Term Paper on "Comparing 2 Plays"

Term Paper 3 pages (1097 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Whistleblowers, men of courage, but not angels -- a comparison of two modern plays

An Enemy of the People" versus "Inherit the Wind"

Although the plays "An Enemy of the People" and "Inherit the Wind" deal with what seem like black-and-white moral debates -- namely the contamination of a local water supply and the suppression of free speech -- the moral complexity of the heroes of these great dramas elevate the subject matter beyond a mere clash of good vs. evil. There are no real heroes and villains in either play, as even the best characters, like Henry Drummond and Dr. Stockmann have character flaws that come to light in the protagonists' pursuits of the truth.

Inherit the Wind" depicts the great legal giant Harry Drummond defending a teacher who has illegally taught evolution to his high school class. But Drummond admits that he even voted for his legal opponent when Matthew H. Brady ran for president and that he has some respect for his opposition as a man. But as an attorney, Drummond questions Brady unmercifully on the witness stand, because Drummond has an obligation to win his case. After the trial, he regrets the suffering he has put the opposing counsel through, and knows that he is responsible for Brady's collapse. Likewise, in "An Enemy of the People," although Dr. Stockmann is technically correct about the public health threat posed by the bacteria in the town's baths, he is so zealous in the pursuit of the truth he alienates, rather than persuades people of the rightness of his cause.

Dr. Stockmann lives entirely for the public good, which sounds like an admirable thing, and may be necessary to some degree so that uncomfortable societal truths can be brought to light. While "his opponents have constantly tried to manipulate him by reminding him of his responsibilities to his family" he is deaf to their entreaties (Moi, 2000). But this also strikes the viewer as unnaturally dispassionate. While this "unworldly enthusiast" and scientist possesses an "innocent energy, a joy of life, a relish of open fighting and a recklessness that makes him completely incapable of petty political calculation" these qualities make him "easy prey for the machinations of his powerful brother, Peter Stockmann, and for the scheming of the editor of the liberal paper" (Moi, 2000). They self-servingly make Stockmann seem insane in their public characterization of the scientist. Stockmann is so naive he cannot understand why others are not as eager to close down the infested baths, even though the existence of the baths prop up the local economy and draw in tourists. Taxpayers are unwilling to pay for the added expense -- but rather than be sympathetic to these concerns, anticipate the opposition arguments, and attempt to persuade the populace otherwise, Stockmann foolishly assumes with his scientific view of the world that right will make might, in a reversal of the old cliche that might makes right.

Stockman's daughter, who is not even involved in his crusade, loses her teaching job, and his sons are thrown out of school. Although he decides to create a school of his own, and his wife and family say they will support him, they essentially have no choice in the matter. Stockmann ends the play by saying: "the… READ MORE

How to Reference "Comparing 2 Plays" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Synge Two Plays by Term Paper

Synge

Two Plays by Synge

Throughout the course of his tragically short life, J.M. Synge wrote a number of plays attempting to capture both the poetic language and bucolic idealism… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2256 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA Topic: World History

---

Art of Comparison: Two Treatments of Judith Essay

Art of Comparison:

Two Treatments of Judith and Holofernes

Often, in the history of art, certain themes are portrayed again and again. Throughout much of Western History, religion provided a… read more

Essay 4 pages (1678 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Art / Painting / Sculpture

---

Compare Greek Plays Term Paper

Greek Plays

Phaedra" and "Hippolytus": A tragedy of desire or disrespect for the gods?

Compare and Contrast Euripides' "Hippolytus" and Racine's "Phaedra"

Although Racine's "Phaedra" takes the myth behind Euripides… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1441 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Compare 2 Plays Essay

Hamlet; Dr. Faustus

Most human beings consider themselves as moral according the norms and values of the societies and communities within which they live. Being moral, these human beings also… read more

Essay 4 pages (1338 words) Sources: 2 Style: APA Topic: Mythology / Folklore / Science Fiction

---

Irish Writings Identify, Then Compare and Contrast Essay

Irish Writings

Identify, then compare and contrast, the Irish nationalist ideal as manifested in the Irish Yankee and the Shaughraun. Be sure to be specific regarding each play's action, characters… read more

Essay 8 pages (2157 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Theatre / Opera / Play

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>