Essay on "One of the Policy Inquiries and Evaluations"
Essay 6 pages (1794 words) Sources: 4
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Policy EvaluationIn Forgotten Australians: A report on Australians who experienced institutional or out-of-home care as children, the Australian Senate attempts to create an overview of the history of children who have been removed from their homes in Australia. They were prompted by the fact that more than half a million children in Australia had been displaced from their homes. In addition, they had heard horrific stories of all types of abuse in these out-of-home placements, including emotional, physical, and sexual abuse in addition to neglect (Australian Senate, 2004). Even children who were not subject to abuse or to a physical level of neglect described a consistent lack of love and affection while in institutional settings, which seems to have contributed to lifelong issues related to trust and security (Australian Senate, 2004). In other words, this institutionalization has left a lifelong impact on many of them, which, given that they have often started families of their own, continues to negatively impact society. The goal of this research was to examine the history of displacement from homes, including the traditional reasons for displacement, and investigate the impact of that displacement on the impacted children.
Politics behind the Review
The review does not seem to be motivated by a single, identifiable political position. It was suggested by Senator Andrew Murray on March 4, 2003. Murray proposed a complete investigation into children who were displaced from their homes and placed in some type of governmental care. The investigation was to include whether the children faced any unsafe conditions, whether there were breaches of statuto
download full paper ⤓
Methods of Inquiry
The Senate began its inquiry by advertising in the Australian, Daily Telegraph and Herald Sun, and other print and electronic media (Australian Senate, 2004). The advertisements were aimed at those who had left governmental care (care leavers). Although there were deadlines for submissions, because the Committee wanted to get a comprehensive view of the scenario, it took submissions after its deadlines. "The Committee received 440 public submissions and 174 confidential submissions" (Australian Senate, 2004). These submissions covered a period from the 1920s to the 1990s. Moreover, it covered people who had been in governmental and non-governmental institutions or foster homes (Australian Senate, 2004). These submissions were personal in nature.
The methodology for the study was qualitative, as if focused on individual reports of individual experiences for those who had been displaced from their homes. The sheer volume of information led to the decision to produce two reports. The report being reviewed was the first of the two reports, and it focused on "children who were in institutional and out-of home care, mainly from the 1920s until the 1970s when deinstitutionalisation began to see large institutions replaced by smaller residential homes, foster care or other options such as placements with families for accommodating children in need of out-of-home care" (Australian Senate, 2004). In addition to describing specific children, the report focused on specific details, including: "background information on institutions and the governments' and churches' roles in placing children in care, the treatment of children in care and the long-term effects of experiences while in care. The issues of responsibility, acknowledgement and reparation are also canvassed, as are issues relating to accessing records and information and the provision of wide ranging services for care leavers which are critical in ensuring that they can improve their quality of life" (Australian Senate, 2004). The report itself is highly subjective. In many instances it uses the language of the submissions given by various care leavers. The subjective nature of the report is intentional; the Committee wanted those who read the report to have exposure to first-person accounts of what it meant to be a child in those scenarios. However, the subjective nature makes it important to realize that quantification from the report is almost impossible. The report attempts to describe what occurred to a number of children in care and how there were no efforts made to help transition them from this abuse to a normal life. It does not attempt to define how many children were abused in which way in each types of care.
Findings
The Committee made a number of findings about children in care. They found that abuse was pervasive in all types of care settings. They found that indigenous children were oftentimes targeted for abuse, and that this abuse in many ways was either genocidal or racially discriminatory in nature. For example, indigenous children were removed from homes without consideration to family kinship placement possibilities, were renamed, were punished for practicing their native religions, and were punished for speaking their own languages.
The Committee found a wide range of abusive behavior in care scenarios. This abuse included physical, sexual, mental, and emotional abuse as well as neglect. "Evidence included stories of children being inadequately clothed and so desperately hungry as to eat scraps from bins; only being permitted to have a bath once a week (in shared water); being locked in small dark places and enduring severe punishments and beltings that would draw blood" (Australian Senate, 2004). In large institutions, children were often depersonalized and record keeping was insufficient, so that children might not have access to critical personal information, such as their own birthdates (Australian Senate, 2004). In addition, the Committee found widespread sexual abuse. In fact, the Committee received complaints of sexual abuse "perpetrated by clergy, officers and staff, other residents, or visitors to the institution, emerged about almost all of the institutions" (Australian Senate, 2004).
