Essay on "Storytelling and Representing Reality"

Essay 6 pages (1780 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Story Telling and Representing Reality

In what ways do the demands of "good story" telling affect the way political issues and events are represented in film (both narrative and documentary)?

The most obvious answer to the above question has to do with the fact that an issue must be portrayed in a manner that is compelling to the viewer. Both narrative and documentary films, in order to be viewed and understood must have a compelling social interest to the viewer, be it emotional, political or both, which it usually is. There must be a story line, often a villain or an implied villain and a message, often placing the political into a position of affecting emotion, be it anger, disgust, empathy, sympathy or even hatred for an implicit or explicit villain, who is in some manner oppressing an underdog. The manner in which the viewer is compelled to build an opinion about the antagonism of a story is through good story telling. To make a film or write a story that has merit and is read or viewed you must have all the same elements of intrigue, plot, conflict, compelling character (s), compelling setting and compelling ideology as to make a reader of viewer a believer in any concept you must draw them in to the story.

Plot and Conflict

To this end there must be an antagonist and a protagonist, regardless of the nature of the film. The viewer must leave the viewing with a sense of inquiry, to either do something or at the very least form an opinion that builds on the ideology or message of the film. In documentary films like Poverty Outlaw (2008), the message is the system, i.e. government is the villain and the poor the underdog, in the Eyes on the Prize, civil rights episode, Mississippi: Is this America (1986) the enemy is again the dominant social system that penalized civil rights proponents and showed the massive social and economic disparities in Mississippi during the civil rights movement. While the "based on a true story" narrative film Mississippi Burning (1988) had a similar message played up by the artistic license of filmmaking. The Road to Guantanamo (2006) offers the viewer a combination of documentary and narrative (docudrama) (Giglio, 2005, p. 57) while it travels through the lives of three wrongly arrested and imprisoned British Muslims who were held in the Guantanamo Bay political prison for two years without ever being charged, the antagonist of the film, being the special system that allowed detention that violates many individual rights and the implied contradiction of this action on the part of the U.S. The film Dave (1993), on the other hand is a purely fictional account of political scandal and conspiracy, where and individual crooked politician is the antagonist and Dave (the everyman) is the protagonist, in much the same way as the everyman, Mr. Smith is developed in the 1939 film Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. People in the U.S. tend to believe in the corrupting effects of power and that many people holding power harbor designs on getting more of it, even to the degree that they will bend, break and remake the law to do so, which is interestingly enough the plot summary of The Candidate (1972) where an every man is corrupted by power and again the "system" is assailed as antagonistic to the dream of individualism, as a political ideology as defined by Kingdon in America the Unusual. (1999, pp. 28-29) Finally in Bulworth (1998) a political comedy the already corrupted senator, living on borrowed time remakes himself by telling the truth and going back to his protagonist roots. Each of these films has a similar message, "if your not mad, your not paying attention." This is a message that pervades the "diversity" of opinion that makes up America, yet is really a timeline of the expression of the ideal of the infallible ability of power to corrupt.

Character and Relate-ability

Though all of these films may have a moral that is similar, this ideology is significant in its ability to sway the common viewer of the "right" and the "wrong" of any given political emotion. The individual must be able to relate to the players, or at the very least be able to believe that they exist, especially in the case of the corrupt politician or political system, through observable messages in the film, again no matter if the film is a true documentary, a narrative message that interjects politics as a main theme or a hybrids in the form of a docudrama. This is not unlike any other film, where narrative fiction represents a message associated with sympathy, empathy and emotion of an individual that the viewer can relate to. If the viewer has no interest in the characters or cannot relate to their ideas, monologues, dialogues or non-verbal cues he or she may simply turn off the film and choose to watch something else that moves her or him. Even when the characters of the film are as foreign as they come, such as in The Road to Guantanmo (2006) the skill of the story teller first must begin with his or her ability to make the character/individual relatable. Yes, we have opinions, don't you? Yes, we have families, don't you? Yes, we have community, don't you? And more than that are your opinions not based on evidence from your environment and your community and are they not common among the members of your community? Yet, look where it got us, we are prisoners with no charge, no sentence and no release date, and if your country could do this to us it could do it to you.

