Term Paper on "Negotiation Project Sanibel Island"

Term Paper 10 pages (2733 words) Sources: 4 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Sanibel

Situation and facts

My investors and I are in the process of developing a three-story beachfront hotel on Sanibel Island, a popular tourist destination off the western coast of Florida. Aside from beautiful weather and access to the Gulf of Mexico, Sanibel Island offers more than 400 different types of shells and an aggressively protected natural habitat for 267 species of birds. The residents of Sanibel Island are very protective of its environment, including its 4,700 acres of habitat and 11,000 acres of freshwater wetlands. As one might expect, this desire to protect the environment frequently presents challenges for the proprietors of Sanibel Island's booming tourist industry.

Since a causeway was constructed linking Sanibel Island to mainland Florida, the tourism business has grown significantly and is currently a major contributor to the Sanibel Island economy. This has raised concerns among residents that the pristine environment and many of the islands key aesthetic features could be compromised. As a result, several restrictions have been placed on the development of hotels and tourist attractions on the island. For example, new buildings can not exceed three stories in height, although such restrictions do not exist on similar Gulf islands, because residents do not want to obstruct island views. Also, buildings often must be constructed on stilts or with open first floors to minimize the risks of property damage in case the island experiences flooding.

State and federal laws also require that development cost Sanibel Island no net loss of wetlands, which are basically poorly-defined transitional areas between dry land and the ocean. So, if any construction occurs that results in a loss of wetlands, new wetlands must be recreated elsewhere on the island. In reality, local regulations are often stricter than federal and state requirements, so projects that result in a disturbance of wetlands are hardly guaranteed a green light from the island's residents. This is a common issue in Florida, as development that impacts wetlands often causes natural habitats for animals, insects and plants to be divided (Green swamp, No date). Recreating wetlands, of course, can not solve this problem.

Finally, the island's residents are very protective of their freshwater resources, which provide habitats for the island's various species and offer a source of fresh water for drinking and other uses for the island residents. Naturally, any project that could disturb or pollute these freshwater resources is going to receive a good deal of scrutiny from the Sanibel Island residents.

While my investors and I currently operate hotel properties on Sanibel Island, our latest planned hotel has raised some concerns among island environmentalists. While the hotel will meet the island's three-story limit and will include a large nature preserve with raised boardwalks so guests do not disturb the environment, other facets of the project are more troubling. First, I need to construct a walkway that will connect the hotel to the outdoor swimming pool, and this walkway will result in a slight loss of wetlands. The environmentalists oppose this loss of wetlands, but the hotel must have a swimming pool and it will be a major detriment to the hotel's operations if the main building and swimming pool are not connected. It would be a major inconvenience for guests if they could not easily access the pool.

Another point of contention for the environmentalists involves the parking lot and access road that must be built to guests can reach the hotel. While the hotel has 350 feet of road frontage, I will need to build a turn-off road for hotel access, and, naturally, a place for guests to park. Because the pavement is a non-porous surface, water will run off of the pavement and carry any pollutants the pavement collects with it. This pollution could eventually reach and contaminate the island's freshwater resources. As a result, the island environmentalists want me to construct barrier/retention ponds and a buffer zone of plants to keep the run-off from reaching Sanibel Island's freshwater resources. Although I believe the environmentalists are exaggerating the risk to their freshwater resources, I have already budgeted the money for such construction. The environmentalists do not know that I have already committed myself financially to this environmental initiative.

The Army Corps of Engineers, which is in charge of issuing permits for construction on the island, has arranged a meeting between the environmentalists and me so we can work through some of our issues. If I can win the environmentalists' support for the project, I will have taken a big step toward receiving a permit to build, which will be good news for my investors and I. With that said, if I make too many concessions to the environmentalists, it could negatively impact the projected financial performance of the hotel. The hotel is only projected to turn a profit of $25,000 the first year, although I have forecast that profits should increase substantially after that. At any rate, as a business owner it is my responsibility to project my margins, or, if possible, to even increase them.

Issues and Objectives common mistake in negotiating is failing to fully research and understand the other side's perspective (Bacal, No date). Therefore, I must make an effort to fully appreciate the environmentalists' issues, what their objectives may be during negotiations, and what tactics they may use to achieve their objectives. To restate, the Sanibel Island environmentalists' issues with my planned hotel development are as follows:

1) They are opposed to the walkway that would connect the hotel with the swimming pool, as the pavement would result in a loss of wetlands.

