Essay on "Whitman and Dickinson and Whitman: The Greater"

Essay 4 pages (1389 words) Sources: 4

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Whitman and Dickinson

Dickinson and Whitman: The Greater and the Lesser

Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson are two very different 19th century American poets. While the former rose to literary significance on the strength of Ralph Waldo Emerson's encouragement and the massive "Song of Myself" of Leaves of Grass, the latter maintained a diminutive stature, wrote her poems in obscurity, and shared them with only a small handful of people in her lifetime. Whereas Whitman became known as the "father of free verse," Dickinson became known as the "Belle of Amherst." Whereas Whitman's poetry was unrestrained and humanist, Dickinson's verse was rhyming, measured (if spasmodic), structured, unconventional -- and yet more alive to traditional religious doctrines than Whitman's was. Although Whitman's poetry certainly captures the essence of an era of American literary history, Dickinson's poetry seems to have been written for all ages and truly seems to transcend both her surroundings and her age to probe the great mysteries of life. Therefore, this paper will show why Dickinson may be considered a greater American poet than Whitman.

While Walt Whitman's poetry is probing, its delight is less in the contemplation of the Deity whom Whitman acknowledged and more in the contemplation and celebration of himself. The celebration of self can be seen in much of Whitman's work, from "Song of Myself to "Passage to India."

Walt Whitman's Son of God is not Christ, as it is for Dickinson, but rather the poet who is the poet of Nature -- the poet who "fuses" together both "Nature and Man" (116) in "Passage to India." In other words, the Son of God, according to Whitman, is Whitman himself. The poem is meant to be an exercise in transcendence -- but it comes off as more of a self-promotion than a self-searching investigation. Whitman's transcendent poetry is more visceral than intellectual. "Passage to more than India!" is the cry of Whitman's Poet of Nature, who yearns for the Mysterious and the Eternal. But Whitman's poet of nature is so full of egoism and posturing that his reflections, while tending away from the incipient and modern and toward the natural and masculine, actually invoke a kind of Hemingway-ish sense of pride and self-worth that is undaunted -- unlike Dickinson's poetry, which is somewhat haunted by the mystery of the spirit and the world outside herself.

In this sense it may be argued that while Whitman expands himself (as in "Out of the Cradle Endlessly Rocking"), Dickinson humbles herself and makes herself small (as in "I heard a Fly Buzz"). Whitman wants to embrace greatness. Dickinson merely wants to be embraced.

In relation to the modern world and technology, Whitman's "Passage" is an act of contemplation inspired by the "Past," but deprived of the foundations of Western civilization, which Francis Thompson described as being the mainstay of the soul of the poet: "The Church, which was once the mother of poets no less than of saints, during the last two centuries has relinquished to aliens the chief glories of poetry, if the chief glories of holiness she has preserved for her own" (Thompson 17). Whitman's pursuit of the glory is apparent -- but, separated by birth from the birthright of the "age of faith" of which David, Dante, Chaucer, and Shakespeare were part, Whitman (like Hemingway) pursues greatness without holiness per se. This holiness can be defined in another way -- as Fulton Sheen states: it is the pursuit of greatness through the spirit of humility: "to a child everything seems big" (Sheen 3). It is the spirit of childlikeness that Sheen states is necessary in the pursuit of transcendence. Whitman embraces a kind of childlike spirit -- but a degree of pride also threatens to overwhelm the balance and turn the pursuit of a greater ideal into an Ode to Self, re-directing the journey upward inward.

Whitman's contemplations serve not to humble but to project his own greatness: rather than marvel upon the greatness or the glories of the past, he sees the same greatness and glory in himself: "O my brave soul!" (253) he cries beckoning it to go farther in time and space than God Himself… READ MORE

How to Reference "Whitman and Dickinson and Whitman: The Greater" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Walt Whitman: Death and Immortality Essay

The parallel structure of the free verse and the repetition of the words "just as" illustrates how Whitman and the inhabitants of the ferry are doing the same things --… read more

Essay 4 pages (1390 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Compare and Contrast Language and Grammar in Whitman Thesis

Spider's Objective In Whitman And Dickinson

We often hear the adage that great minds think alike and this is certainly true when it comes to poetry, especially poems about spiders.… read more

Thesis 3 pages (868 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Emily Dickinson Thesis

Emily Dickinson is often cited as one of the most creative and innovative of America's poets. She is also "... known for her unusual life of self imposed social seclusion.… read more

Thesis 8 pages (2436 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Emily Dickinson Thematic, Stylistic and Other Characteristics Term Paper

Emily Dickinson

Thematic, Stylistic and other Characteristics Unique to Emily Dickinson's Poetry

Emily Dickinson is perhaps the best of two or three examples of a completely unique voice within 19th… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (671 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Romanticism and Modernism Essay

Emily and Dickinson and Walt Whitman are diverse poets and their work can be seen as offering equal contributions to the Romantic era because they exemplify the ideas the Romantics… read more

Essay 6 pages (1797 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>