Term Paper on "Wendy Brown's Points About Toleration and Contrasting Them With Plato Locke Rousseau Mill or Marx"

Term Paper 4 pages (1341 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Wendy Brown's Perspective on Tolerance society defines itself by the accepted set of norms that it establishes to define itself. Those that lie outside of those "norms" are viewed differently than those the fit neatly within the constructs of the society. Tolerance is viewed as an acceptance, or desire to live in harmony with those that are different from ourselves. It is seen as the way to end violence and conflict in the world, bringing in a world of peace and harmony. However, as Wendy Brown points out, things are not always as they appear. Brown points out that "tolerance" has a dark side, which has emerged dramatically as a result of the "War on Terror." This analysis will support the thesis that Brown's work is biased by her own decidedly biased liberal viewpoints, rather than representing a comprehensive historical analysis of the development of tolerance as we know it today.

Tolerance According to Wendy Brown

According to Brown, disapproval and regulation are at the hear of tolerance, as defined by Western society. This definition of tolerance means not affirmation and acceptance of others that lie outside of societal norms, but to conditionally allow them. Tolerance as been touted as the better alternative to violence, but the War on Terror demonstrates that tolerance can be a means to justify violence. The War on Terrorism is underpinned by the differences between the "Civilized West" and "Barbaric Islam." Brown notes that tolerance, "reifies that which we do not like" (Brown, p. 47).

Browns' analysis of tolerance places it in a different light than that which has been presented to the public. Wendy Brown's view of tolerance highlights the norms, dominance of the powerful, and abjection of those that are tolerated. Those that are considered to be "intolerant" by Western standards are labeled as barbaric. Labeling of the intolerant as barbaric places them as a status that is less than civilized and is therefore used as justification for violence towards them. When viewed through Brown's eyes, it is difficult to view the War on Terror as anything more than imperialism, just one step short of colonialism. Brown states, "the native, the fanatic, the fundamentalist, and the bigot are what must be overcome by the society committed to tolerance" (Brown, p.184).

Brown demonstrates how the increase in 'tolerance talk' since the 1980s has been promoted by state, national, and nongovernmental bodies has become a form of regulatory practice. Practicing tolerance towards a cultural sub-group or minority has become a type of badge that proclaims one's credentials as a member of civilized society. Yet, one must maintain the group's separation and uniqueness. The differences remain, but it is virtuous and moral not to suppress them. Tolerance works in the private realm, but when the subject of tolerance moves into the political arena, it is transformed into intolerance.

Subjugation and Society

Plato believed that justice was the primary virtue upon which successful society is built. He further argued that justice is achieved by properly balancing wisdom, courage, and temperance. However, he did not feel that this balance was possible for the common person. This state of perfection could only be achieved by philosophers. Like Brown, Plato was never able to make his ideal society conform to what happens in real society and he died in prison as a result of his ideas, a victim of intolerance. Plato's, ideas disagree with Brown, but what happened in his real life, supports her vision of the evils of tolerance.

John Locke has been called the Father of classic liberalism. Liberalism advocates a system of government where citizens play a more active role in the political process. Locke sees tolerance for the beliefs of other as a necessity. Freedom of speech is a major precept of a successful society. Locke's position is that revolution against social order is an expression of he violence of the government in breach of its contract with the people (Keohane, p. 481). Locke and Brown would agree on several key points. Brown sees the government's… READ MORE

How to Reference "Wendy Brown's Points About Toleration and Contrasting Them With Plato Locke Rousseau Mill or Marx" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Marx and Rousseau on Property Marx Term Paper

Marx and Rousseau on Property

Marx, Rousseau, and the Question of Property

Of all the liberal philosophers of the modern era, the one closest in his views on the question… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2567 words) Sources: 8 Style: Harvard Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Locke "The Natural Liberty of Man Essay

Locke

"The Natural liberty of man is to be free from any superior power on earth, and not to be under the will or legislative authority of man, but to… read more

Essay 3 pages (1026 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics

---

John Brown's Raid in Harper Ferry Research Paper

John Brown's raid in Harper' Ferry

John Brown was the famous abolitionist who is often mentioned as the man who killed slavery, sparked civil war and seeded civil rights (Reynolds… read more

Research Paper 4 pages (1361 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: American History / United States

---

Dan Brown's the Davinci Code Term Paper

Dan Brown's "The DaVinci Code" did not violate the copyright and other rights of others in his story line regarding Jesus and Mary Magdalene. This is because it was a… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2208 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Plato and Aristotle Essay

Plato and Aristotle are arguably the two most important philosophers in Western history, because although they were not necessarily the earliest thinkers to consider questions of epistemology and ontology, they… read more

Essay 7 pages (2175 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>