Assessment on "Rethinking Curriculum in Education for Sustainability"

Assessment 10 pages (3030 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Rethinking Curriculum in Education for Sustainability in Private Education in Victoria, Australia: Curriculum Research Project

"Sustainability" has become a veritable buzzword in recent years that has a wide range of connotations. Companies competing in extraction industries such as oil and gas, logging, and mining, for example, have all been exhorted to develop sustainable business practices to protect their industries for future generations. Calls for a comprehensive curriculum in education for sustainability started in earnest during the 1970s and the need has become more pronounced since that time. Unfortunately, despite a growing body of knowledge concerning the importance of education for sustainability, many educational institutions remain at a loss concerning how best to deliver these educational services and what content they should include. To determine the current state of affairs with regards to education for sustainability in general and in private educational settings in Victoria, Australia in particular, this study reviews the relevant literature to develop a background and overview of the issues, followed by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Analysis

By most accounts, time is running out for the human race and the need for action is immediate. According to Siraj-Blatchford (2009), "It is now widely recognised that humanity faces urgent problems affecting local, regional and global environments, and social and economic development. The Earth's limited natural resources are being consumed more rapidly than they are being replaced, and the effects of global warming upon ecological balance and bio-diversity are well-known" (p. 9). Not surprisingly, in response to these well-documented environmental crises, the past 40 years or so have been characterized by increasing calls for environmental education initiatives by various governmental and international organizations. For example, Palmer (1999) emphasizes that, "In recent years, alongside world-wide acceptance of the need for sustainable development, and education for sustainability, there has been an ever-increasing focus in the environmental education literature on the crucial importance of education for the environment in particular" (p. 137). Indeed, Elliott and Davis (2009) cite a fundamental misperception that education for sustainability places a higher priority on conceptual knowledge than it does on important values and skills such as problem solving, creativity and collaboration in its curricular offerings, thereby diminishing its value in formulating complex solutions to these complex problems. According to Elliott and Davis, "This is an erroneously narrow view of education for sustainability as being simply about the acquisition of knowledge about environmental topics. We suggest that this is founded on outdated transmissive modes of learning which do not reflect current pedagogical thinking" (2009, p. 66). This erroneous view of education for sustainability has caused some educators to either undervalue its potential or misapply its precepts, making revisions to current curricula even more imperative. For example, Elliott and Davis (2009) stress that, "The long-term health and survival of human populations and the health of global natural systems are closely entwined. The need for fundamental changes in how we live has become impossible to ignore. Education has a key role and all sectors must be a part of re-imagining and transforming current unsustainable patterns of living" (p. 65).

These calls for education for sustainability curricular offerings are based in large part on the perceived benefits that accrue to the provision of such educational services, including the following:

1. Education for sustainability enables people to understand the inter-dependence of all life on this planet, and the repercussions that their actions and decisions may have both now and in the future on resources, on the global community as well as their local one, and on the total environment;

2. Education for sustainability increases people's awareness of the economic, political, social, cultural, technological and environmental forces which foster or impede sustainable development;

3. Education for sustainability develops people's awareness, competence, attitudes and values, enabling them to be effectively involved in sustainable development at local, national and international level, and helping them to work towards a more equitable and sustainable future. In particular, it enables people to integrate environmental and economic decision-making;

4. Education for sustainability affirms the validity of the different approaches contributed by environmental education, and development education and the need for the further development and integration of the concepts of sustainability in these and other related cross-disciplinary educational approaches, as well as other established disciplines (Palmer, 1999, p. 139)..

The increasing calls for such educational offerings to realize these benefits, though, have been characterized by different priorities being advanced and various solutions advocated with no clear direction emerging from the debate concerning which curricular offerings are best suited to achieve the overarching goals of providing effective education in sustainability (Moon, Ben-Peretz & Brown, 2000). Indeed, Kennelly and Taylor (2007) report that, "Although the need for education for sustainability in education is well recognised, little has been published to indicate how this might be incorporated into university courses in Australia" (p. 3). Therefore, it is important to national and local governments in this part of the world to refocus their efforts to rethink curricular offerings in education for sustainability in general and in private education in particular. According to Moon and his associates, the impact of these trends on educational institutions seeking to develop appropriate curricula for education in sustainability have been profoundly constraining: "Schools and teachers struggle to find their own path through a bewildering mixture of often contradictory advice and guidance, and amid doubts about their effectiveness and progress" (Moon et al., 2000, p. 489).

