Term Paper on "United States Government Should Grant Conditional Amnesty"

Term Paper 10 pages (3332 words) Sources: 10

[EXCERPT] . . . .

United States Government should grant conditional amnesty -- and offer a path to citizenship -- to undocumented students living in the U.S. that have finished high school and qualify under "The Dream Act" legislation. This paper presents solid arguments as to why the U.S. Congress should the pass legislation known as "The Dream Act" -- technically called "The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act" -- and reasons why The Dream Act did pass the House of Representatives but did not pass muster with the U.S. Senate in 2010.

Why is There an Immigration Crisis? Brief Background

It is widely known that the United States is facing a serious crisis with reference to the estimated 12 million undocumented immigrants that are living and working in the U.S.; the crisis includes an unknown number of undocumented immigrants that are coming across the U.S. / Mexican border every day. The flood of immigrants -- and the social, economic and political problems those immigrants have created -- real or imagined -- has resulted in some hard-line anti-immigration legislation in several states, including Arizona and Florida.

In Arizona, for example, Governor Jan Brewer signed into law a tough piece of legislation (SB 1070) in 2010 that: a) allows law enforcement officials to question a person's immigration status "if there is a reasonable suspicion they're in the country illegally" (Associated Press); b) would make it "a state criminal offense for an illegal immigrant to seek work or hold a job" (AP); c) allows police to "arrest suspected illegal immigrants without a warrant"; and d) makes it a criminal offense for an undocumented immigrant to be in Arizona without proper immigration paperwork (AP).

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has blocked portions of that law and the United States Justice Department has sued the state of Arizona asserting that a state cannot pass legislation with reference to immigration because immigration issues come under federal jurisdiction. Governor Brewer has responded to the federal appeals court "stay" on SB 1070 with this comment: "I remain steadfast in my belief that Arizona and other states have a sovereign right and obligation to protect their citizens and enforce immigration law in accordance with federal statute" (AP).

Moreover, the Republican Party has taken an extremely hard-line stance on immigration, far more drastic than independents and Democrats have taken. For example, in 2010 "…all seven Republican senators on the Judiciary Committee… asked [the Homeland Security Department] how much money it needed to depart every illegal immigrant the government encountered" (Bennett, 2011, p. 1). One estimate by the Center for American Progress showed it would cost American taxpayers "$206 billion over five years to deport the estimated 11 million people living in the country illegally" (Bennett, p. 1). In 2006, Republicans in the House of Representatives rallied around a bill written by Congressman James Sensenbrenner (R-WI) that would have made being in the U.S. without proper papers a felony. It would have imposed "criminal penalties for those aiding illegal immigrants [hiring or providing shelter]" and further would call for construction of a 700-mile-long fence along the U.S. -- Mexico border…" (Media Matters, 2006, p. 1).

These sources point up the frustration of some American lawmakers when it comes to the need for immigration reform. In short, there is a need to act, and notwithstanding the urgent need to act, the U.S. should proceed with civility and dignity when it comes to immigration reform. The most promising and humane proposal that would allow some undocumented immigrants to remain in the U.S. And pursue their futures legally is the Dream Act.

The Dream Act -- what is it?

Meanwhile, the Immigration Policy Center explains that The Dream Act would help approximately 1.9 million young undocumented immigrants that are part of the American culture, have grown up in the U.S., and have graduated from high school. It would allow them to have "a pathway to U.S. citizenship through college or the armed services" (Immigration Policy Center / IPC, 2010, p. 1). The Dream Act offers hope and a future in America for "undocumented children belonging to the 1.5 generation," Professor Roberto Gonzalez of the University of Washington explains in the IPC fact sheet. Many of the 65,000 undocumented students that graduate from high school each year want to attend college, join the military, get a good job "or otherwise pursue their dreams," Gonzalez explains. But they cannot do those things because they are undocumented.

Many of these students have "high aspirations, yet live on the margins" according to Gonzalez. In addition then cannot get a driver's license, they cannot vote or work, in many cases. This is a highly frustrating situation for young people who have lived their whole lives (or most of their lives) in the United States, they are fluent in English, they understand American laws and cultural values in most cases and they want a future in the United States.

