Article Review on "Vocabulary Learning Methods With Beginning Learners"

Article Review 10 pages (2662 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Vocabulary Learning Methods With Beginning Learners of Spanish

This work intends to conduct a critical review of the work of Nuria Sagarra and Matthew Alba entitled: "The Key Is in the Keyword: L2 Vocabulary Learning Methods with Beginning Learners of Spanish" published in the Modern Language Journal in July, 2006.

Cognitive Models and Lexical Processing

The work of Sagarra and Alba (2006) entitled: "The Key Is in the Keyword: L2 Vocabulary Learning Methods with Beginning Learners of Spanish" reports a study which investigated three methods of learning vocabulary and their effectiveness among 778 students who were beginning second language (L2) learners. Sagarra and Alba (2006) state that "Cognitive models of lexical processing and storage have provided the impetus for developing a number of teaching methods that have sought to aid the retention of new words by increasing depth of processing." (p. 228)

Depth Processing

Sagarra and Alba explains that what is being referred to by 'depth of processing' is "the level at which stimuli are cognitively processed" and claim that the depth of processing can be enhanced "by increasing the processing of new words and facilitation their integration into the learner's previous knowledge." (2006, p. 228) Sagarra and Alba relate that in studies of first language (L1) and second language (L2) "vocabulary memorization strategies requiring deeper processing have been found the result in better retention of words than strategies involving shallower processing." (2006, p. 228) However, second language (L2) learners tend to "favor strategies that require minimum depth of processing, unless instructed otherwise." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 228) the reason for this preference is stated by Sagarra and Alba to be due to the limited capacity to process and store information that is incoming to the learner as well as the fact that "the acquisition of an L2 during adulthood imposes additional processing load on cognitive resources." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 228) Sagarra and Alba relate that a great deal of evidence has been building that affirms "infrequent spontaneous usage of more complex strategies such as imagery, inference, and the keyword method by less proficient L2 learners." (2007, p. 228)

III. Lexical Processing Enables Deeper Processing at Early Stages

Lexical processing has been found to enable the "deeper processing at early stages" by L2 learners. It is supported in research findings that the role played by instruction on L2 vocabulary acquisition indicates that "instruction channeling the resources available to learners yields better retention than unstructured learning...when learners use strategies of their own choice." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 228)

IV. Limitations in Previous Study Findings and Adjustments to Overcome Limitations

Sagarra and Alba state that there are "methodological pitfalls" that lead to questions concerning the reliability of the findings in previous studies and state that the study which they report has the objective of addressing those limitations through adoption of a "within-subject design with a large sample pool, and controlling the length, frequency, concreteness and imageability of the target words." (2006, p., 229) Stated as an addition in this study is a pretest, an immediate posttest, and a delayed posttest, and counterbalancing of the order that treatment and the posttests are presented and as well the pretest and posttest items within each treatment. It is held by Sagarra and Alba that "the findings of this empirical study" would assist in gaining a greater understanding of the L2 vocabulary learning methods effectiveness:

1) Rote memorization;

2) Semantic mapping; and 3) Keyword mnemonics. (2006, p. 229)

V. Rote Memorization, Semantic Mapping, and Keyword Mnemonics Explained

Sagarra and Alba state that the technique of 'rote memorization' is comprised by commitment to memory of the L1 to L2 world translation by rehearsal. Semantic mapping is comprised by "the creation of a diagram with L1 words semantically related to the new L2-word." (2006, p. 229) Lastly, the keyword method is comprised of an association of the L2-word with a L1 keyword that is "acoustically or orthographically similar, and then connecting the L1 keyword with the L1 translation of the L2-word." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 229)

VI. Associative Models

Sagarra and Alba state that "functional architectural-style models are based on dictionary-like mental lexicon containing information about various features of each word. However, associative models posit that words are stored in a network of items linked by sharing phonological, morphosyntactic, and semantic properties, and that the relative strength of any given item and its relationship to other items in the network are directly determined by the speaker's experience both using and perceiving the word." (2006, p. 229)

Associative models are held by Sagarra and Alba to, much like other interactionist models hold a view of the acquisition of language to be a "result of the continuous interaction between one's current level of cognitive functioning and the linguistic and nonlinguistic environment." (2006, p. 229) This acknowledged network of associative models has resulted in a growth of studies seeking to support vocabulary learning for second language (L2) students. Nearly all studies report that rote repetition in early stages of language and vocabulary acquisition results in shallower processing and less retention than do mnemonic and non-mnemonic techniques, which result in deeper processing. Stated as being the difference between techniques that are mnemonic and non-mnemonic is "whether novel words are integrated into previous knowledge through visual and verbal imagery (mnemonic) or through semantic properties (non-mnemonic)." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 229)

