Research Proposal on "Recruitment First of All, Before Even Deciding"

Research Proposal 10 pages (2658 words) Sources: 0 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Recruitment

First of all, before even deciding on the selection mechanism and evaluating the results and CVs that the different individuals have sent, we need to have a brief discussion around the different requirements that such a position imposes, as well as about what is likely to make a good store manager. The tests will help in determining whether the chosen individuals actually fit the required parameters. The results will also help us shape an appropriate set of hiring practices for any future such action within the organization.

The position is that of a very important store manager. The store is important because of several different reasons, including the fact that this is close to the very first Tanglewood store (thus the symbolic value the store has) and the fact that this is a store with very strong revenues in the past couple of years (a variable which shows that a set of strong, loyal customers has already been formed and that the new manager will need to ensure the consumers' loyalty in the future as well, while at the same time attempting to increase the market share for the respective store).

At the same time, this store is also a store where different appearances and themes combine to make it a very elaborate store - this means that the store manager will also need to prove imagination and creativity to keep these additional features, improve them and blend them into the store activities. As we can see, the potential candidate will need to combine a set of different characteristics and attitudes in order to make a successful store manager.

The selection tests that have been used on the applicants closely follow the KSAO framework in that they attempt to cover and investigate four important areas of each of the candidates. These areas refer to knowledge, skills, abilities and other areas and should constitute themselves as an overall evaluation instrument. In terms of knowledge, we are testing how well each of the applicants is accommodated to the retail industry, what his background in the industry is and how well the candidate will be able to provide the necessary background for his employees, when this becomes necessary at some point. The knowledge part will also include a small part of managerial knowledge and it will be a plus if the candidate has worked in managerial positions in the past. This will come to show that he or she is used to the main human resources characteristics, that he or she has a background knowledge on motivational policies, selection and recruitment methodologies for further diversification of the team etc.

On the other hand, we are also testing skills and abilities. By this we are trying to cover essential parts of the activity as a store manager, especially one in such an important store. This ranges from abilities that would make a good manger (the capacity to interrelate with the employees, the capacity to promote and support ideas, the capacity to create the right working environment) to abilities and skills required for this particular job, including, for example, the capacity to be inventive and creative.

The biodata will measure the candidate's experience in different competency-related activities and tasks, while the Marshfield Applicant Exam is measuring the candidate's ability to solve problems and his or her mathematical and numerical process abilities. As seen, each of these tests will not necessarily point to the perfect candidate for the position, but will give us a better idea of how each of these candidates is performing on different segments that are important for the position.

I think we can use two different scoring methodologies, each potentially providing a result which reflects the candidate's abilities. These two scoring methodologies will include the weighted and the non-weighted version. The weighted version will tend to attribute a higher importance to some of the tests, mainly because we would assume that the respective characteristics and abilities that those tests reflect are more important for the current position. Each weight will need to add up to one, so a potentially weighting system can be the following:

biodata - 0.1. We attribute least importance to the biodata, because we find it too general and not reflexive enough of the candidate's abilities and skills.

A applicant exam - 0.1 retail knowledge 0.4. Most important test because it will show us the retail background of the candidate and will give us a good idea whether or not he will be able to assume a store manager position. Weighing the retail knowledge in this manner will mean that the position will basically be chosen based on the knowledge competency - note that this is twice as important as any of the other four tests.

A conscientiousness - 0.2 We want to see a candidate who is very interesting in doing his job right and very thorough in this sense. This is why conscientiousness is also weighed quite significantly high.

A extraversion - 0.2. Our candidate needs to be extrovert - to bond easily with the people around him, to communicate and interrelate with them. At the same time, we are also checking through the extraversion tests, his or her capacity to be imaginative and creative, as usually people who are creative and imaginative will also tend to be extrovert individuals.

The non-weighted score will simply add up all the scores obtained by a candidate and this will reflect the final score he or she has obtained on all the scores and his final total.