In June, 2010, an undocumented student (who had enrolled at Harvard University in spite of her lack of citizenship) was put on detention by immigration officials. Harvard University President Drew Faust was quoted saying the Dream Act could serve as a "lifeline to these students who are already working hard in our middle and high schools and living in our communities by granting them the temporary legal status that would allow them to pursue postsecondary education" (IPC, p. 2).

What would the Dream Act do for undocumented immigrant youth?

The Dream Act was introduced by U.S. Senators Richard Durbin (D-IL) and Richard Lugar (R-IN) and Representatives Howard Berman (D-CA), Lincoln Diaz-Balart (R-FL), and Lucille Roybal-Allard (D-CA) in 1009, the IPC reports. In the Senate it is S. 729, and in the House it is H.R. 1751. It would do several important things for young Latinos living in the U.S. without citizenship status. Initially, it would make a young undocumented immigrant eligible to achieve a "lawful permanent resident" (LPR) status, providing he or she has been in the country for at least five years and providing that individual was "younger than 16 when they first entered the country" (IPC, p. 2).

The LPR status would be granted (on a conditional basis) to the young person for up to six years, "during which time the student would be allowed to work, go to school, or join the military," the IPC explains. Also, after six years, the "conditional" status would be taken away provided the person would have "either completed two years in a program for a bachelor's degree or higher degree or has served in the armed services for at least two years, and if discharged, has received an honorable discharge" (IPC, p. 2). For those politicians that don't want to see taxpayer money used to help the youths that have achieved LPR status, the legislation includes a provision that Dream Act students would not eligible for federal education grants, the IPC notes.

Who would be benefiting from the Dream Act?

The IPC estimates that (as mentioned earlier) about 1.9 million undocumented children and young adults would be eligible to benefit from the Dream Act. These young people have dreams of becoming doctors, nurses, teachers and entrepreneurs, the IPC continues. The Dream Act would give them the opportunity to fully explore their potential; in fact there are today 78,000 potential beneficiaries "with at least an associate's degree" who would be eligible for conditional LPR status (some community colleges allow undocumented immigrants to attend), according to the IPC. Also today the IPC estimates there are 541,000 "potential beneficiaries" who would be "immediately eligible for conditional LPR status" since they have already achieved a high school diploma (or a GED). Those 541,000 young people with high school behind them would likely "…have the incentive to complete two years of college or two years of military service to be eligible for permanent status" (IPC).

Meantime there are 934,000 children under the age of 18 who would be eligible for "conditional LPR status in the future, which would provide them with incentives to finish high school and pursue a post-secondary education or join the military," the IPC continues. And there are approximately 421,000 potential beneficiaries who could be eligible for conditional LPR status in the future "if they obtain a GED" (IPC).

California currently has the most Dream-Act-eligible immigrants (26% of the national total live in California); Texas is next with 12% of the national total, followed by Florida (9%), New York (7%), Arizona (5%), Illinois (4%), New Jersey (4%), Georgia (3%), North Carolina (2%), and Colorado (2%).

What are the economic benefits of the Dream Act?

Because the Dream Act would give the students who participate "greater educational opportunities and better jobs" that means more taxable income coming into the IRS coffers in Washington, D.C. (IPC). A study was done by the North American Integration and Development Center -- on the University of California at Los Angeles campus -- that shows an estimate of the potential total earnings of Dream Act beneficiaries. "Over the… READ MORE

How to Reference "United States Government Should Grant Conditional Amnesty" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

United States Government Is a Republic Term Paper

United States Government is a Republic, formed on democratic principles. This means that the United States operates under a system of democracy that is "for the people, by the people."… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (717 words) Sources: 1 Style: APA Topic: American History / United States

---

United States Investing Too Much in WMD A2 Coursework

United States investing too much in WMD protection

Is the United States investing too much time and money in WMD protection?

America has made massive investments of their resources towards… read more

A2 Coursework 4 pages (1551 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

United States Engaged in a World Term Paper

United States engaged in a world wide war against terrorism in the wake of September 11th, it is believed that we have become much more isolationist in our economic and… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3295 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: American History / United States

---

American Government Should the President Research Paper

American Government

Should the President of the United States have authority to remove officials that the U.S. Senate has confirmed?

A bit of government history is needed here to make… read more

Research Paper 3 pages (1099 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics

---

Democracy the United States' Support Term Paper

Democracy

The United States' support for the promotion of democracy not only in the U.S. But in other countries as well is not new. Some of those who have strongly… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1825 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Government / Politics

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>