Term Paper on "Compare the Relation Between Religions and the State in Europe"

Term Paper 8 pages (3296 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

religions and the state in Europe

State interference in religion in Germany and Austria

The question of a state interfering in religion occurs when a group of religious believers feel that it is superior to other believers and decides to issue an order for the commoner to behave in a particular manner due to their religious beliefs. The latest situations regarding the importance of religion are concerning the Islamic faith. In this month, there has been a fatwa from leaders of Muslims in America saying that the attacks of September 11 were not religiously justifiable. There were also criticisms of the fatwa, saying that it was so broad that the fatwa was meaningless and should have mentioned specific groups of Muslims for the incident. Thus the fatwa was viewed as an instrument for the improvement of image for Muslims rather than discussing the entire issue. Another widely condemned attack has occurred in Britain and there were two groups of Muslims who denounced the same, and among them one said that suicide bombing could be justified against an attacking power, while the other group said that such an attack could not be justified. The problem is getting worse as Islam unlike Christianity has no ordained clergy or central authority who can hand down orders. Thus there have been fatwa from Iran asking for violence and fatwa from America condemning it.

Thesis Statement:

Religion is a personal matter and no authority has any right to issue orders to a believer saying how he should act as a believer in a religion.

Why these countries are chosen for analysis?

The aim of this paper is to study the influence of the state using its powers for the support of one religion in a particular form or the other. In the case of these two states, it is important to realize that both these states are very near each other, the populations of the two states are from the same basic ethnic stock, and in many cases they have been even ruled by one king or emperor. Thus in normal course, the religion or religious tendencies should have been the same, but has that happened?

Analysis of religion in Germany and Austria:

In the analysis of religion in these two countries, let us go alphabetically and first look at Austria. The rulers of Austria were the Habsburgs and the leading political representatives of Roman Catholicism during the period of conflict with Protestant Reformation in Central Europe during the entire sixteenth and seventeenth century. Let us remember that Protestant Reformation started to a large extent in Germany. Even today, Austria is a predominantly Roman Catholic country. At the same time, the Habsburgs were religiously heterodox and the real reasons behind the start of many of the smaller denominations that exist even today. This spirit of religious tolerance has come from the enlightened absolutism of the late eighteenth century. This freedom was then fixed to the soul of Austria with the constitution of 1867. Even at the end of the eighteenth century, twelve religious communities were recognized officially in Austria - Roman Catholic; Protestant which was Lutheran and Calvin; Greek, Serbian, Romanian, Russian, and Bulgarian Orthodox; Jewish; Muslim; Old Catholic; Methodist and Mormon.

However the principal role was then for the Roman Catholic Church or Vatican and the status was decided through a number of treaties or concordats between Vatican and the Republic of Austria. This led to the influence of the Catholic Church continuing in public life even after 1918. One of the ways that this happened was that many members of the Church hierarchy openly supported the Christian Social Party. This got a response from the other parties and the Social Democratic Workers' Party became anti-clerical in the period between the two World Wars. Some of the Roman Catholics also tried to have a form of "political Catholicism" and this meant that they were both anti-Liberal and anti-SDAP. These sympathies are very deeply rooted and had led to the formation of a "Christian Corporate State" in 1934.

That sort of a situation is not possible now as the position of religion is clearly defined in the present constitution with articles 14, 15 and 16. These clearly state that full freedom of religion and conscience is guaranteed to all. The enjoyment of civil and political rights has been made totally independent of any religious beliefs, at the same time the performance of civil duties cannot be influenced by religious beliefs. The little confusion that arises is from the sub-clause "No one shall be forced to perform any religious rite or to participate in any religious ceremony except in so far as he is subject to another who has legal authority in this matter."

What will be the interpretation of this law by a judge cannot be anticipated. The rights clearly state that all recognized churches and religious societies will have the public right to conduct their worship, regulate and administer its internal affairs independently and remain in possession and enjoyment of all its establishments, institutions and property to be used for the purpose of religion, education and charity. The societies are however subject to the general laws of the state. Even when a particular religion is not officially recognized, they are permitted to worship in private as long as their religion does not interfere with laws or public morals.

