Essay on "Role of Human Resource Management in the Hotel Industry"

Essay 11 pages (3672 words) Sources: 11 Style: Harvard

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Training and Retaining Quality Employees for the Hospitality Industry

There are very few duties and responsibilities that a human relations manager is accountable for that are more critical to the success of his or her venue than selecting high quality people for employment. How to accomplish that delicate, pivotal task is the point of this research paper. The purpose of this research is to critically evaluate the way in which human relations departments (and managers) in the hospitality business go about the process of hiring and retaining competent, creative talent. What are their selected strategies? What innovations and creative tactics are employed? Which strategy works the best and how do human relations managers craft systems that reduce the level of talent turnover in the hospitality business? These questions and issues will be reviewed and critiqued in this paper.

The Literature -- The Hiring Process

In Mary Tanke's book (Human Resources Management for the Hospitality Industry) the author advises future human resource managers that "due to the very high turnover ratios" in the hospitality industry, screening applicants correctly has taken on "a new importance" (Tanke, 2000, p. 119). Tanke, who is associate professor of Human Resources (HR) Management in the School of Hospitality Management at Florida International University, insists that many hospitality employees that quit or were fired "should never have been hired in the first place" (119). Tanke makes that assertion because she believes "…poor selection methods are a major factor" in the high turnover among hospitality employees; a person is only an asset for a company if and when that individual performs his or her job "efficiently and in accordance with job standards" (120).

Part of any good selection process should include a carefully constructed employment application. This sounds simple and appears to be a no-brainer on first review; but Tanke insists that the application should be designed so "that only information pertinent to that particular job is obtained" (120). Many job applications have the same ubiquitous questions and fill-in-the-blanks sections, and are not job-specific, but Tanke objects to those kinds of applications. In order to be certain the application is not only job-specific but that it also follows all aspects of employment law, the author suggests that the HR department should, at all times, have an "open channel" of communication with the operations division of the hospitality company in question.

Key questions that should be on the application form in a hospitality environment include asking if the candidate will be available to work nights, weekends, or holidays. Also, the HR person that is well-prepared has spent time developing structured, pertinent questions to ask the candidate once the HR person has reviewed the application and has decided that this candidate has appropriate skills and experience to take the time for an interview. On page 135 Tanke insists that getting the candidate comfortable for the interview is important, since "a nervous applicant is not going to interview well"; hence, the HR person should institute practices that are designed to break the ice, so to speak.

This part of Tanke's presentation is absolutely vital and should be implemented by any competent hospitality industry human relations department. She offers interview icebreakers ("I see you're from New York originally. How do you like living in Florida?" And "Did you have any trouble getting here today?") and she quotes "industry expert" Bob Morrison on how the HR interviewer should behave as the candidate is initially brought into the interview room:

"I am a big fan of welcoming the job applicant to your place of business.

Thank them for coming in to interview with you. Thank them for their time. Begin the interview process in a positive way the minute they walk in the door. There are other hospitality companies with the same job openings you have. The way the job applicants are treated during the interview process could make all the difference in having them decide to work for you and not your competitor" (Tanke, 135).

A competently constructed employee application form -- and ice-breaking interview strategies -- are but two of the many tools that Tanke discusses in her book. She emphasizes how important it is for HR personnel to fully understand and comply with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (age discrimination law), with the Americans with Disabilities Act, with laws that protect veterans (the Veterans Readjustment Assistance Act of 1974 and the veterans Reemployment Rights Act of 1994), and with other legislation related to hiring.

Another legal issue -- pointed out by authors David Hayes and Jack Ninemeier -- deals with undocumented workers in the United States. This is not just a problem for HR people in the hospitality industry, it is pervasive in the economy per se, and it is also a volatile political issue in the country. Sparks and accusations fly every time it is suggested that a hotel has hired "illegal aliens" (the most mean-spirited of definitions). Under current federal law, the fines for "knowingly employing undocumented workers can be severe" (Hayes, et al., 2008, p. 102). The Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) requires, through the Justice Department's federal laws, that HR managers "… verify the authenticity of identification" shown them by prospective employees (102).