In both methods, James Heckman scored best, a total of 380 in the non-weighted approach and a weighted score of 74, the only candidate to obtain a weighted score of over 70. Given the fact that he came out with the highest total in both cases shows the consistency of both methodologies as compared one against the other. It is interesting to note, however, that James did not score the highest score in the category of tests which was weighted as the most important: retail knowledge. The other two candidates in the list are Thomas Reznor and Shauna Greer (weighted score) and Thomas Reznor and Max Renoir (non-weighted score).

In my opinion, the multiple hurdle selection procedure provides a more thorough approach to the selection process by taking into consideration a larger array of instruments and including different phases to the selection process. However, we also need to consider that this is a very time consuming methodology and that individuals in the upper management of the organization will need to find the time to go through the interviews and resumes. Given the importance of this particular store, the method is viable to be used. The final panel should probably include somebody from the top management of the company (maybe the COO would be a good idea), the marketing director (given some of the innovatory approaches of the store), the human resource manager and someone from the employees' side (maybe the union leader).

A short browse through the revenues does indeed show that James seems to be the most qualified to take on the store manager position. Besides the fact that he has managed to obtained the highest scores according to two different methodologies, his experience in retail, despite the fact that he has not scored so highly on the retail knowledge test, goes back almost 20 years, all the time he has spent with Tanglewood. He has moved through different retail and managerial positions with the company, performing as sales associate, but also as a department manager, for example, just a step before the store manager function.

The fact that he generally stayed a long period of time in each of these positions show the fact that he was able to interconnect well with the people working with him, qualifying him to be a successful manager.

The selection process for other store will include:

set of tests: retail knowledge, personality test, extroversion, human relations;

An assessment of the employees with a direct meeting with them - this will remain anonymous;

An interview with the human resource manager, the COO, the promotion director and the sales manager.

2) There are several conclusions that can be drawn even before starting an introspective analysis of some of the causes of the high turnover rates and before looking deeper into the signification of some of the satisfaction and turnover rate figures. First of all, the figures are anything but homogenous. Indeed, if we take, for example, the pay satisfaction, this ranges from a very satisfied Colorado (4.7) to a more than unsatisfied Northern Oregon (1.5) - it is difficult to believe that the living standards and price ranges vary so much from Northern Oregon to Colorado, so this is probably a reflection of the wide range of perception from the employees.

On the other hand, the variation for the supervisor satisfaction is significantly lower and, in general, it ranges around a 3.2-3.4 mean value. If we notice the figure in this category, none of the stores… READ MORE

How to Reference "Recruitment First of All, Before Even Deciding" Research Proposal in a Bibliography

Related Research Proposals:

Decided to Install Condom Dispensers in All of the Rest Rooms Essay

install condom dispensers in all of the rest rooms.

In favor of condom vending machines at Camden County College

Recently, objections have been raised to Camden County College's decision to… read more

Essay 2 pages (822 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA Topic: Sexuality / Gender

---

Women and Gender Bias Thesis

Women and Gender Bias

The purpose of the present paper is to discuss the implications of gender bias and the consequences of Affirmative Action. To be more specific, we will… read more

Thesis 42 pages (13238 words) Sources: 40 Topic: Race / Ethnic Studies / Racism

---

Recruiting and Selection Process for Personnel in a School District Term Paper

Rio Linda Dist. Recruiting & Hiring

Review of Personnel Recruitment and Selection Processes within the Rio Linda School District

This study focuses on reviewing current recruiting and hiring practices, under… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1630 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

History of Espionage Class Reading Essay

The chapter also circles back to the "Cambridge Five," and how even with Soviet spy Kim Philby placed so highly in the British Secret Service, the Soviet leader's inability to… read more

Essay 27 pages (7517 words) Sources: 29 Topic: World History

---

Immigrants Serving in the U.S. Military Research Paper

Except for the indigenous Native American population, the United States is truly a country of immigrants. Indeed, most modern Americans can trace their ancestry to the nations of Europe, Asia… read more

Research Paper 30 pages (8783 words) Sources: 12 Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>