The situation in recent times has changed, and the Roman Catholic Church has not given public and active support to any particular political party. There was one occasion when they became actively involved and that was in 1970s when the question came up of legislation for abortion in Austria. This also changed the attitudes of the political parties towards the Church and the Socialist Party of Austria developed a more accommodating attitude to it, and this could not have been thought of in the period before the Second World War. In the meantime, changes have also taken place in the religious affiliations of the population and according to the 1991 census the majority of Austrians were with the Roman Catholic Church. The share of population with them was 77.9% as compared to the 87.2% share that was with them in 1971. The share of Protestants also declined during the period and the major group among them, the Lutherans or members of the Augsburg Confession declined from a share of 5.7% in 1971 to 4.8% in 1991. Similarly the share of Calvinists or members of the Helvetic Confession dropped from 0.3% earlier to 0.2% in the same census.

The question naturally comes as to which religion gained adherents, and the answer is simple - the Austrians who do not profess any religion and their share increased from 4.3% in 1971 to 8.6% in 1991. This is probably helping one of the political parties which say that there should be no religious affiliation. This reminds us of the infamous saying "Religion is the opium of the people." Without getting personal about religion, one can clearly say that in Austria when the state interference has been removed, the status of all religions is shifting to a common ground.

Now let us get into the religious position of the other country - Germany. It would be useful to remember that both these countries are actually parts of one country and this can be seen in the fact that they speak a language which is similar and both were parts of the Holy Roman Empire. The separation came in the first half of the seventeenth century due to the last of the great wars of religion, in what is now called as the Thirty Years War which lasted from 1618 to 1648. This was a direct struggle for power between Protestants and Catholics and also between the local kingdoms forming parts of the empire. At the end of the war, France became the most powerful state in Europe as it succeeded in replacing the Habsburgs in both Spain and the Holy Roman Empire of Germany. The worst loser was probably Germany as it separated into some 300 separate states. The Catholic portions of Austria were with the Habsburgs and they probably lost the most during this war. They could not think of consolidating under their rule any more. Germany was split into Catholics, Lutherans and Calvinists in different states. The religion of the ruler determined the religion of the people. (The Seventeenth Century)

The two states to emerge as the most powerful in the region were Catholic Austria and Lutheran Prussia, and they formed for the basis of the loose confederation which was still called the Holy Roman Empire. Here one can clearly see the influence of religion in creating countries, and thus the religion of some individuals created different states. This of course may be called the interference of religion into states and not the interference of states into religions. How did all this start? In 1517, it was Martin Luther who challenged papal authority as he viewed… READ MORE

How to Reference "Compare the Relation Between Religions and the State in Europe" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Ethics Epistemology Religion Term Paper

Religion

This work looks at the concept of religion by first explaining its definition. It argues about whether God really exists and takes the standpoint that He does exist. The… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2442 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Religion as a Possible Determinant of Fertility Rate Term Paper

Religion as a Determinant in Fertility

Summary and suggestions

The studies reviewed and analyzed take a look at how religion affects birth and fertility in married or paired women throughout… read more

Term Paper 22 pages (7679 words) Sources: 15 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Place of Religion in Our Society Term Paper

Religion in Our Society

The history of many states includes the relations of secular and church powers, of state and religious organizations. In order to understand the core the place… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (2981 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Judaism Christianity Islam Term Paper

Religion

CHRISTIANITY, JUDAISM & ISLAM

Historically, Christianity began as a small sect within Judaism several thousand years ago, thus, both religions share a common history and common geography, meaning that… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (993 words) Sources: 6 Style: MLA Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Comparing and Contrasting Vodou and Santeria in the Caribbean Term Paper

Religion

Comparing and Contrasting Vodou and Santeria in the Caribbean

Though, as shown in the works of comparative mythology, all religion is syncretic, the term is most appropriate to certain… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2523 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>