Perhaps more important than findings of specific abuse, was the fact that the Committee recognized what a care leaver had described about life in an institution. "Apart from specific acts of emotional, mental, physical, psychological and sexual abuse, institutional life itself is inherently abusive: It was abusive to be kept in an institution separate from your family. It was abusive to be denied rights as a human being, such as affection and relationships" (Australian Senate, 2004).
The Committee found that the impact of this abuse had a lifelong duration that continued to plague many care leavers well into their adulthood. Some examples of lingering impact included problems with interpersonal relationships, insecurity, depression, and even suicidal behavior (Australian Senate, 2004).
Conclusions / Recommendations
The Committee's recommendations are too extensive to be described in a short policy analysis. Therefore, this analysis will highlight the seemingly most important of those recommendations. First, the Committee suggests that the Commonwealth, state governments, local governments, churches, and any other local agencies that were involved in the displacement of kids into the care system issue apologies for the negative impact of that care (Australian Senate, 2004). Next, the Committee suggests that governments consider changing their statutes of limitations to permit victims to seek compensation for damages (Australian Senate, 2004). Next, the Committee suggests a series of legal changes that would make it easier for victims to sue in the event of continued abuses in the care system (Australian Senate, 2004). Another suggestion is that the government establish a national reparations fund (Australian Senate, 2004). In addition, the Committee wants the government to establish a review board to process complaints about the care system (Australian Senate, 2004). Furthermore, they want an open policy with churches and other organizations having to publish any allegations of abuse from this point forward and require them to open their records about any prior allegations of abuse, with… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "One of the Policy Inquiries and Evaluations" Assignment:
Policy Analysis Report Undertake a critical review of one of the policy inquiries and evaluations listed below. Pay particular attention to the politics that lay behind the commissioning of the review; the methods of inquiry and the nature of the evidence used; the findings of the inquiry (in brief); the conclusions or recommendations arising from the inquiry; and the impact of the review on current policy or practice. The Report: The Australian Senates Inquiry Forgotten Australians: A report on Australians who experienced institutional or out-of-home care as children (2004) ***** *****
How to Reference "One of the Policy Inquiries and Evaluations" Essay in a Bibliography
“One of the Policy Inquiries and Evaluations.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2013, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/policy-evaluation-forgotten-australians/7142945. Accessed 3 Jul 2024.
Related Essays:
Public Policy Research Quantitative Inquiry A-Level Coursework
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Hence, two factors that can be used as to analyze the operational validity of the measure must include: the linguistic variable and the use of the fuzzy set theory in… read more
A-Level Coursework 15 pages (4124 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare
Social Variables in the Development and Maintenance Thesis
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Social Variables in the Development and Maintenance of Business Relationships with Libyan Companies
The Need for the Research
Expected Contribution to Knowledge
Review of the Chapters
Review of Chapter 2… read more
Thesis 58 pages (16820 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Israel / Palestine / Arab World
Politics a Policy Issue in Education Term Paper
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Politics
A Policy Issue in Education: No Child Left Behind
Political Influences that Helped to Determine the NCLB Act
The publication of a Nation at Risk Report in 1983, put… read more
Term Paper 8 pages (2723 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning
International Competitiveness Politics and Policy Essay
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
International Competitiveness, Politics and Policy
Globalization
As Thomas Friedman clearly states in the Lexus and the Olive Tree, globalization is not just a trend. Globalization is not just a trend… read more
Essay 6 pages (1915 words) Sources: 1+ Style: Chicago Topic: Urban Studies / City Planning / Housing
Overarching Goal Essay
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
overarching goal of this study was to develop an improved understanding concerning assessing and developing the survey research methodology within an educational setting in general and the use of the… read more
Essay 75 pages (18833 words) Sources: 40 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning
Wed, Jul 3, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!