Essay on "Ford Pinto"

Essay 4 pages (1251 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Pinto

The Ford Pinto scandal was one of the most significant issues in corporate ethics. Ford had rushed the Pinto to market quickly, because it was facing intense competition from Volkswagen in the small car market. The company's engineers knew that rear-end collisions would cause the fuel tank to rupture, but the company had already tooled its production system. It was deemed cheaper to pay out damages to victims than to deal with the problem. The company even lobbied government to prevent rule changes that would have forced Ford to modify its Pinto design. The company had conducted an internal cost-benefit analysis that placed value on human lives, and decided that fixing the problem cost more than dealing with the death tolls. Over five hundred people would ultimately die as the result of the Pinto issues (Dowie, 1977).

Ford engaged in this unethical behavior over the course of eight years. Its designers knew about the flaw and the risk it posed to human life in the pre-production testing process. Ford actively conducted the cost-benefit analysis, and the company actively fought the legislation that would have forced them to redesign the fuel tank. Thus, the unethical activity would not passive, but active, and it occurred over the course of eight years. In terms of social responsibility, Ford clearly took the Friedman (1970) that the only social responsibility of business is to earn profits. Even Friedman, however, noted in his essay that corporations should "conform to the basic rules of the society, both those embodied in the law and those embodied in ethical custom." This implies that if Ford violated common ethical custom, its pursuit of profit over social responsibility was unethical and not in line with Friedman's philosophy.

Cheeseman (2010) points out that there a number of competing ethical theories that can help to resolve ethical dilemmas. Ethical fundamentalism holds that an individual should look to an outside source for ethical rules and commands (Lako, 2011). In this instance, either Friedman's view of corporate social responsibility or the general ethics of society would be a good guidepost. Ford violated both of these by failing to account for the unique value that human life has to members of our society. Rawls addresses this issue perhaps more clearly when he seeks to define the morally correct behavior in terms of what the actions of free and equal citizens would undertake in fair conditions. This view would find that if there is consensus about social justice in this case, that consensus would fall on the side of the preservation of human life. Nor does ethical relativism let Ford off the hook. Corporations may have a somewhat unique set of ethics, but Ford violated even the most basic ethical code for corporations. Additionally, as Dowie (1977) points out, corporations are comprised of human beings, and human beings do not under any social contract have the ability to engage in willful actions that result in the deaths of others, at least outside of times of war, and certainly not in the engagement of basic commercial activity.

Utilitarianism is another doctrine, one that prescribes that the moral action is the one that delivers the greatest good for the greatest number. Ford's actions could be seen as a form of utilitarianism. In weighing the value of human life, Ford put a price on that life, and then weighed that price against the costs to other stakeholders, in particular Ford management and the shareholders of the company. Kantian ethics would take the opposite view, that the actions of Ford were morally unjust, because Ford's actions resulted in the deaths of hundreds of people, deaths that the company could have prevented.

On this issue, I feel that the best philosophical approach is the Kantian. While… READ MORE

How to Reference "Ford Pinto" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Case Review Ford Pinto Fires Article Review

Pinto Fires Case - Summary

Case Summary

In the early 1970s, Ford was rushing to design its Pinto model automobile to capture the entry-level car market. Whereas the typical development… read more

Article Review 2 pages (462 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

Pinto Ethics Deontological and Utilitarian Essay

Pinto

Ethics

Deontological and utilitarian ethics at the Ford Motor Company: The case of the Pinto

In 1971, the Ford Motor Company was making a new car, called the Pinto,… read more

Essay 2 pages (868 words) Sources: 1+ Style: APA Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

Pinto Ford Business Plan

Pinto/Ford

The Ford Pinto: Case study

Analyze and evaluate alternatives:

The Ford Pinto was a budget vehicle designed to compete with small, European models in the American car market. Lee… read more

Business Plan 4 pages (1097 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

Pinto Fires Case Study

Pinto Fires

The occurrence of Ford Pinto fires due to rear-end collisions, and the company's subsequent recall of more than a million vehicles, is known to most. It is an… read more

Case Study 5 pages (1720 words) Sources: 6 Style: APA Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

History of Ford Motor Company Essay

Ford Motor Company

Henry Ford began working on steam engines as an apprentice in Detroit in 1879, at the age of seventeen. After bouncing between jobs for several years, Ford… read more

Essay 6 pages (1882 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>