VII. Comparison of the Three Methods for Vocabulary Learning

Sagarra and Alba present as well as compare the three methods for learning vocabulary that have been stated including rote memorization, the keyword method and a non-mnemonic technique of semantic mapping. It is related that previous studies have attempted variations of the keyword method for the purpose of identifying the most effective application of this method. One group of studies made an examination of the impact of facilitation on keywords that were experimenter-provided vs. those that were learner-generated. Additionally, it is related that the experimenter-provided vs. learner-generated keywords links reported mixed results as well as did the use of written sentences vs. The use of mental imagery to link keywords to the L2-word. (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, paraphrased)

Other study findings have indicated that the keyword technique is effective and that this remains true under various situations. One example stated by Sagarra and Alba is that the keyword technique has yielded better L2 vocabulary learning in several languages to include Chinese, German, Hebrew, Navajo, Russian, Italian, Spanish, and Tagalog. (2006, p. 230) in addition, the keyword technique is a facilitator of L2 "lexical retention in children, elderly learners and students with various individual differences." (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 230) However, the effectiveness of the keyword technique is not applicable to all circumstances.

Sagarra and Alba relate that in the work of De Groot and Van Hell (2005) five factors are proposed that serve to reduce the benefits of the keyword technique on L2 vocabulary learning. Those five factors are stated to include the following:

1) Keyword learners are outperformed by rote learners 'when there is no immediate test' which indicates that the 'long-term benefits of the keyword' technique that are stated in some studies might be because of the effect of the immediate test which serves as an additional learning practice. Furthermore the knowledge of other foreign languages might explain why the keyword technique results in lasting effects of memorization in that the work of Beaton et al. (1995) states findings that "a keyword learner who spoke various languages was able to recall 35% of L2 Italian words 10 years after exposure to the target language;

2) the second keyword restraint identified is that the keyword technique has not been found to be effective in teaching cognates and that simpler word or picture association has been found to be more effective and as well the keyword technique is not effective in teaching abstract words;

3) Third, the keyword technique makes word retrieval slower since recall 'takes place through the keyword; and 4) the keyword technique is inefficient for 'productive recalls'. (Sagarra and Alba, 2006, p. 230)

The keyword technique is stated by Sagarra and Alba (2006) to have been found effective for: (1) the more advanced learner; and (2) the elementary learner. (p. 230) However, the opposite is stated to be true for the use of rote memorization. There is a final limitation noted by Sagarra and Alba for use of the keyword technique and specifically is that "the beneficial effects of this method decrease with target words involving low levels of concreteness and imageability." (2006, p. 230) the keyword technique of learning furthermore serves to enhance "phonological similarities between L1 and the L2" which results in L1 pronunciation patterns being incorrect in the L2. Sagarra and Alba state that finally, the variable results from tests that are delayed should be noted in the keyword technique of vocabulary and language learning. In summary the findings of the studies reported by Sagarra and Alba indicate that keyword learners "outperform rote memorization learners on receptive recalls at… READ MORE

How to Reference "Vocabulary Learning Methods With Beginning Learners" Article Review in a Bibliography

Related Article Reviews:

Language Teaching and Learning Methods Essay

Language Teaching and Learning Methods: Focus on the Natural Approach of Teaching and Learning English as a Foreign Language

One of the oldest and most widely-cited beliefs involving learning as… read more

Essay 10 pages (3071 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Learning Theories in 2009-2010 Term Paper

Learning Theories

Jones, Wendell

By the end of the 19th and turn of the 20th century, researchers became fascinated by the differences in learning styles and concepts. This was perhaps… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2808 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Learning Tasks Term Paper

Learning Tasks

There is a lack of information regarding the preparedness of adult English language learners. The population of adult immigrants, refugees, migrant workers, and naturalized citizens studying nonacademic English… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1950 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Second Language Learning Motivations of Non-Heritage Chinese Research Proposal

Second Language Learning Motivations of Non-Heritage Chinese Learners in University Credit Courses

The 21st century has been dubbed the "Century of Asia" with China leading the way. Moreover, the number… read more

Research Proposal 24 pages (9074 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Foreign Language Teaching Methods Term Paper

Foreign Language Teaching Methods

Globalization and the concept of the "global village," has brought about interesting developments in language teaching. It is currently recognized, for example, that contact with one… read more

Term Paper 9 pages (2812 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: Language / Linguistics

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>