposed sunny financial improvements. (Summative Assessment Case, 2009-2010)

"We have taken the proposal Microsoft delivered to us very seriously. We made a public statement why we not accepted the proposal." & #8230; "In many ways it has been a galvanizing event for all of Yahoo," he said. "Our board, which has been a very independent board, is spending a lot of time understanding our alternatives."

"the number of people who talked to us about what this could mean for the industry." & #8230; "give me a lot of encouragement. We are trying to make sure Yahoo goes to the right place for our customers, our employees and above all our shareholders." (Hansell, 2008)

Only a few supporters are represented in the case study, or really in the press and are not big players, they were small shareholders who obviously held a grudge against Microsoft, on principle and who were expecting to see their stocks continue to decline despite support of Yang. (Summative Assessment Case, 2009-2010)

Critics of Yang and the Yahoo! team that rejected the Microsoft offer, including Carl Icahn, who developed the proxy threat on the other hand offer sobering words that are backed by the real numbers and tangible assets:

It is clear that the board of directors of Yahoo has acted irrationally and lost the faith of shareholders and Microsoft. Microsoft's bid of $33 per share is a superior alternative to Yahoo's prospects on a standalone basis. I am perplexed by the board's actions. It is irresponsible to hide behind & #8230; over-optimistic financial forecasts. It is unconscionable that you have not allowed your shareholders the choice of accepting an offer that represents a 72% premium over Yahoo's closing price of $19.18 on the day before the initial Microsoft offer. I and many shareholders strongly believe that a combination between Yahoo! And Microsoft

would form a & #8230;force strong enough to compete with Google on the Internet.

In Ballmer's (CEO of Microsoft) words to Yahoo! removing the offer from the table the same is true. His valuation of the company as well as his offer of 33$ per share are bolstered the fact that Yahoo! may have acted rashly in its bid to stave off the offer. "I still believe even today that our offer remains the only alternative put forward that provides your stockholders full and fair value for their shares. By failing to reach an agreement with us, you and your stockholders have left significant value on the table." (Microsoft Corp., 2008)

Task 3

The most likely theory to apply to the culprit's state of mind prior to, during and after the Microsoft offer debacle is a closed environment. Yang as well as other top Yahoo! execs obviously suffered from a limited view of both the company and the market. Yang may have been prematurely appointed to CEO as the co-founder of the company only 13 years old and the team may have been surrounded by a bunch of yes men who were afraid to give Yang the facts on the real strengths and weaknesses of the company prior to the offer. (Arsenault & Castells, 2008) (Rosenzweig, 2007)There is no doubt that Yang, having been an innovator and a risk taker, building the company from scratch through intellectual properties might have had an unrealistic sense of the health of the company based solely on the fact that it did rise from nothing to a multi-billion dollar company in just 13 years and that it would rise from this conflict as well as the overall economic condition of the world in the same or similar manner. (Weston, 2007) the search team that sought out better alternatives than a Microsoft buyout may have also misrepresented the real value of cooperative and acquisition futures that were in the pipeline. (Matzick, Kusters, Krall, Kuhn, & Schumacher, 2008)

Despite countless warnings to the contrary Yang in fact has proposed as part of his plan, either to strengthen Yahoo! Or possibly as some contest to make it undesirable to Microsoft, to do a joint venture with Google, its biggest competitor on some of its services. The decision was seriously challenged by Microsoft as a very unwise move.

We regard with particular concern your apparent planning to respond to a "hostile" bid by pursuing a new arrangement that would involve or lead to the outsourcing to Google of key paid Internet search terms offered by Yahoo! today.

In our view, such an arrangement with the dominant search provider would make an acquisition of Yahoo! undesirable to us for a number of reasons.

(Microsoft Corp., 2008)

CEO of Microsoft then goes on to list several strategic reasons why such a deal would be unwise, not the least of which is the derailing of any real attempt to [provide a reasonable competitor to Google. (Microsoft Corp., 2008) This is despite the fact that Yang and others at Yahoo! have had many multiple meetings with unnamed important industry leaders regarding the need to build a real competitor for Google, rather than get in bed with them. (Hansell, 2008) (Beyazitoglu, 2009) (Curwen, 2008)

Task 4

The process of mergers in the current internet/communications business climate include a long list of FCC and other federal and even international reviews to conclude that any merger would provide acceptable terms not to produce a monopoly in any one area of the given business. (Roberts, 2008-2009) Federal antitrust laws are significant in any formation of a merger, especially with business giants like Yahoo! And Microsoft. The proposed merger would have required many hours of review on the part of the Federal Trades commission, and the Federal Communications Commission, as each would need to determine if the merger would increase or seriously decrease fair trade in the notable aspects of each business. Yet in this case, though it was surely discussed by both parties did not reach this stage of development. The legal system which governs such "negotiations" has broad leeway with regard to how it rules, given the state of continued business evolution and the are of communications is a prime example of… READ MORE

How to Reference "Yahoo! Summative Assessment Family Name" Case Study in a Bibliography

Related Papers:

Spanish Nicknames and Family Names. En Todos Term Paper

Spanish

Nicknames and family names.

En todos las culturas, los nombres son muy importante para la identitad personal. Los nombres son differentes en las culturas differentes. Por ejemplo, Juan en… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (1010 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

Family Ecology Term Paper

Family Ecology

The family is considered the basic unit of the society. It is where a person acquires his/her basic characteristics and habits. They say that the personality of an… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2218 words) Sources: 13 Style: APA Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

Family Health History Essay

Family Health History

It is important to note from the onset that although I came to the U.S. approximately 17 years ago, my parents have been residing in this country… read more

Essay 8 pages (2560 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

Family Therapy Term Paper

Family Therapy

Family establishment and sustainability are a multifaceted endeavour that has immense explanations and perceptions in the world. Many families in the society have diversity in management, care, materialization… read more

Term Paper 16 pages (4841 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

Family System Therapy Thesis

Family Systems Therapy: Strengths and Weaknesses

While most forms of therapy treat the individual in isolation, and focus upon the family only to the extent that the family impacts that… read more

Thesis 2 pages (899 words) Sources: 1 Style: APA Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>