Research Paper on "Sharon Kemp's "The Hidden Workforce: Volunteers' Learning"

Research Paper 7 pages (2277 words) Sources: 15

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Sharon Kemp's "The hidden workforce:

volunteers' learning in the Olympics"

Critical Analysis

Author Sharon Kemp, in her work "The hidden workforce: volunteer's learning in the Olympics" sets out to understand the motives behind those called to volunteer in what she deems "mega events" such as the Olympics in this case. In comparing volunteers from the 1994 Winter Games in Lillehammer, Norway and the 1994 Summer Games held in Sydney, Australia, Kemp was able to analyze and interpret the reasoning and motivation behind the many hundreds of volunteers' decisions to join in on these monumental events. In beginning with this simple research question, Kemp is able to use a distinct set of methodological means to undertake her research experiment and evidently interpret its results. In viewing Kemp's approach, one can specifically see where her approach exceeds an acceptable research standard as well as where her research methods stand to be improved.

In undertaking her research, Kemp aims to address "the role of volunteers during the Olympic Winter Games in Lillehammer as compared to the role experienced by the volunteers involved in the Sydney 2000 Summer Olympic Games" (Kemp 2002, pp. 110). As any individual familiar with the Olympics understands, the presence of volunteers is absolutely essential to the running of the Games, and without the work of these many hundreds of volunteers, the Olympic Games would cease to exist in the grand manner which the world has come to appreciate. Kemp, in her work, takes note of these many individuals who come to the aid of the Olympic host cities in order to ensure that the Olympic standard is maintained. The understanding that so many individuals continue to come out year after year is undisputed. However, the understanding as to why these individuals continuously do so had yet to be fully determined upon the beginning of Kemp's research. Kemp notes that the underlying motivations behind Olympic volunteering are vast and varied including national pride, sense of value and life enrichment, but in seeking the overarching reasoning behind this volunteerism, sets out with one main objective: to compare two sets of respondents' perceptions of learning and job satisfaction at each of the two aforementioned Olympic Games.

Kemp, in beginning her work, makes distinct mention that without the personal investment of the volunteers, mega-events such as the Olympics could simply not be arranged or carried out, a theory that was considerably recognized during the Sydney Olympic Games which consistently and considerably displayed the presence of the Olympic volunteers present. Kemp notes that while volunteerism at these events is always widely noted, there exists little research on the topic and therefore considerably few theoretical answers to the question at hand.

However, Kemp, driven by past theories and studies focusing on issues such as motivational and behavioral patterns, professionalism, volunteers' perception of an event's strengths and weaknesses, and the recruitment of volunteers, is able to draw from these smaller-scale theoretical analyses in order to apply the same motivations to a mega-event such as the Olympics (Henderson 1990, pp. 61; Lynn and Smith 1991, pp.1; Miller et al. 1990, pp.2; Pearce 1993, pp.1; Ryan and Bates 1995, pp.59; Williams et al. 1995, pp.83). In taking this theoretical framework, discovered through research on a smaller scale, and methodically interpreting its basis in volunteerism at a far greater level, Kemp is able to understand the basic motivations for volunteerism at a base level and add to this to account for the magnitude of an event such as the Olympic Games.

Kemp's methodology is solely focused on the Lillehammer Winter Olympics and the Sydney Summer Olympics. The Lillehammer component of Kemp's research is concentrated on students who presented the largest subgroup of volunteers, and older volunteers, aged 45 and over (Kemp 2002, pp. 110-111). As both of these groups worked between five weeks and three months as volunteers at the Winter Games, Kemp's evaluation was to be taken after the completion of the Games in their entirety. Contrarily, the Sydney component of the study consisted of 200 respondents comprised of both students and older volunteers who were recruited on-site at various Olympic venues during the 16-day Olympic period (Kemp 2002, pp.110). In comparing the perceptions of each of these respective groups, Kemp evaluated the groups' learning, social skills, knowledge about society, job-specific skills and volunteer satisfaction with the use of a questionnaire comprised of both open-ended and closed questions. Responses to the closed questions were specifically coded and results of the open-ended questions evaluated and compared to those of the rest of the internal group and external groups in order to gauge an overall understanding of volunteer mood.

