Literature Review on "Workplace Reorganization and Its Effects on the Welfare of Employees"

Literature Review 10 pages (2740 words) Sources: 8

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Workplace Re-Organization and Its Effects on the Welfare of Employees

Organizational change has gained incremental momentum within the specialized literature of the past recent years. The dimensions of organizational change are numerous, including elements such as the necessity for change, the actual plan of change implementation or the management of change and its impacts. The academic community generally agrees with the incremental role played by organizational change within the contemporaneous business society. Offering a definition of organizational change is a highly challenging task and this difficulty is pegged to the complexity of the process on the one hand, and the perception that the term of organizational change is clear and does not require a formal definition, on the other hand. Some authors will simply commence their discussions of the desired dimensions of organizational change, whereas others will strive to offer a definition. In this light of events, some notable definitions or organizational change include the following:

1. "Organizational change involves, by definition, a transformation of an organization between two points in time" (Barnett and Carroll, 1995).

2. "There are several types of changes in ones organization. They are changing nature of the workforce, technology, economic shocks, competition, social trends and world politics" (Eric, 2008).

3. "Change initiatives […] range from corporate restructuring and the replacement of key personnel through to the minor modification of basic operating procedures" (Dawson, 2003).

4. "Organizations are not the same all the time. They do adapt to circumstances. This process of becoming different in order to adapt to new assumptions can be defined as a process of organizational change" (Langer, Alfirevic and Pavicic, 2005).

Once the meaning of organizational change is offered -- or implied -- the authors move on to the discussion of the change dimensions of interest. One such dimension refers to the time frame in which change occurs. While some organizational leaders still implement change as a sporadic event, others argue that the change process is an integrant party of the business model and that change is an ongoing process. From this latter standpoint, change is no longer perceived as a temporary event, but as an ongoing business model by which the company managers strive to improve and consolidate their competitive positions.

Authors Karl. E. Weick and Robert E. Quinn (1999) reveal the growing concern over the increasing pace of organizational change. They argue that a discrepancy occurs in the nature of change, which is now perceived in a dual mode. On the one hand, organizational change is perceived as a sporadic event, which occurs every now and then. On the other hand, it is perceived and implemented as a continuous process. In order to settle the debate, the two authors analyze change from different standpoints, such as conducting an analysis of the organization through the lenses of change implementation, or the identification of the nature of organizations implementing sporadic and ongoing change.

A noteworthy element in their article Organizational Change and Development is constituted by the comparison of sporadic and ongoing change through four distinct lenses -- metaphor of organization, analytic framework, ideal organization, intervention theory and the role of the change agent. This analysis is briefly revealed in the table below:

Sporadic change

Ongoing change

Metaphor of organization

Organizations are inertial and change is infrequent, planned and discontinuous

Organizations are emergent, change is seen as evolution

Analytic framework

Change is driven from the external environment; it is dramatic and disrupts equilibrium

Continuous small and large responses to emergent features, organized under continuous change and adaptation

Ideal organization

The ideal organization is able to continually adapt

The ideal organization is able to continually adapt

Intervention theory

Three levels

1. Unfreeze -- preparation for change

2. Transition -- implementation of new knowledge, values and other change components

3. Refreeze -- solidification of change

Three levels:

1. Unfreeze -- identify the need for change

2. Rebalance -- implement change

3. Refreeze -- solidification of change and the search for new change opportunities

Role of the change agent

The change agent creates the change

The change agent redirects the change process

At the end of their analysis, Weick and Quinn conclude that episodic and continuous changes are both present within the business community and that they are implemented by organizations with distinctive features. Additionally, they find that both types of change are generated by an internal failure to adapt to a specific phenomenon and that, in spite of a theoretic separation of the two types of change, the process of change is in fact ongoing. "Our review suggests both that change starts with failures to adapt and that change never starts because it never stops" (Weick and Quinn).