The information found in the previous paragraph is vitally important to HR departments because, as Hayes reports on page 102 -- and as has been obvious to travelers and hotel guests for many years in the United States -- "…immigrants make up a very large portion of the hospitality industry workforce." If the employees are not legal, and the INS makes an arrest in a hotel or restaurant environment, it gets into the newspapers and the hotel has a public relations disaster to contend with -- not to mention the hotel has a stiff fine to pay in the aftermath. Such an arrest also leads to a certain level of suspicion (and even paranoia) among the legal immigrants also working at that venue.

Hayes also offers a candid and innovative suggestion for the strategy to be used in the selection of a candidate applying for any of the following positions: "servers, dishwashers, kitchen cleaners, counter workers, food preparation specialists, cashiers, housekeepers, and front desk staff" (103). Hayes asserts that it is "common" and "even necessary" to hire workers who "do not come to the operation with readily applicable job skills" (103). This may sound like heresy, and it may go against the grain of old-school human relations departments' strategies, but Hayes as a cogent point when he insists that what the interviewer is really looking for is not a wealth of experience but "a sincere commitment to serve guests, a willingness to learn, and the work ethic" that this particular hospitality venue deems to be vital.

Hence, Hayes continues, the hospitality manager should be looking for an individual whose characteristics lead a seasoned manager to believe he or she will be "an excellent addition to the staff" -- notwithstanding a dearth of dishwashing skills, or maid-related experience (103). This also implies that the hospitality venue has adequate training tactics, in order to take a very enthusiastic, honest, intelligent new hire and train that person to be a cashier the way that particular company wants cashiers to be trained. It can be an advantage to have a talented person with no experience on the payroll because then the hotel can train that person fresh from the start, instituting the values and fundamental work-related specifics of that particular venue. To wit, a person who has worked for seven years as a cashier elsewhere, may bring some bad habits with her or him, or may not adjust to that hotel's style as fully as need be.

The Literature -- The Turnover Rate in Hospitality Venues

"…The planning of more informed strategic HRM approaches has potential to not only increase the effectiveness of the employee and employer relationship, but also recognize the welfare of employees is fundamental in the achievement of organisational objectives [in the management practices of hospitality providers on Phillip Island Victoria]" (Townsend, 2010).

Author Peter Harris reports that the turnover rate in hotels averages about "33% per annum, or one-third of the total workforce" (Harris, 1998, p. 72). Albeit his book is about 13 years old, Harris writes that the turnover in the hospitality industry is the highest of any industry. The research into this issue has not, as of the time Harris's book was published, determined as to whether or not high turnover in hotels is a good thing or a problem. Some argue that high turnover rates are "detrimental to the organization" because they can "adversely affect the quality of products and services" in the organization, Harris explains (72). Constantly training new staff as veteran staff members move on to other jobs can "induce dysfunctional behaviour amongst remaining employees," Harris continues. And this problem is laid in the hands of the HR manager, Harris explains; in other words, if a better job had been done vis-a-vis the hiring practices, the people… READ MORE

How to Reference "Role of Human Resource Management in the Hotel Industry" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Human Resources Is Organizational Behavior Term Paper

Human Resources and Organizational behavior in Shopping Mall organizations (METRO Cash and Carry)

Organization is a social place working for the productivity and prosperity of mutual goals and aims. Shopping… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3151 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Management Development Process Has Been Adopted Term Paper

management development process has been adopted in the public and private sectors for the enhancement and development of the new managers and professionals. The enhancement program was adopted and implemented… read more

Term Paper 16 pages (4207 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Role That the HR Department Is Playing Term Paper

role that the HR department is playing now in the process of organizational strategic planning is generally due to the contemporaneous approach to the human resource. For centuries, organizations have… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3227 words) Sources: 1 Style: APA Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

Human Resources Information System Thesis

Human Resources Information System

The situation that Jay Morgan faces as the manager of a series of geographically dispersed locations throughout the Detroit area is one of the factors that… read more

Thesis 3 pages (1073 words) Sources: 2 Style: APA Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Human Resources Role Behind Five Stars Hotels Service Quality Term Paper

Electronically

Business research methods

Faculty:

E.Schofield

BENVENGA JEAN-PIERRE

IRS Final Proposal

Statement of Authorship

'I certify that this assignment is my own work and contains no material which has been… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (3062 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>