The results of Kemp's evaluations and research proved to have a basis in the research of the past in terms of smaller venues, but found that the sense of national pride proved a significant motivator in volunteer recruitment. A majority of the volunteers (64.5% found that they had developed important social skills and further increased their knowledge of society around them (55%) (Kemp 2002, pp. 112). Volunteers additionally increased their job skills on an overarching level and at a more specific level in great numbers in both the Lillehammer and Sydney venues, with younger students learning many new skills and older respondents honing in on skills they already possessed. Despite the differences in ages amongst the volunteers, Kemp concluded that a positive relationship does in fact exist between volunteer learning and satisfaction, as well as concluding that "the sharing of knowledge and having the opportunity to exercise and learn new skills are important motivational factors of volunteers" (Kemp 2002, pp. 115).

Respondents showed no undue bias and each response questionnaire, collected upon the conclusion of each respective set of Olympic Games showed significant validity and integrity as shown through respondents' answers to open-ended questions as well as within the included comments sections. Kemp and other researchers who view her work on the topic of volunteerism has maintained the standard of research integrity, choosing respondents at random and providing no means to sway their responses. In allowing respondents to go about their business during the Olympic Games and partake in answering questionnaires after the completion of the Olympic Games, Kemp sought to receive an overarching selection of responses that encompassed the entirety of the volunteers' experiences at the Games.

Revised Research Approach

While Kemp's initial aim and objective in undertaking the research project at hand was to determine the motivations and amount of learning that occurred within the volunteers at the Olympic Games, her research may have proven more conclusive had she sought to measure the changes in attitudes of volunteers from the beginning of the Games to the end. In altering the structure of this research in this manner, questionnaires could still be used to gauge the opinions of the volunteer respondents, but more frequent use of these questionnaires would likely provide more accurate information rather than the information that is gauged from polling the respondents merely at the end of the Games when they are likely filled with a sense of nostalgia that may alter the honesty of their responses.

In this sense, the methodological approach behind the experiment that Kemp created would not be completely overthrown, but simply altered to increase the accuracy of the responses. Research has shown that a questionnaire is one of the most cost-effective research tools for use in data collection. However, certain steps should always be taken in order to ensure that these questionnaires provide as much accurate information as possible despite the "cheap" nature of the data collector. Questionnaires should be sent to a pilot sample to check reliability and validity before going directly to the research sample (Clarke and Jack 1998, pp.176). Through imposing this type of base questioning, researchers can have a level ground to judge the reactions of the respondents from. Additionally, while the volunteer subgroups in Kemp's original experiment were chosen at a semi-random status with individuals being chosen from the most represented demographics, a revised experiment should select participants randomly.

In choosing a random 200 volunteer respondents from each of the two Olympic Games to be observed, the experiment eliminates any type of group bias or generalization in favor of a more comprehensive result. The most common sampling error encountered in survey or questionnaire research occurs because the sample selected is not an accurate representation of the population being researched (Assael and Keon 1982, pp. 114). This effect can be better eliminated with the choosing of a truly random representative sample. In questioning the respondent sample with initial questionnaires upon their coming into their volunteer work at the Olympic Games, again during these Games and again at the end, a more accurate understanding of the overall motivation and learning process within the group can be discovered rather than an overly positive final review upon the end of the Olympic Games.

The implementation of such questionnaires will prove simplistic and can be managed with simple coding of answers and accurate management of the questionnaires that are completed. However, with… READ MORE

How to Reference "Sharon Kemp's "The Hidden Workforce: Volunteers' Learning" Research Paper in a Bibliography

Related Research Papers:

Volunteering in Favor of Community Service Term Paper

Volunteering

In favor of community service...an address to the local PTA

Recently, the local school board passed a somewhat controversial measure requiring all high school students to participate in some… read more

Term Paper 1 pages (406 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Learning Organization on Leadership and Management Essay

Learning Organizations

Leadership and Learning Organizations

Developing a Learning Organization through Informed Leadership

The ability to learn faster than your competitors may be the only sustainable advantage. -- Cliff Purington,… read more

Essay 15 pages (4434 words) Sources: 25 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Learning Styles -- Visual-Auditory Learners Essay

Learning Styles -- Visual-Auditory Learners

My Learning Style

According to my responses, my predominant learning style is Visual-Auditory. That means I am less inclined to learn optimally from reading textbook… read more

Essay 2 pages (651 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Learning Theory Several Theories Term Paper

Learning Theory

Several theories are suggested for the best way to help students learn in a classroom setting, such as constructivism, brain-based learning, attribution theory, emotional intelligence and multiple intelligences.… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1884 words) Sources: 6 Style: APA Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Relationship Between Learning Styles Gender and Mathematics Scores Literature Review

Mathematics

Relationship between Learning Styles, Gender, and Mathematics Scores

Learning is one of the most significant backgrounds in research today and at the same time one of the most complex… read more

Literature Review 6 pages (2029 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>