Essay on "Problem of Evil Is Evil Really"

Essay 3 pages (1082 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Problem of Evil

Is Evil Really a "Problem" for Theists?

Throughout history, the persistence of evil has posed problems for conventional theistic belief systems. Crime, pain, disease, and other "evils" continue to make the world what Hume called "a diversity of distress and sorrow" (72), and yet a God that is omnipotent, omniscient, and benevolent would logically have acted to prevent such suffering. Generations of philosophers have argued that because we can all point to evil in the absence of equally compelling evidence for a God defined in these terms, God does not exist. However, I would argue that many of these arguments are stated in overly simplistic terms or else themselves frame the relationship between God and evil in overly simplistic ways -- the truth is more complex.

Theistic arguments from evil traditionally begin with the Greeks; Epicurus is often cited as the first recorded figure to ask how a good, strong God can coexist with suffering (Larrimore xix). If we insist on a good God, the argument goes, then the presence of evil makes God weak; if we insist on a strong God, then that God is evidently not good at all. And if an entity is neither strong nor good, can it be divine? While this line of reasoning has "disturbed" theistic philosophers since at least the 3rd Century CE (Lactantius 50), it would be naive to consider it compelling proof of the nonexistence of any divine entity.

In fact, theistic writers have usually conceded that the persistence of suffering only serves as evidence that, on the one hand, "evil" has been misunderstood as being incompatible with ultimate benevolence or, on the other, that God has been misunderstood as being in some way incompatible with the world. The earliest known rebuttals to the argument from evil posit that even a benevolent God can get angry with created entities -- "just" anger motivated to correct evil -- and that even an omnipotent God is not necessarily scrutable. As the early Christian apologist Lactantius notes, God may be omniscient but we are not: "The mind of man, walled in by the darksome dwelling-place of his body, is removed far from an accurate view of truth" (47).

Lactantius employs this notion of human fallibility (an "evil" or flaw in creation in itself, but one that hinges more on free will for its solution) to challenge those who follow the Epicurean conclusions that either God does not exist or has no active moral disposition toward either good or evil. Perhaps the phenomena we commonly (mis-) interpret as "evil" actually serve some inscrutable higher good, and thus negate the apparent contradiction posed by God's putative benevolence. Those who follow this theodicial approach then attempt to explicate this higher good in order to produce evidence of that divine benevolence, whether it resides in the "soul-making" or evolutionary approach recently spearheaded by John Hick (355-61), the more abstract "best of all possible worlds" of Leibniz (191-200), or elsewhere

Modern attempts to defend the argument from evil on evidential or probabilistic grounds gloss over this idea of "hidden" good within apparent evil by focusing on what we currently know. Because "evil" necessarily signifies an experience in which we have not yet been able to locate an… READ MORE

How to Reference "Problem of Evil Is Evil Really" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Existence of Evil Proves That God Essay

Problem of Evil

One of the oldest arguments against the existence of a supposedly omniscient, omnipotent, and omni-benevolent god proposes that this god is logically inconsistent with the "evil" observed… read more

Essay 8 pages (2755 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Evil Is Ambiguous Term Paper

evil is ambiguous as it has many different meanings. Evil can be either morally bad or wrong, it can cause pain or injury and is supposed to be a manifestation… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1970 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Question of Evil Research Proposal

Question of Evil

One of the most challenging questions that faces Christian -- theologians, clergy, and the laity -- is why does God permit there to be evil in the… read more

Research Proposal 6 pages (1702 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Social Problems Accuracy of the Uniform Crime Term Paper

Social Problems

Accuracy of the Uniform Crime Reports

The accuracy of the data of the Uniform Crime Reports is criticized on a number of grounds. Firstly, the mentioned reports only… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1968 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Theistic Response to the Atheism of H.J Term Paper

Theistic Response to the Atheism of H.J. McCloskey

For a Christian -- a person whose belief in God and Jesus Christ is unshakable and spiritually sustaining -- God is the… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1961 words) Sources: 4 Style: Turabian Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>