Term Paper on "Effect of Unionization on the National Basketball Association NBA"
Term Paper 7 pages (2516 words) Sources: 6
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Unionization on the NBANBA unionization
Last year, the National Basketball Association (NBA), its players and the owners of the 30 teams that employ those players engaged in the second-longest labor dispute in NBA history, resulting in a lockout and two lawsuits that delayed the season by sixteen games, which itself cost both sides regardless of the outcome of the disputed contractual negotiations. Although the players agreed to salary, earnings and contractual concessions, their union held out over free-agency rules and ultimately prevailed by decertifying their bargaining unit, which forced the dispute from the jurisdiction of labor law into anti-trust regulation. This review describes the situation and then analyzes the potential ramifications of unionization on the NBA, on which the court issued no new decision since both parties withdrew their suits after overcoming impasse. For the purpose of this discussion, the National Basketball Association or "NBA," refers to the league itself, and analysis of the effects of unionization on the players and privately-owned teams who employ them would take different focus. Although the entire professional basketball system is often referred to as the NBA in general, here these other two groups will be designated the players and the teams who employ them, and reference to the NBA designates the league that regulates and organizes the teams for which the players work.
Description
The League represents the owners of 30 professional basketball teams, setting rules that apply to roughly around 450 players of varying levels of expertise and experience. These players and the league have a histo
download full paper ⤓
The ultimate result was a new contractual agreement (which both sides have the option of canceling early after six years) after the players forced the NBA to return to the bargaining table using a negotiating tactic that required they disband their union. By decertifying their union, imposing free agency across the league for all players, the various teams of the League could no longer agree on or even discuss terms of employment without breaking federal antitrust law, where previously federal labor law had applied as long as the players chose to bargain as a unified group represented by the players' union. This difference underlies any discussion of the results of unionization on the NBA, and resulted in the League or NBA returning to the table and relinquishing the last of demands the players found important enough to reject (Beck, 2011).
Analysis
Professional sports has unique characteristics compared to other industries like say manufacturing or health services, in a general sense because there are few markets outside the League for players' skills, and because owners must collaborate to a meaningfully higher degree that in a different industry would achieve illegal market power prohibited by anti-trust law (Feldman, 2012, p.1233-34). Section I of the Sherman Act prohibits competitors from collaborating in order to achieve reduced competition that undermines consumer choice or provision of labor in the marketplace (Feldman, 2012, p.1227). Increased competition between producers is allegedly in the consumers' best interest because reduced competition leads to cartelization by a group of 'oligopolistic' producers acting together to artificially inflate prices (Feldman, 2012, p.1236-7). Such 'antitrust' cases are indeed prosecuted against producers by U.S. courts most every year (U.S. Department of Justice, 2012, n.p.), which indicates the strong incentive producers have to reduce competition between them such that the results is a cartel, or 'oligopoly.' In such cases, the courts step in effectively to represent the consumers against the producers, on the rationale that the consumers are the government's constituents, and competition between producers encourages efficiency and lower prices for consumers and is therefore in the public interest. Since no individual consumer can achieve market power over the producers, the government represents all consumers. Therefore such producer collaboration is prohibited under the Sherman Act if the result reduces competition, under a thread of consumer and worker protection law with specific precedents designated under the heading 'anti-trust'.
Once a group of workers votes to negotiate contractual terms of employment as a group, entirely the choice of the employees (Feldman, 2012, p. 1254), the result is a labor union, and the employment situation falls under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) and Labor-Management Relations Act (LMRA). The difference is critical, because as long as the players elect to negotiate as a group with the teams that pay them, the terms and conditions are regulated under NLRA, but the very moment the players elect to dissolve their union and negotiate conditions individually, then any collaboration between owners becomes viewed by the courts as cartelization in the process of selling the series of games that as a whole constitutes the annual professional basketball season, including the peripheral income derived from those games that often ends up larger than the direct ticket sales (Brandt, 2011, n.p.). Once the players elect to dissolve the union, the Sherman Act applies instead of the NLRA, which in 2011 forced the NBA to consider whether the teams wanted to compete against each other hiring all player-employees individually as free agents. Absent the players' union, such owner collaboration would incur "treble damages" under the Sherman Act (Feldman, 2012, p. 1239) on grounds such collusion would result in deliberate reduction of competition between employers.