Compelling Setting

The setting of any persuasive political film, document or narrative must be believable. For a setting to be believable in the truest sense it must actually exist in some form in the psyche of the viewer or reader. Each of the films mentioned in this work offer the viewer a believable and compelling setting, often places where "mere mortals" rarely tread, the halls of justice, the halls of congress (Rosenstiel, 1997, p. 89) the oval office and even the deep south of oppression, or the confines of a political prison. Many of these spaces are settings in history that few people really get to see and even fewer get to watch people interact within. This in and of itself compels the viewer to watch the bit of good story telling that makes a good political docudrama, documentary or narrative. (Giglio, 2005, pp. 119-120) Due to the fact that these places are mysterious we seek to be a fly on the wall within them, to better understand the decisions and politics that pervade them, true or fictional, but usually believable and compelling. (King, 1988, p. 7)

Compelling Ideologies

Though documentary tends not too be overtly star studded, to get almost anything done in film one must seek funding, and the political leanings of those who have wealth in Hollywood are clearly expressed by what films, either documentary or political narrative they support and even act in.

This adherence to causes has led to stars using celebrity to promote civil rights, personal liberties, opposition to wars and freedom of speech. Invariably, the liberal complexion of the Hollywood film industry created closer affiliations with the Democratic rather than the Republican Party. Stars supported reforms to what they perceived was an underepresntative and corrupt system. (Wheeler, 2008, p. 160)

It is clear that like any other area of personal interest, the popular model of what is a "good story" changes, given the state of the situation in the nation, as Wheeler also points out the immediate post 9-11 patriotism film also brought many people to the box office and some "closeted" Republicans out of Hollywood and into influential and powerful positions. (2008, p. 158) Yet, this does not change the fact that influential works, such as those described above in both the narrative and documentary formats represent an example of "good story" telling for the time and place in which they were created. It could in fact be said that the later works, and specifically Road to Guantanamo is really a resurgence or backlash to what many see as the patriotic complacency that allowed the nation to knee jerk into two wars associated with retaliation over the terrorism that spurned the immediate patriotism.

The history of movies is clear on one point: people in and out of the industry have behaved as though movies make a difference, as though they are powerful. From the beginning, movies were the target of attempts from without to control content; these were succeeded by efforts from within to do the same. (Gianos, 1999, p. 45)

Both overt and covert attempts have been made to sway public opinion and reassert or assert either conservative or liberal values, using film in both narrative and documentary format. This assertion clearly provides implicit proof that films are capable, as… READ MORE

How to Reference "Storytelling and Representing Reality" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Storytelling in Odyssey Book Report

Storytelling in "The Odyssey"

Storytelling not only shapes the Odyssey, it demonstrates the power of storytelling. Homer was not simply telling a story, he manipulated the art of storytelling to… read more

Book Report 6 pages (1670 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Mythology / Folklore / Science Fiction

---

Hollywood Truly Global? Hollywood Represents a Specific Essay

Hollywood Truly Global?

Hollywood represents a specific image and ideal. Its role in the formation of major movie success has allowed it to become a dominating force within international cinema.… read more

Essay 7 pages (2011 words) Sources: 3 Style: Harvard Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

Emotional Drivers of Consumer Toward Swarovskis Brand Literature Review

Emotional Drivers Towards Swarovski's Brand

Emotional Drivers of Consumer toward Swarovski's Brand

Emotional Drivers of Consumer toward Swarovski's Brand

Emotional Drivers of Consumer toward Swarovski's Brand

The standard of living… read more

Literature Review 38 pages (12508 words) Sources: 45 Style: Harvard Topic: Advertising / Marketing / Sales

---

Japanese Film Double Suicide or Hanabi Term Paper

Japanese Film

Defining Reality in Double Suicide: When Traditional and New Storytelling Methods Combine

Masahiro Shinoda's 1969 film Double Suicide recounts a tale of a two lovers who ultimately vow… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (575 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

Royal Tenenbaums Was Directed Essay

It gives the reader a sense that Richie is like a melancholy caterpillar, swallowed by the dark merciless cocoon of life. Also notably, when Richie removes his sunglasses, there's a… read more

Essay 8 pages (2428 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>