2) They are concerned that the parking lots and access roads that are being built will result in run-off that could pollute the island's freshwater resources.

A must bear in mind that these are not necessarily the only objections the environmentalists have -- they are simply the only objections of which I am currently aware. It is possible that the environmentalists could raise a host of issues ranging from pollution during the construction process to the types of materials that will be used. It is reasonable for me to expect that the environmentalists may not yet have shown all of their cards and that additional issues could surface at the negotiating table. but, for now, I will focus my preparation and strategy on the two issues that have been communicated to me.

My issues with the Sanibel Island environmental lobby are as follows:

1) I believe the three-story limit on building height is extreme, bad for business, and out of line with the policies of similar resort locations in Florida.

2) the risk to freshwater resources from runoff as a result of paving is, in my opinion, being overstated.

3) the objections to my plans to connect the hotel to the swimming pool are unreasonable. Any loss of wetlands will be replaced, as required by law, and if I do not connect the hotel to the pool it will adversely impact the desirability of my hotel to tourists.

The main objective of the environmentalists, I must assume, is to compel me to build as environmentally friendly a hotel as possible. As was mentioned, this would include requiring me to build a retention pond and buffer zone to protect freshwater resources from pavement runoff, and possibly forbidding me to build a walkway connecting the hotel to the swimming pool.

To compel me to act, the environmentalists could threaten to withhold support for the hotel construction. This, really, is a dramatic approach -- a nuclear option, if you will. Beyond that, the environmentalists may use a carrot-and-stick approach. The stick, obviously, is withholding support for construction. The carrots, which would be incentives to require me to act, could involve concessions on other issues, such as building height.

My objective is to win some concessions from the environmentalists that would maintain or enhance the profitability of the hotel. My chief responsibility is to protect the investment my investors and I have made in this project and to ensure a good return on that investment. I need to keep a slim first-year margin of $25,000 from disappearing, which could occur if I am forced to fund more expensive environmental initiatives. Although the hotel is projected to increase its profitability significantly after the first year, as business grows and debt service shrinks, those projections may not be met if key hotel features, such as a walkway connecting the hotel to the swimming pool, can not be developed.

While protecting margins is critical, I also will pursue opportunities to make the site more profitable. The chief way to enhance the profitability of the hotel is to increase the number of floors. If I can increase the hotel size from three to four floors, I have the opportunity to realize 33% more revenue. Also, because I have 450 feet of beach frontage, that is an entire additional floor of ocean-view rooms that I may be able to charge a premium for. So, while I need to protect myself from expensive… READ MORE

How to Reference "Negotiation Project Sanibel Island" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Project Management Essay

A good project priority system supports the management efforts and develops a culture in which every member of the organization contributes to the goals of the organization (Gray, & Larson,… read more

Essay 6 pages (2018 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Project Management Scenario a Global Consumer Electronics Case Study

Project Management

Scenario

A global consumer electronics company is interested in expanding its business by developing vehicle-mounted PDAs (Personal Digital Assistant). The vehicle-mounted PDA is the compact computer terminals that… read more

Case Study 9 pages (2476 words) Sources: 10 Style: Harvard Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Negotiation Strategies and Procedures Essay

Negotiation and Strategies and Procedures

According to van Wanrooy, there are a number of fundamental problems facing women in the workplace in Australia. Many of these are the result of… read more

Essay 3 pages (1019 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Women / Feminism

---

Negotiations Arusha Peace Process in Rwanda Term Paper

Negotiations-Arusha Peace Process in Rwanda

Analyze the success/failure of negotiations to resolve the dispute.

Two warring factions in Rwanda signed Arusha accord on August 3, 1993: Government of Rwanda (GoR)… read more

Term Paper 9 pages (2456 words) Sources: 8 Topic: African History / Africa

---

Project Management the Wedding Term Paper

Project Management of the Wedding

Project management the wedding

Work breakdown structure

Responsibility Allocation

Network Diagram

The purpose of the report is to identify specific activities for wedding planning of… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1815 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>