Essay on "Theory and Social Policy"

Essay 10 pages (3323 words) Sources: 9 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Social Policy: KiwiSaver as a Social Policy

A vitally important social / economic policy that the New Zealand Government launched - thanks in part to the progressive influences of the Labour Alliance Coalition and cooperation from private providers and employers - is called KiwiSaver ("Poua he Oranga"). KiwiSaver is a kind of savings program to help all citizens prepare financially for their retirement, or whatever their future plans happen to be. The benefits are many, and the program is flexible. This program was certainly not designed with Maori needs in mind exclusively, but indeed KiwiSaver offers returns to individuals - if they take advantage of it - that may not be as well off financially as they would like to be in terms of support for their families and their future comfort.

KIWISAVER & DATA SHOWING the NEED:

To get started with KiwiSaver, one becomes a member, opens an account, and the Government will put a tax-free investment of $1,000 into that (legal citizen's) personal private account, according to www.kiwisaver.govt.nz.A KiwiSaver member must be a person earning a steady wage so that he or she can make contributions into an account. That $1,000 ("kick-start" money) goes into the account about three months after the account is opened.

Another advantage to joining KiwiSaver is the tax credit that is given to members after one year (July 1 to June 30, the fiscal year, is the time frame in this instance). The minimum tax credit is $1,042.86. A person must be a member, be over 18 years of age, and be a resident of New Zealand.

As of April 1, 2008, the employer of a KiwiSaver member is required by law to make contributions into the member's account. The first year, the employer is required to put 1% of a member's earnings into the KiwiSaver account; each year after that, the member's employer is required to increase the contribution by 1% until the maximum of 4% of a member's earnings is being put into the member's account. To help out with those contributions, the Government will give employers of members "up to $20 a week to help them meet the cost of making contributions."

After three years of making contributions to one's account, a member may withdraw from the KiwiSaver account to buy a home - if it is a first home purchase. This scenario becomes a bit complicated as far as withdrawing for a home purchase; for example, if the KiwiSaver member has already purchased a home in the past, he or she may withdraw KiwiSaver funds but not the original $1,000 that the Government placed into the account at the outset.

KiwiSaver is clearly becoming a successful social democracy-themed program; indeed, as of 31 May 2008, membership in KiwiSaver reached 673,942. Finance Minister Michael Cullen said in www.kiwisaver.govt.nzthat it was "especially gratifying to see so many young New Zealanders starting a savings habit" (more than 180,000 members are less than 25 years of age).

SOCIAL DEMOCRACY & KIWISAVER:

The political philosophy that was ostensibly the driver for the initial policies of social change when the Labour Alliance Coalition Government took over in 1999 - which in reality embraced the philosophy of social justice - was, according to Steve Maharey (today a member of Parliament) the "New Social Democracy." Why the New Social Democracy as a working policy phrase? Politicians are drawn to "safe" phrases and slogans, which cannot be thrown back into their faces by opponents of their policies. Meantime, Maharey, who has served in myriad roles in the New Zealand government and within the Labour Party over the years, explains in a speech (26 March, 2001), whilst he was "Acting Minister of Broadcasting" and "Associate Minister of Education" that his Labour Government used the shied away from labels like "The Third Way" and "Closing the Gap."

In the www.Beehive.govt.nzWeb site Maharey states (in 2001, the date of his speech) that "The Third Way" had become "somewhat imprecise" (read that actually to mean it was up for criticism by the political opposition). Also, the concept of "Closing the Gap" - as a political philosophy that steered a new form of social justice through the country - had become "imprecise," Maharey went on. And "Closing the Gap" had in fact become "a political lightning rod for the kind of criticism that was both politically destabilizing" and also it was "undermining" the results his government was seeking (Maharey, 2001). In short, Maharey believed "Closing the Gap" had become a target for criticism by conservative opponents of the Labour Alliance Coalition.

Those individuals (opponents of progressive legislation led by the Labour group) viewed the slogan "Closing the Gap" as something of a "zero-sum game" in which the Maori and Pacific Island peoples win and Pakeha New Zealanders (European ethnicities) are the losers. And so the bottom line in terms of what political philosophy guided the launching of KiwiSaver was the "New Social Democracy."

