Essay on "Cherokee Removal"

Essay 3 pages (1080 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

urging of President Andrew Jackson to Congress, he advocated that the Cherokees should be driven to lands west of the Mississippi because of two reasons:

The objectives of "civilizing" the tribes and driving them west contradicted each other.

Constitution did not provide the Federal government with the right to dismember an already existing state and to recognize a sovereign state within their boundaries without the consent of their legislature.

Jackson saw himself in a paternalistic role and the Cherokees and other Native American tribes as children that needed guidance in how to properly manage their affairs. By exiling the tribes to the lands over the Mississippi River, they would be free from the depredations of whites and would then be able to develop into an "interesting commonwealth." In other words, they would then resolve the contradiction that whites had forced on them between trying to assimilate and the continual pressure to move west and out of the way of white settlers. At this early time in American History, no one in the American government or intelligentsia foresaw the time when the "Great American Desert" west of the Mississippi would become attractive to white settlers as well (Erbach, "The Cherokee Removal Group a Readings").

Certainly this picture of "Old Hickory" does not square well with the much celebrated rise of Jacksonian Democracy that the Jackson administration supposedly ushered in with the presidential election of 1828. What does become apparent is that this commonwealth was available for white males only. Native Americans need not apply and needed to be moved out of the center of it with all possible speed.

Senator Peleg Sprague calls upon the United States government to honor their treaties (some 15 between 1783 and 1819) with the Cherokees. The fact that there have been 15 separate treaties would seem that the Federal Government and the American people it represents did not take their treaty obligations seriously to begin with (Erbach, "The Cherokee Removal Group B. Readings"). With any other nation that had overwhelming military power and was not in a continually weakening state, America would have been more meticulous in the observance of a treaty. The fact that it was with a Native American tribe that was sitting upon valuable land in the South sealed the fate of the Cherokees who were to be shipped to the far West with impunity. As the Senator pointed out, they were highly cultured and civilized by White and Indian standards. In fact, they were developing at an amazing and rapid pace. They were expected by Whites to go over the Mississippi to a strange land amongst hostile people and somehow miraculously survive. Certainly, this is why over 4,000 out of 15,000 of the Cherokees died on the way west to the territory that is now present day Oklahoma ("Historical Documents: The Trail of Tears").

The report from the Committee of Indian Affairs on the Removal of Indians delivered to the House of Representatives on February 24, 1830 states that "in the opinion of many of our statesmen, most distinguished for their justice and benevolence, as well as by their talents and experience, promised to increase their happiness, and to afford the best prospect of perpetuating their race ("Andrew Jackson… READ MORE

How to Reference "Cherokee Removal" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Cherokee Removal Book Report

Cherokee Removal

The "Trail of Tears": Historical Background

In the spring of 1838, U.S. troops began to round up people of the Cherokee nation and imprison them for eventual removal… read more

Book Report 4 pages (1230 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Native American Indians

---

Removal of the Cherokee Term Paper

Removal of the Cherokee

The book, The Cherokee Removal, is about savagery and civilization. The Cherokee made poor use of their homelands. White Americans had a higher use for the… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1430 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Native American Indians

---

Cherokees Sir Alexander Cuming 1730 Term Paper

Cherokees Sir Alexander Cuming 1730

The character of Sir Alexander Cuming is draped in mystery and legend. Respected and even loved by the Cherokees, marginalized by his own aristocratic English… read more

Term Paper 9 pages (2771 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Native American Indians

---

Historiography of the Native American Removal Term Paper

removal of the Native Americans from the United States of America. In the year 1830, Five Civilized Tribes which included the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Seminole, Choctaw and Creek were still residing… read more

Term Paper 11 pages (3097 words) Sources: 11 Topic: Native American Indians

---

Cherokee the Impact of Intolerance of Tribal Term Paper

Cherokee

The impact of Intolerance of tribal religion on the Cherokee over the last 150 years

The Cherokee are one of the largest North American indigenous tribes. They are linked… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1417 words) Sources: 6 Style: MLA Topic: Native American Indians

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>