Thesis on "Comparing Assessing the Impact of Political or Economic Globalization Between Two Countries"

Thesis 10 pages (3336 words) Sources: 9 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Political or Economic Globalization Between Two Countries: China and India

The following work is of the nature that focuses on comparison and assessment of the impact of political or economic globalization and specifically as related to two particular countries which are those of India and China.

Despite its many critical views, globalization not only spreads democracy, but it also increases efficiency and therefore increases prosperity as well. Globalization is a realistic route out of poverty for the world's poorer populations.

The methodology employed in the present study is one that is qualitative in nature and that involves a review of literature and specifically peer-reviewed professional or academic literature.

Literature Review

In a 2003 speech entitled: "Globalization and Its Challenges" Stanley Fischer states that the debate4 over globalization "is lively, often passionate, and has sometimes been violent. At least until recently, it has been intensifying." Fischer states that the debate is both "untidy and ill-defined..." (2003) Fischer defines globalization as "the ongoing process of greater interdependence among countries and their citizens" and states that globalization is "complex and multifaceted." (2003)

The largest challenge of globalization is that of poverty and according to Fischer "the surest route to sustained poverty reduction is economic growth." (2003) Growth however, makes a requirement of good economic policies and according to Fischer, "the evidence strongly supports the conclusion that growth requires a policy framework that prominently includes an orientation towards integration into the global economy." (2003) Fischer states that this effectively places obligations on the following three groups: (1) those who are most responsible for the operation of the international economy (governments of developed countries); (2) those who determine the intellectual climate (government and non-government organizations and individuals); and (3) government of developing countries who bear the major responsibility for economic policy in their countries. (Fischer, 2003)

Economic globalization, which is described as "...the ongoing process of greater economic interdependence among countries" is stated to be reflected "...in the increasing amount of cross-border trade in goods and services, the increasing volume of international financial flows and increasing the flows of labor." (Fischer, 2003)

Fischer (2003) states that the vision of the founders of the Bretton Woods system was one in which the "restoration of goods and services" was an element that was "essential to the recovery of the global economy" however, their views of capital flows were stated to have not been as benign. Capital flows did however recover in the 1950s decade "and intensified in the 1960s." (Fischer, 2003) Capital flows grew more slowly to the developing countries consisting primarily of bank loans in the 1970s and 1980s but by the 1990s they are stated to have taken the form "mainly of foreign direct investment and purchase of marketable securities." (Fischer, 2003)

Globalization is however "much more than an economic phenomenon. The technological and political changes that drive the process of economic globalization have massive non-economic consequences." (Fischer, 2003) Fischer (2003) notes that Anthony Giddens, a leading sociologist stated of globalization as follows: "I would have not hesitation in saying that globalization, as we are experiencing it, is in many respects not only news, but also revolutionary...Globalization is political, technological and cultural as well as economic." (Fischer, 2003) Just as important as the economic aspects in shaping the international debate are the non-economic aspects." (Fischer, 2003, paraphrased) Fischer notes that many who object to globalization "resent the political and military dominance of the United States and they resent also the influence of foreign -- predominantly American -- culture, as they see it at the expense of national and local cultures." (Fischer, 2003)

The work of Chandrasekhar and Ghosh (2005) entitled: "Macroeconomic Policy, Inequality and Poverty Reduction in India and China" states that it is now "commonplace to regard China and India as the two economies in the developing world that are the 'success stories' of globalization, emerging into giant economies of the 21st century." (2005) Chandrasekhar and Ghosh states that the success is defined by the following: (1) The high and sustained rates of growth of aggregate and per capita national income; (2) The absence of major financial crises that have characterized a number of other emerging markets; and (3) Substantial reduction in income poverty. (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005) The economies of China and India are noted in the work of Chandrasekhar and Ghosh to be fundamentally different although China and India do have some "superficial attributes in common, including: (1) large populations covering substantial geographical areas; (2) regional diversity; and (3) relatively high rates of growth over the recent period. (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005)

However, "the institutional conditions in the two economies have been and remain very different." (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005) India has been a "traditional 'mixed' developing economy with significant private sector participation...since Independence..." (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005) Chandrasekhar and Ghosh state that the reforms that have been undertaken "in the phase of globalization have...substantially expanded the scope for private activity and reduced regulation." (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005)

The macroeconomic policies of India are stated to have been "designed and implemented in contexts similar to those in other capitalist economies, where involuntary unemployment is rampant and fiscal and monetary measures have been used to stimulate effective demand." (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005) The institutional structure in China however is stated to have bee "very different...for most of this period, where the basic elements of a command economy have been much more in evidence." (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005)