The facts that led to the need for a program like KiwiSaver were presented well before the KiwiSaver program began in 2006-2007. The Tax Policy Center (Urban Institute and Brookings Institution) showed data in 2006 that while the New Zealand Superannuation, or NZS, has helped prevent poverty among older citizens, nevertheless there is "a significant share of the population falling below the poverty line" (Toder, et al., 2006). However, the report explains, "There was a notable decline in employer-provided superannuation plans between 1993 and 2003." The number of employees that were covered in a superannuation plan that was provided by a private employer as a percentage of the employed labor force "decreased from 18.5 to 11.4%," hence, the need for KiwiSaver.

POLITICAL THEORY (NEOLIBERALISM) and KIWISAVER:

When Dr. Michael Cullen gave a speech to the government union forum on 7 November, 2002, he observed that the New Zealand Government had "rejected what he called the 'neoliberal' route to growth," according to Roger Kerr, Executive Director of the New Zealand Business Roundtable (Kerr, 2002). What Cullen specifically was referring to as neoliberal included (Kerr's words): "Low taxes, as little regulation as possible, the privatization of as much economic activity as possible, and a minimalist state." Kerr is making this point because he is among conservatives who question whether or not the Labour Alliance ever really gave up on neoliberalism as a theory leading to social policies. Kerr is not alone in questioning the actual definition of neoliberalism,

Kerr quotes from Australian Andrew Norton, with the Centre for Independent Studies in Sydney, who says using the term "neoliberalism" is a "code for 'I am a left-winger who does not like markets'...It is a leftist version of the secret handshake; a signal that the reader is with fellow travelers," Norton wrote, and Kerr quotes from Norton to make his point that a) neoliberalism is a confusing concept; and b) hidden behind the "neo" are real political and social liberals who are not to be trusted.

An article in the British Journal of Sociology of Education (Robertson, et al., 2002) asserts that as regards proponents of neoliberalism in New Zealand - with reference to the restructuring of education and other matters of social justice - have sought to "isolate and localize" problems "in order to contain and manage the risks associated with them" (Robertson, et al., 2002). In fact, neoliberalism in New Zealand, according to the authors (one of whom is a professor at the University of Auckland) amounts to offering social benefits to citizens through a kind of "trickle-down of wealth" generated by the state... [That encourages] individuals...to be more responsible for their own economic well-being."

The post-war welfare state "accepted and met - though with decreasing success - a legitimation burden based on taking responsibility for a wide range of social outcomes," Robertson and Dale argue. In fairness to New Zealand's post welfare policies, the authors state "New Zealand...has sought to promote a state of permanent innovation and flexibility both in its citizens and workers...in order to strengthen structural competitiveness..."

This article of course was written well before the launch in New Zealand of the KiwiSaver, and by reading the critique of neoliberalism one can see that it was high time for a program like KiwiSaver, on order for citizens (voters, taxpayers) to begin to provide for their own financial needs.

Meanwhile, that being said, a more general approach to the need for government to understand (through political theory played out by political parties) and know their constituencies very well, including the economic and social demographics of those constituencies. No matter what policies they prefer to lay claim to, the Labour Alliance party actually brought a "neoliberal" economic policy to the forefront by 2002, according to an article in Political Psychology (Allen, et al., 2000). Professors Michael W. Allen (of the University of Newcastle in Australia) and Sik Hung Ng (of Victoria University of Wellington) insist that people's concerns about the economy "...affect their political party preferences," and indeed it is no surprise that empirical research shows that people choose… READ MORE

How to Reference "Theory and Social Policy" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Criminological Theory and Social Policy Essay

Criminological Theory and Social Policy

Describe how certain theories are related to how social policies are created

Classical and rational theories of criminology view crime as a 'choice' made by… read more

Essay 1 pages (379 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Criminology Social Learning Theory and Social Policy Essay

Criminology

Social Learning Theory and Social Policy

Dealing with the problems that occur in society and preserving the welfare of innocents is the responsibility and duty of law enforcement and… read more

Essay 3 pages (1031 words) Sources: 4 Style: APA Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

Boudon 2001 Theories of Social Thesis

Boudon 2001: Theories of Social

Does the author present a view of society?

Although he does not present his own view of society, the author presents several different views of… read more

Thesis 3 pages (838 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Canadian Social Policy Essay

Canadian Social Policy

The title of the article by Gerard Boismenu and Peter Graefe provides a strong hint as to the intended message and impact of this piece. "Tool Belt"… read more

Essay 3 pages (1064 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Government / Politics

---

Marx's Theory of Social Change Term Paper

Marx's Theory Of Social Change

Karl Marx (1818-1883) is regarded as the founder of 'socialism'. He was a great philosopher and thinker. There have been written large number of books… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1350 words) Sources: 1+ Style: MLA Topic: Sociology / Society

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>