The League tried to argue that the whole intent of the Sherman Act is limited to consumer protection, but the Supreme Court has ruled anti-trust protection also applies to competition in labor markets (Feldman, 2012, p. 1274), so the risk for the owners arose from whether the Courts would find a link between owner collaboration and market power that harmed consumers or gained leverage over potential employees. If dealing with all players as free agents created an auction where owners had to bid up compensation attempting to capture talent, the result could mean higher cost for the team and thus lower revenue absent increased ticket prices or other revenue. Since there is no other market for consumers to purchase professional basketball of the essentially similar quality of the NBA, the increased prices would reduce consumer access if the result was increased revenue for the League, achieved through collaboration. The League was apparently losing some $300 million per year, which indicates increased cost would have to be offset by increased revenue either through ticket prices or other income, including BRI. If the owners attempted to collaborate in any way to restrict the players' power to demand higher compensation (direct pay or noneconomic concessions), say through salary caps, and the courts could discover such agreement, the steep fines in addition to any increased pay the players could achieve, would require increasing revenue so high that many consumers would eventually forego tickets or merchandise, broadcasters would abandon licensing agreements, and these effects would ripple out through "any revenue-generating activity -- from selling tickets to hot dogs to television rights to video games" (Brandt, 2011, n.p.).
The players have in the past negotiated the greater share of BRI revenue, but conceded that excess to the League down to a 50/50 split before the 2011 lockout. The cost of achieving that revenue is borne entirely by the League, however (Brandt, 2011); therefore increasing the total cost for a league that is already losing money and thus has no room to take profit reductions, would result in passing that cost on to consumers where players had the ability to negotiate compensation increases under total free agency across the league. These pay increases would affect different teams to varying degree depending on their profitability, and the result would be concentration of talent into the richest, dominant teams, reducing competitiveness for consumers alongside ticket and peripheral price increases for teams with the narrowest profit margins.… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Effect of Unionization on the National Basketball Association NBA" Assignment:
Introduction
Describe
Analysis
Conclusion
How to Reference "Effect of Unionization on the National Basketball Association NBA" Term Paper in a Bibliography
“Effect of Unionization on the National Basketball Association NBA.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2012, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/unionization-nba/6508409. Accessed 5 Oct 2024.
Related Term Papers:
Entertainment and Art Book Report
National Basketball Association
Marketing in the Arts and Entertainment Industry
A Branding Analysis of the National Basketball Association
The National Basketball Association (NBA) continues to define best practices in the… read more
Book Report 8 pages (3129 words) Sources: 15 Style: APA Topic: Advertising / Marketing / Sales
National Security the Office of the Director Term Paper
National Security
The Office of the Director of National Intelligence works at the top level of the U.S. Intelligence Community. DNI is the personal presidential advisor. It also offers advice… read more
Term Paper 9 pages (2833 words) Sources: 9 Topic: Management / Organizations
Sociology in Basketball Term Paper
Sociology in Basketball
This informative and analytical of sociology is presenting various facts on sociology of basketball. Therefore, a descriptive history of basketball along with historical ups and downs and… read more
Term Paper 8 pages (2312 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Sports / Exercise / Fitness
Prep-To-Pro' NBA Draft According to Brian Hindo Essay
prep-to-pro' NBA draft
According to Brian Hindo's essay entitled "The NBA's Youth Squad," the drafting of high school age athletes by the National Basketball Association may be rapidly coming to… read more
Essay 3 pages (1046 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Sports / Exercise / Fitness
Concept of National Cinema Literature Review
National Cinema
The cinema and film is an art form that has existed since the first silent films saw the light. Today's manifestation of this type of entertainment takes many… read more
Literature Review 20 pages (6599 words) Sources: 15 Topic: Film / Movies / Television
Sat, Oct 5, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!