Research Paper on "Police Discretion"

Research Paper 4 pages (1402 words) Sources: 3

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Police Discretion

What is police discretion?

Police discretion is the utilization by law enforcement personnel of judgment based on both good and questionable knowledge regarding who to investigate detain and arrest, based not specifically on obvious criminal intent or witnessed criminal acts but instead on the appearance and the context (where they are, how they are perceived to be acting, what they are doing) of the individual. Discretion can involve the police officer's perception of behavior, beyond a criminal act. Police discretion is often referred to as street-level decision making on the part of officers in the field. The police must be allowed the opportunity to use discretion to a large degree because they, by the nature of their work often face situations that require rapid thought and action to keep the public and themselves safe (Sims, Ruiz, Weaver, & Harvey, 2005, p. 247)

In other words it is not illegal to run from anyone, but the mere act of running from the scene of a crime or from the police often ends in the individual being detained, questioned and in some cases arrested for crimes that they did or did not commit because police discretion is utilized to presume that running from such a scene is a guilty act. Subtler clues can also lead to discretionary acts by officers as well, in some areas simply standing on a street corner wearing certain colors or acting in certain ways can constitute the reason for a discretionary decision on the part of an officer. There have been many times in history where police discretion was relatively unchecked and simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time could constitute a reason to detain an individual and charge him or her with a minor crime if no other connection to greater crime was found, "Because almost anything counted as vagrancy or one of the cognate crimes, such as loitering, the police always had the discretion to arrest a suspect, even a law-abiding one," (Miller, 2010, p. 68). Though police discretion has been curtailed to some degree and is said to be balanced by the fact that other agencies and officials must support discretionary decisions, especially with regard to filing charges and prosecuting individuals, yet it must also be noted that if the police had not detained and called attention to the individual he or she would not be within the confines of this decision making process and would not be subject of inquiry (Miller, 2010, p. 15).

II. Do you consider police discretion ethically wrong, or a form of misconduct on the part of the police? Or is it a good thing to have and use. How do you feel about the practice?

Police discretion is an absolutely essential aspect of policing. There is no way around utilizing police discretion in many instances as short of traffic violations the police are rarely lucky enough to witness a criminal act and therefore police officers are required to build knowledge, both good and questionable that allows them to make rapid decisions about the behaviors of others based on relatively few cues, "policing necessarily and inevitably involves discretion…"(Murakawa & Beckett, 2010, p. 706). The basic ethical grey area of police discretion is when such discretion includes issues that identify individuals as presupposed to criminal behavior simply by virtue of appearance, and especially race.

Greater emphasis has been paid on the idea of race and class as biasing forces in institutional discrimination over the last twenty or so years and the agencies who enforce the law, defend individuals from it and prosecute in its name are far more scrutinized than they have been in the past regarding police and other discretion, yet it is clear that an ethical balance has not yet been reached. It is also clear that the discretionary power of the police is greater in the case of lesser offences than in more serious crime, likely as a result of the higher stakes associated with such criminal behavior (in act and outcome) as well as the greater amount of scrutiny associated with procedural behaviors on the part of the police and others with regards to prosecution. It is even argued by some that… READ MORE

How to Reference "Police Discretion" Research Paper in a Bibliography

Related Research Papers:

Police Discretion Position Term Paper

Police Discretion refers to any situation in which an officer deviates from standard procedure, or where official procedure permits officers to exercise their personal judgment about a specific situation. While… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1919 words) Sources: 0 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Police Discretions, Its Uses, and the Abuse Thesis

police discretions, its uses, and the abuse of discretionary powers. Simply put, police discretion is the ability of police officers to make discretionary judgements on the job, for example, the… read more

Thesis 4 pages (1354 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Police Discretion Abstact Each Day Term Paper

Police Discretion

Abstact

Each day, officers of the law are faced with new and unique situations. They must make a myriad of decisions, often on their own at their own… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2245 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Discretion Police Chiefs and Discretionary Situations "Nobody Term Paper

Discretion

Police Chiefs and Discretionary Situations

"Nobody wants a ministerial agency of justice, one that would ritually and religiously follow every rule and regulation down to the letter in a… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2323 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Police Officer Term Paper

police officer might be one of the most stressful jobs available today. The reasons for this are myriad, with the already odious nature of the work exacerbated by outside issues… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2028 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>