Essay on "Social Contradiction"

Essay 3 pages (1066 words) Sources: 3

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Social Contradiction

The contradiction between America's promise of opportunity and freedom on the one hand and its inherently unjust capitalism system on the other plays itself out in literature, both fiction and non-fiction, as a seemingly unbridgeable divide between the two sides of any capitalist endeavor, namely, management and labor. This divide appears so insurmountable precisely because the moral and political legitimacy of one side (management) ultimately depends upon an insistence that such a divide does not exist. Because there is no way to justify the inherent exploitation of capitalism without an appeal to some kind of divine right on the part of the privileged, capitalism and its representatives in management have simply been forced to pretend that no such exploitation actually exists. Both the appeal to divine right and the seemingly willful disavowal of any injustice in capitalism can be seen in the work of Benjamin Franklin and Herman Melville, because one of the central arguments of Benjamin Franklin's autobiography depends upon a kind of divine right, while the narrator of Melville's Bartleby the Scrivener is woefully unaware of his own privileged position and the inherent injustice of his position. By discussing Franklin's autobiography alongside Melville's Bartleby, one is able to see not only how American capitalism attempts to justify itself, but also the somewhat counter-intuitive way in which this form of capitalism has been challenged.

Capitalism is inherently unfair, in that profit is by definition the product of an unequal transaction, and capitalism is dependent on profit as both its means and end. However, modern capitalism finds itself deeply rooted to representative democracy, and thus there has always been a kind of dissonance between the rhetoric of democracy and liberty and the exploitative reality of capitalism, a dissonance that America's earliest capitalist leaders attempted to explain and ultimately dissolve. Benjamin Franklin implicitly makes the defense of capitalism one of the central goals of his autobiography when he explains his motivations for writing it, and the specific explanation of his motivations embodies the appeal to divine right that paradoxically characterizes the economic system of a country explicitly founded in opposition to the supposed divine right of kings. In short, Franklin, like so many of his American descendents, believes in the Protestant myth of American meritocracy, and thus equates financial success with the benediction of an interventionist god (Franklin, 2008, p. 3).

He reveals as much when he tells his son that one of the major "inducements" for writing his autobiography is the fact that he, "with the blessing of God," was able to find economic success, and thus feels a kind of duty to subsequent generations to share with them the secrets of that success (Franklin, 2008, p. 3). While Franklin was obviously quite successful, not only in business but in politics and philosophy, he misidentifies the source of his success, simply because he attributes it to a god, rather than the fact that he was a relatively well-positioned white male in a society created by and for white men. While Franklin undoubtedly worked hard for his success, the fact remains that any challenge he faced was immeasurably lessened due to the fact that he happened to be born a white male,… READ MORE

How to Reference "Social Contradiction" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Social Justice Essay

Social Justice

By saying that social justice is a "mirage," Friedrich Hayek has raised the question whether the concept of social justice has meaningful content. This provocative statement implies that… read more

Essay 5 pages (1450 words) Sources: 9 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Social Security How the Social Security Insurance Term Paper

Social Security

How the Social Security Insurance Works

The Social Security is an organization is that is commonly known to anyone especially to those who are in the labor force.… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1075 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Social Media on the Advertising Competitiveness Literature Review

Social Media on the Advertising Competitiveness of Small Businesses

Marketing is a complex issue (Joshi, 2005; Christensen, 1997). Because of the complexities surrounding it, it is very important that every… read more

Literature Review 15 pages (6921 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Advertising / Marketing / Sales

---

Theory and Social Policy Essay

Social Policy: KiwiSaver as a Social Policy

A vitally important social / economic policy that the New Zealand Government launched - thanks in part to the progressive influences of the… read more

Essay 10 pages (3323 words) Sources: 9 Style: APA Topic: Government / Politics

---

Social Engagement Through Images in the Online Sphere Article Critique

Social Engagement Through Images Online

The author of "Comments about Social Engagement through Images in the Online Sphere" asserts that digital photography combined with online social networks has wrought a… read more

Article Critique 2 pages (663 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Computers / IT / Internet

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>