Term Paper on "Values Influence Decision-making. While No Decision-Making Method"

Term Paper 4 pages (1422 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

values influence decision-making. While no decision-making method is perfectly rational, perhaps weighted decision matrices come the closest to identifying optimal choices. However, even these are subject to influence by values at various levels, as the weights assigned to ranking criteria depend upon who is assigning the weights, his or her cultural background, and the sum total of their distilled experiences. For an interesting discussion upon how ranking criteria can be weighted differently depending upon the "ranker," please see Price-Bonham (1976).

In my experience dealing with businesses in multiple countries, I have often observed that the companies in a given country will have some shared values that are absent from companies in different countries. If the values shared by firms in one country are the same within that country, but differ among firms across countries, then perhaps an argument could be made that the differences have their roots at a deeper level; perhaps at the cultural level. Further, since no values are intrinsic, but learned, and since none of these can be learned outside of culture, it stands to reason that personal values also have their roots in cultural values.

In effect, I am saying that the concept of "values" is one that, at the very least, is highly multidimensional, and it is uncertain whether the effects upon decision-making by cultural, corporate, and personal values can be meaningfully disentangled. My position, therefore, is that all values are ultimately reducible to cultural ones, and that culture is the main driver producing variance in decision making across professional and personal levels. Given prior research on the differences among cultures, this should come as no great surprise; consider Barker and Cobb (2000) and Hofstede and McCrae (2004).

For instance, when a person is expected to behave in a way that is contrary to his or her personal values, cognitive dissonance is the inevitable result. But these personal values are perhaps very largely, if not entirely, influenced by the values held at large by the culture into which the person was born. The degree to which personal values are at variance with cultural values is the degree to which an individual's personal experiences have positively or negatively reinforced cultural messages regarding its values.

If the culture sends a message that working hard is a good way to get ahead in life, then the culture values hard work. Yet, if a person thus acculturated works hard but is consistently passed over for promotion in favor of peers or subordinates who are not as hard working, a form of cognitive dissonance emerges that negatively reinforces the cultural message about hard work. The individual's values will necessarily change; he or she may no longer value hard work and may learn to value "taking it easy." Thus, cultural and personal values interact within the mind of the individual.

One clear, to me, example of how entangled values are across these three areas is in the Chinese concept of mianzi (Gries, 1999). This translates loosely as "face" and it is essentially the same "face" that one thinks of in the phrase, "to lose face." While this concept has some similar concepts in the West, such as self-image, self-respect, and esteem, none of these correspond 100% with "face" in the Eastern sense, nor do they have precisely the same effect on behavior. They do influence behavior, but not in the same way.

For instance, in the West, candor is a valued attribute and practice in business relations. One could say that American businesses value personal opinions and expect positive criticism when it is invoked. To paraphrase Frank Zappa, the trend-setting musician and pop-culture icon: progress requires deviation. This is a very Western point-of-view.

I am not saying it is not the right point-of-view, nor that it is not a good one, but that it is not a point-of-view that is embraced in Eastern Civilization, certainly not in China. I am reminded of something one of my professors once said to a class about the difference between Western and Eastern business practices, "In the United States, the squeaky wheel gets the oil, but in Japan, the nail that sticks out gets hammered back in."

Face" has as much to do with one's own self-esteem as it does with the self-esteem of… READ MORE

How to Reference "Values Influence Decision-making. While No Decision-Making Method" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Applied Management and Decision Sciences Thesis

management and decision sciences from various theorists; and, analyzes the evolution of managerial decision making from scientific management to the complicated forecasting models used today. The objectives of the Breadth… read more

Thesis 90 pages (25680 words) Sources: 40 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Decision Whether to Internationalize Research Paper

Decision Whether to Internationalize or Not?

Companies competing in the oil and gas extraction industry are faced with some unique challenges and opportunities as the demand for energy increases and… read more

Research Paper 22 pages (6941 words) Sources: 30 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Decision-Making: What Are the Newest Concepts Utilized Thesis

Decision-making: What are the newest concepts utilized in decision-Making? What are the most applicable concepts?

The most common form of traditional decision-making analysis is a 'rational actor' model. In this… read more

Thesis 2 pages (689 words) Sources: 1+ Style: APA Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Ethical Influence on Consumer Behavior Research Paper

Ethical Situations That Influence Consumer Behavior

Counterfeiting expensive merchandise and making it available at significantly lower prices without regard for the legal or ethical implications of this practice cost the… read more

Research Paper 6 pages (2334 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Copyright / Trademark / Patent

---

Inventory Management a in an Importer Industry Case Study

Inventory Management

The raw materials, goods in process, and finished products represent different forms of inventory. Every stage of production of commodity represents money tied up until the inventory finds… read more

Case Study 40 pages (12443 words) Sources: 40 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>