Term Paper on "Scar of War"

Term Paper 8 pages (2992 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien [...]'s antiwar position and how this position relates to the era of unrest in the United States over the Vietnam War. The era of the Vietnam War was a difficult time in American history. Many Americans were against the war, and vocally protested our involvement in Southeast Asia. This book is a reflection of that unrest. The young men O'Brien portrays in his novel are just boys, really, and they show the horrors and the tediousness of war through their stories and their memories. The book is a clear antiwar statement, because underneath all the stories and the memories is the horror of war and the meaninglessness of war. The Vietnam War ended in defeat for the Americans and the South Vietnamese, and our being there did not change anything, we just lost many good young men like the ones in this story. This is the theme and the fiber that holds this book together; and what makes it such a strong and poignant message against fighting and war. O'Brien shows his antiwar theme by consistently showing just how war is "hell." By the end of the book, the reader understands just how war is hell, and why this book is such a strong statement against war and the horrors it creates on both sides of the fighting.

Author Tim O'Brien knows the Vietnam War because he fought there. It seems as if it would be impossible to write a book like The Things They Carried without having actually experienced the war. That is one reason the book is so vivid and so interesting. The author experienced many of these things first-hand. That is also why it is so disturbing. The author saw many of these things or things like them, and many of them are horrible. O'Brien notes that the book is fiction, and yet, many of the characters seem so real they must have existed, and the lines of reality blur even more when the reader realizes the narrator of these short stories strung together into a novel is named Tim O'Brien.

One critic, Catherine Calloway, notes "The relationship between fiction and reality arises early in the text when the reader learns the first of many parallels that emerge as the book progresses: that the protagonist and narrator, like the real author of The Things They Carried, is named Tim O'Brien" (Calloway 250). O'Brien attended college in Minnesota and protested the Vietnam War during his college years. Shortly after he graduated, he was drafted, and served in Vietnam. He believes the experience helped him as a writer, but he never talks about his service or his experience, he simply writes about it. Therefore, he clearly experienced things like the things he describes in this book. He fictionalized many of them, as he did many of the characters, but many of them are based in true experience. That makes the book even more interesting and disturbing. Another literature critic, Jim Neilson, notes, "The Things They Carried was a finalist for both the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Critics Circle Award" (Neilson 192). The book is a classic American war novel, and an even more classic American antiwar novel.

It is easy to think all the violence, bloodshed, and atrocities of war are made up. Knowing they could be true is more difficult. Knowing many of these incidents could be true also shows why O'Brien is so against war. It is clear from these stories that war is terrible. It is violent, it is deadly, and it changes people. It is also quite certain that none of the young men who returned from Vietnam were the same as when they left the United States. War changes people, and not in a good way. This war was worse than most, because it ended in defeat. These young men fought for nothing, and that had to affect them, too. That is one reason this book carries such a strong antiwar message. O'Brien does not want other young men to go through what he went through. Unfortunately, it does not seem like that is possible in our world.

O'Brien did not connect and plot the book like most fictional works. This book is more like a series of short stories woven together to make a book. Many of the characters, alive and dead, continue through many of the stories. Two characters are consistent throughout the stories - the narrator, who turns out to be O'Brien, and Jimmy Cross, the young lieutenant who always stays in touch with O'Brien. These two consistent characters help hold the book together and keep the characters from becoming disjointed and difficult to understand. At one point the narrator states, "But the thing about remembering is that you don't forget" (O'Brien 38), and this is an important aspect of the antiwar message of this book. The men who fought there cannot forget their experiences in Vietnam. They color the rest of their lives, and convince many of them that war is wrong and useless in the end. All it does is kill innocent people on both sides. Wars change people, and not for the better, and that is another message of this book.

There is another very strong fictional device that holds this book together, and that is the characters in each story. Even in such short sections, O'Brien creates characters that the reader comes to care about. He does this by making them real, and the situations they face real, too. For example, he opens the book with his friend Jimmy Cross. He makes him real by showing him longing for home. He writes, "He would imagine romantic camping trips into the White Mountains in New Hampshire. He would sometimes taste the envelope flaps, knowing her tongue had been there" (O'Brien 3). This opening also sets up another important aspect of the characters. Each of them "carries" something throughout the novel - from soap to drugs to a treasured Bible. That gives the novel its title, but it also gives the characters more "character." Author Leslie Adams writes, "The description of the items each man carried gives the reader some initial impression of the character's personality, but the items also represent the private anxieties of each soldier" (Adams 91). Critic Neilson continues, "Characters and incidents are repeated from story to story and are refracted through several literary modes and through the O'Brien narrator/persona's shifting self-interest and self-delusion" (Neilson 192). The characters are crucial to the reader's understanding of the novel, and how the characters delude themselves is crucial to the story and to the theme.

That is another very important antiwar theme in the book, that people often delude themselves into believing war is "good" or "necessary." For example, several times in the book the narrator and other characters refer to "true" stories and then say they aren't true, such as, "That's a true story that never happened" (O'Brien 84). This shows that the characters have lost the ability to understand the difference between reality and fantasy, and so, much of what they say in the book is suspect. The reader does not know what to believe and what not to believe. They do not want to believe some of the most gruesome stories, like the death of Curt Lemon and the death of the baby water buffalo, and yet they suspect both are "true." The characters are trying to tell themselves what they are doing is good, or at least necessary by making up stories that make it seem better or much worse than it really is. This book shows that war is neither good nor necessary; it is simply a way for two sides who disagree to do away with each other, and never really come to an agreement or an understanding. This is especially important regarding the Vietnam War, because that war has never really "gone away." It is still controversial, and many people refer to the War in Iraq as "another Vietnam," meaning it is a war we cannot win and should not be fighting. If Vietnam were not so controversial, people like Tim O'Brien would not continue to write books about it twenty or thirty years after it ended.

O'Brien uses many techniques throughout the novel to show the hopelessness and waste of the Vietnam War and continue his antiwar message. One is metaphor, particularly the metaphor of poor Kiowa slowly sinking and dying in a field of *****. O'Brien writes, "[...] when he got there Kiowa was almost completely under. There was a knee. There was an arm and a gold wristwatch and part of a boot" (O'Brien 149). He makes Kiowa vividly real by using the minute details of a soldier's life to show what a man leaves in the end. It makes the reader think about the waste of war and warfare, and it is a metaphor for the entire war, too. Critic Neilson believes the metaphor is strong, too. He… READ MORE

How to Reference "Scar of War" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

War of the Worlds Term Paper

War of the Worlds was written over a decade before the outbreak of the first World War, H.G. Wells' seminal novel actually predicted the kind of mechanized, impersonal slaughter that… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (989 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

War World War II This Report Focuses Term Paper

War

World War II

This report focuses on the frontline battlefield experiences of both American and Japanese soldiers as depicted in the semibiographical but fictional work "The Naked and the… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1525 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: World History

---

What Are the Costs of War? Essay

War

An Analysis of Ishmael Beah's Experience as a Child Soldier

In January of 2007, the New York Times ran an excerpt of Ishmael Beah's memoir of life as a… read more

Essay 4 pages (1243 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

Civil War How the Civil War Shaped Research Proposal

Civil War

How the Civil War Shaped the Nation's View

The Civil War shaped America's destiny while bringing about great change for this country. The political and social consequences of… read more

Research Proposal 7 pages (2408 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: American History / United States

---

Salinger Tracing Expressions of Post-War Trauma Research Paper

Salinger

Tracing Expressions of Post-War Trauma and Sincere Isolation in the Works of J.D. Salinger

War is a subject that is often in the news and the broader public attention… read more

Research Paper 8 pages (2368 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>