Chandrasekhar and Ghosh report that India "moved from a path characterized by a slow 3% 'Hindu rate of growth' on to a rather creditable growth trajectory involving GDP growth of around 5 to 6 per cent per annum from the early 1980s. That is, the recovery from a period when growth decelerated sharply starting in the mid-1960s did not begin with the "economic reform" of 1991, but a decade earlier." (2005) It is reported that a number of weaknesses "...characteristic of this otherwise creditable rate of growth" and those are stated as follows: (1) First, growth was far less pronounced in the commodity producing sectors than in services. In fact, during the 1990s, the rate of growth of per capita food production in the country was at its lowest level for decades; ( 2) Second, there were signs that this growth was accompanied by increased vulnerability inasmuch as it exploited the benefits for developing countries associated with the rise of finance internationally. Especially during the 1980s, growth was driven by debt financed public expenditure, which was supported with debt creating inflows from the international system. That resulted in a doubling of India's external debt to GDP ratio and led to a crisis in 1991 when a loss of investor confidence resulted in a freeze in such flows. Though during the 1990s non-debt creating inflows and remittances from migrant Indian workers abroad (particularly in Gulf countries) helped shore up the balance of payments, financial liberalization has encouraged volatile capital flows that imply that vulnerability is still a problem. This vulnerability is not immediately visible because of the large inflows on the current account of remittances from non-resident workers and earnings from software and IT-enabled services exports; (3) Further, the response of the central bank to the substantial inflows of portfolio capital involves purchasing foreign exchange to prevent excessive appreciation of the rupee. The consequent increase in India's foreign exchange reserves presents a picture of a strong balance of payments; and (4) Finally, very recent trends in the economy suggest that performance has been far below potential. This is illustrated by the extremely poor performance of agriculture and allied sectors and the increased volatility of industrial growth over the recent period. Indeed, only the services sector shows sustained high growth rates. (Chandrasekhar and Ghosh, 2005)

The following table, adapted from the work of Chandrasekhar and Ghosh present decadal compound rates of growth since the early 1950s, for Gross Domestic Product and per capita Net National Product at constant 1993-94 prices. It is evident that real GDP growth rates increased to a higher level in the last two decades. Increases in per capita income were even more marked because of the fall in the rate of population growth.

Figure 1

Annual rates of growth of national income in India

(per cent) Period

(year starting April)

Gross Domestic Product

Per capita Net National Product

1950-52 to 1960-62

3.9

1.8

1960-62 to 1970-72

3.5

1.2

1970-72 to 1980-82

3.5

1

1980-82 to 1990-92

5.6

2.9

1990-92 to 2000-02

5.6

3.5

Source: Chandrasekhar and Ghosh

The following table shows the changes in structure in the Indian economy beginning 1950-52 and running through 2000-2002.

Figure 2

Structural Change in the Indian Economy Per cent of GDP

Structural change in the Indian economy Per cent of GDP

Period

(year starting April)

Investment rate

Primary

Secondary

Tertiary

1950-52

15.5

59

13.4

27.6

1960-62

19.4

53.1

17.3

29.6

1970-72

23.8

46.6

20.4

33.0

1980-82

22.0

41.3

21.8

36.9

1990-92

26.0

34.4

24

41.6

2000-02

26.2

26.1

24.7

49.2

Source: Chandrasekhar and Ghosh

Chandrasekhar and… READ MORE

How to Reference "Comparing Assessing the Impact of Political or Economic Globalization Between Two Countries" Thesis in a Bibliography

Related Thesis Papers:

Role of Private Investment on Economic Development in Iraq Literature Review

Role of Private Investment on Economic Development in Iraq

Private investment in developing countries

An overview on early Empirical studies

In 1980s, the developing countries encountered some increment in their… read more

Literature Review 40 pages (14411 words) Sources: 45 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

International Marketing Assessing the Impact of U.S Term Paper

International Marketing

Assessing the Impact of U.S. Strategy

For Managing Trade Agreements

continues to lag the rest of the world on trade agreements, with President Obama and his staff citing… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (585 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Impact of Global Economic Crisis on the Nigerian Business Environment Research Proposal

Global Economic Crisis on the Nigerian Business Environment

Nigeria is a land of stark contrasts, a country in which the extremely wealthy live together with the starving individuals. This is… read more

Research Proposal 25 pages (8527 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

How Does Globalization Foster Economic Growth? Term Paper

globalization foster economic growth?

Globalization

Defining globalization

The term of globalization has been defined by numerous specialists under various forms. The most commonly used definition, which encompasses the most elements… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1414 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

In Defense of Globalization Term Paper

Defense of Globalization

This present age has been described as the Era of Globalization. It has replaced the Roaring 20s, the Cold War and the Space Age (Porter 2005) and… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (2822 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>