In response to the statement that the reactions of the organization to change differ in relationship to the nature of the firm, this conclusion seems to be enforced by Bob Hamlin, Jane Keep and Ken Ash (2001) in their Organizational Change and Development: A Reflective Guide for Managers. The three authors reveal that the employees in public institutions are more reticent to change than the employees in private institutions. The table below reveals the various degrees of change acceptance and its impacts across different types of organizations:

Table 1: The impact of change on loyalty, morale, motivation and sense of job security by type of business:

All

Charity / non-profit

Family owned businesses

Partnerships

Private limited companies

Pic's

Public sector

Effect on loyalty

Increased

10

14

21

14

15

7

6

Unchanged

44

45

52

57

52

42

36

Decreased

46

42

28

29

33

51

59

Effect on morale

Increased

17

20

36

40

26

15

8

Unchanged

21

20

29

7

23

26

13

Decreased

62

60

36

53

50

59

79

Effect on motivation

Increased

22

28

25

33

30

21

14

Unchanged

30

23

39

20

37

34

23

Decreased

48

49

36

47

34

45

63

Effect on perceived job security

Increased

11

9

14

13

19

10

5

Unchanged

26

29

32

40

30

25

19

Decreased

64

62

54

47

51

65

76

Hamlin, Keep and Ash

Aside the nature of change, another important dimension in the analysis of the process is represented by its impacts on the various categories of organizational stakeholders. In terms of customers, organizational change processes have the ability to increase the levels of client satisfaction through an increase in the quality of the products and services offered. After conducting a study on the means in which organizational change in the banking sector impacts customers, Gagandeep Kaur at the Panjab University concluded that "banks can create customer satisfaction by exhibiting trustworthy behavior, showing genuine commitment to service, communicating information to customers efficiently and accurately, delivering services competently, handling potential and manifest conflicts skillfully, and improving overall customer relationship quality" (Kaur). The academician also argues that organizational change can have a positive impact on the levels of employees' on the job satisfaction.

In terms of the staff members however, these will often reveal a reticence to change, which will delay the successful implementation of the process. The most commonly forwarded reason for the reticence employees reveal relative to change is that of their fear of the unknown. Yet, this constitutes a mere section of the reticence rationale. At a general level, the reticence to change is generated by the realization of a change in the job processes; by a reduction in the economic security of the job; by a psychological threat (be it real or perceived); by the disruption of social arrangements or by the lowering of the employee's status within the organizational context (Dawson).

At a more specific level, Patrick Dawson identified a total of 13 reasons which create reticence to organizational change. They are revealed below:

1. The inability of the employees to comprehend the problem

2. The dismissal of the solution in favor of another alternative

3. The employees' sentiment that the proposed solution would not lead to the established objectives

4. The personal costs in accepting the change are unacceptable

5. The rewards in embracing the change are insufficient

6. The employees are afraid that they would not be able to cope with the new situation

7. The change reveals the risk of disrupting the current social arrangements

8. The sources of control and influence would be eroded

9. The change would integrate new values and practices

10. The employees reveal a reduced willingness to change

11. The employees feel that the managerial rationale for change is suspicious

12. The new change proposal is undervalued in comparison to other interests, and last

13. The change would reduce the professional power and opportunities for the employees (Dawson).

Most of these change resistance roots are addressed through the practice called organizational change management. Through this practice, organizational leaders strive to decrease the reticence to change and create an environment in which the impacts of the change are positive on all categories of stakeholders, including the staff members. Yet, in spite of these efforts, negative impacts can still occur. The specialized literature offers various instances… READ MORE

How to Reference "Workplace Reorganization and Its Effects on the Welfare of Employees" Literature Review in a Bibliography

Related Literature Reviews:

Societal Changes in Work Structure Affected Research Paper

Societal Changes in Work Structure Affected the Family Structure in the Last 20 Years?

Twenty years ago, the first effects of innovations in telecommunications began to be felt in the… read more

Research Paper 12 pages (3198 words) Sources: 12 Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

Risk and Insurance Term Paper

Risk and Insurance: ARAMARK

Risk Assessment of ARAMARK Corporation

Today, ARAMARK Corporation employees almost a quarter million people around the world in various food service and hospitality enterprises. The company… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (2953 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Ruchi Tomar the Advantages of Electronic Medical Thesis

Ruchi Tomar

The Advantages of Electronic Medical Records

First, it needs to be established again that a medical record is basically considered to be the documentation of an individual health… read more

Thesis 12 pages (3264 words) Sources: 12 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Information Systems and Their Efficiency Essay

This CRM software will be crucial to tracking customer satisfaction and help-desk efficiency. Thus, as per Puchbauer, in evaluating performance on the basis of goal achievement, he would like to… read more

Essay 33 pages (11200 words) Sources: 25 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Organisational Culture of J. Sainsbury Term Paper

Organisational Culture of J. Sainsbury

During the past two decades, the concept of organisational culture has gained broad acceptance as a way to understand human systems (Deal and Kennedy, 2000).… read more

Term Paper 46 pages (12724 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>