Because resources are by definition scarce, it is vitally important that the curricular offerings that are developed for education for sustainability programs are effective, timely and relevant. For instance, Palmer (1999) emphasizes that, "Successful examples of sustainable development should be built into the curriculum" (p. 139). There also remains a lack of comprehensive approaches in place, though, that can be used as a set of best practices by educational institutions seeking to implement or refine such programs. In this regard, Paris (2002) points out that, "There has been increasing recognition that environmental education as it has been traditionally taught is not enough to stem the current environmental crisis. It needs to embrace a more holistic paradigm, one that incorporates the ecological, economic, social, cultural, and personal dimensions of sustainable development and their inter-relationships" (p. 100). Other educators emphasize the need for additional research to help address these gaps. In this regard, Davies, Engdahl, Otieno, Pramling-Samuelson, Siraj-Blatchford and Vallab recently observed that, "As an emerging field of practice, Education for Sustainability is seriously under-researched. This must be remedied in order to build the field on an evidence-base of critique, reflection and creativity" (2009, p. 114).

Many of the initiatives that have been intended to encourage environmental education through the Asia-Pacific region in recent years have been promoted by ministries of environment, agriculture or natural resources instead of educational ministries (Yencken, Fien and Sykes, 2000). Although these efforts have been needed, the initiatives promoted by these non-educational ministries have largely been focused on specific environmental issues instead of a comprehensive governmental commitment to sustainability; moreover, many of these initiatives have assumed the form of public awareness campaigns focused on changing individual behaviors rather than on system-wide approaches to education in sustainability (Yencken et al., 2000).

The cumulative net effect of this dearth of action by ministries of education in countries such as Australia has been "to marginalize environmental education from mainstream education policy. As a result, it is often not a priority, especially where the curriculum is overcrowded. In addition, the low profile of environmental education and sustainable development in external examination subjects contributes to a lack of status for this area of learning" (2000, p. 253). Consequently, environmental education is not widely regarded as a curricular priority by teachers, students or parents in many parts of Australia. This paucity of awareness on the part of the important stakeholders in the educational process has made it even more difficult to provide a comprehensive program of instruction in sustainability. As Yencken and his colleagues emphasize, "This makes the introduction of both in-service and pre-service teacher education for sustainability difficult and, unfortunately, when in-service courses are provided, they tend to be attended by teachers who are already committed to environmental education" (2000, p. 253). Moreover, Kennelly and Taylor also cite the lack of pre-service sustainable educational opportunities for teachers in Australia. According to these authorities, while teachers require a thorough understanding of education for sustainability in order to communicate these concepts to their students, "Sustainability education is poorly represented in Australian teacher training courses at the present time" (Kennelly & Taylor, 2007, p. 4). Likewise, Ferreira, Ryan and Tilbury emphasize that, "Teacher education is widely recognised as a key strategy that is yet to be effectively utilised to embed environmental education and/or education for sustainability in schools" (2007, p. 45).

This "perfect storm" of constraining conditions has resulted in a situation where the introduction of education for sustainability has been even more challenging. In this regard, Yencken et al. conclude, "As a result, the official as well as the… READ MORE

How to Reference "Rethinking Curriculum in Education for Sustainability" Assessment in a Bibliography

Related Assessments:

Sustainable Development Is the Process That Responds Term Paper

Sustainable Development is the process that responds to the needs of current population without destroy any of opportunities and needs for future population.

What Sustainable Development is about:

Environment and… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (4234 words) Sources: 5 Style: Chicago Topic: Environment / Conservation / Ecology

---

Corporate Universities Investigation of Their Development Internationally in the Field Sector of Tourism Term Paper

Corporate universities"-investigation of their development internationally in the field/sector of tourism.

In this paper, it will be discussed how corporate universities function internationally and otherwise. From there, their development process… read more

Term Paper 60 pages (16387 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Recreation / Leisure / Tourism

---

Cities in International Politics Research Proposal

City Diplomacy: The Increasing Role of Cities in International Politics

Over the past several decades, there has been a tendency for cities to be involved internationally and this is stated… read more

Research Proposal 69 pages (18927 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics

---

Sociology History of Business Science Research Proposal

Delimitations

Today, modern business systems help an increasingly globalized world function in seamless ways. In fact, English is rapidly becoming the lingua franca of the business world and transnational borders… read more

Research Proposal 75 pages (20751 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Telecommuting There Are Many Different Ways Term Paper

Telecommuting

There are many different ways to look at telecommuting. Depending on the country one comes from, there are conflicting opinions on exactly what the word means, and the same… read more

Term Paper 27 pages (8212 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>