Term Paper on "Police Management Performance Management: Comparison"

Term Paper 5 pages (1374 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Police Management

Performance Management:

Comparison of Management of Police in the U.S., England & Wales

The purpose of this work is to examine performance management in the U.S., England and Wales and describe how an organization can be maintained within a framework of specific targets in ensuring best value and to describe the methods utilized in England and Wales in terms of structure and then to compare that with performance management systems in the U.S.

Performance management is stated to be "the government's way of determining whether it is providing a quality product at a reasonable cost." (NCPP 2004) However, there are different approaches that may be taken in performance management. There is what is referred to as the "top-down" approach as well as the "bottom-up" approach in methods of managing performance of law enforcement officers. Utilization of the bottom-up approach is characterized by responsibility of planning development and strategy evaluation is taken on by individual units. Use of this method generally ensures customer satisfaction. (Viljoen 1992) the limitations of this approach are characterized by the fact that the management is influenced by individuals inexperienced in management and perhaps without knowledge of the internal and external business environments. (Eigerman 1988) Accordingly this is likely the reasoning that contemporary planning does not use the methods that are 100% "bottom-up" or "top-down" in nature. Generally, a combination of the two is utilized to achieve integration of activities and cooperation/commitment among employees in the setting of plans that are realistic with better chances of the desired outcomes. (Gummer 1992; Cross & Lynch 1992; Gilreath 1989; Gates 1989; Kazemek 1991).

I. Performance Management in the United States:

Outcome-based management is used within the U.S. And is characterized by each city setting goals based on community indicated, objectives and performance indicators. Sunnyvale California uses this method and the results for Sunnyvale were a 40% decrease in crime. Furthermore the City Manager Tom Lewcock stated that, "with this system for the first time they [city] understands what the money is actually buying. In this system if the program 'exceeds its objectives for quality and productivity, its manager can receive a bonus of up to 10%.' The effectiveness of the system is demonstrated through the facts that in a 1990 comparison results showed that Sunnyvale delivered more services than other cities of similar size and type with 35 to 45% fewer people. Guidelines for standards of performance measurement have been published in a series entitled Service Efforts and Accomplishments (SEA) developed by government agencies, professional associations, the Urban Institute and Universities. The "do more with less" motto has become a standard in performance measurement as it is becoming a tool in assessing productivity improvement in relation to the elements of efficiency, effectiveness and accountability. The Government Accounting Standards Board (GASB) lists the measurements as: "Productivity, Effectiveness, Quality, and Timeliness."(NCPP 2004) Performance management assists in the following areas:

1. Better decision-making: it provides managers with information to perform their management control functions.

2. Performance appraisal: it links both individual and organizational performance to aspects of personnel management and motivates public employees.

3. Accountability: it fosters responsibility on the part of managers.

4. Service delivery: Improvements in public service performance.

5. Improvement of civic discourse: it helps to make public deliberations about service delivery more factual and specific.

There are different types of performance indicators defined by the GASB which are as follows:

Input Indicators: GASB defines these as indicators designed "to report the amount of resources, either financial or other that has been used for a specific service or program. Input indicators are ordinarily presented in budget submissions and sometimes external management reports."

Output/Workload indicators: Indicators that report units produced or provision of services. Workload is the measurement or work performed.

Outcome/Effectiveness Indicators: The reporting of results of the service inclusive of quality.

Efficiency/Cost-Effectiveness indicators: GASB defines these indicators as those that measure the costs per unit of output or outcome.

Productivity Indicators: Combines efficiency and effectiveness into a single indicator.

In a performance measure plan that is properly developed performance measures should satisfy the criteria of being valid, reliable, understandable, timely, and resistant to… READ MORE

How to Reference "Police Management Performance Management: Comparison" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Managing Organizational Change and Improvement Research Paper

Managing Organizational Change and Improvement

Globalization is changing the workplace at an incredible pace. This means, that because the competition is more severe, employers must ensure that productivity levels remain… read more

Research Paper 8 pages (2807 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Comparative Public Management Essay

Public Management

Over the last 65 years, the role of the public sector manager has been constantly evolving. Where, the traditional models of the past are being replaced by other… read more

Essay 10 pages (3483 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Police and Stress in a Police Officer Thesis

Police Stress

Preventing Police Officer Stress

The stresses that police officers face as a part of their daily job often make it difficult to maintain a normal life. Police officers… read more

Thesis 7 pages (2066 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Organizational Performance. This Study Pointed Out Essay

organizational performance. This study pointed out that while some association between HR policies and performance was obvious, there were no clearly defined factors as to why and how such an… read more

Essay 10 pages (2770 words) Sources: 10 Style: MLA Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Global Human Resources Management Term Paper

Global Human Resources Management

More and more companies are competing in an increasingly globalized marketplace, and these multinationals are confronted with some challenges that must be overcome in order to… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1765 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>