Term Paper on "Pro-Physician Assisted Suicide"
Term Paper 4 pages (1441 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Physician-Assisted Suicide and EuthanasiaThe debate about Euthanasia is an ancient one but it has acquired a new relevance in recent times as advances in medical science have greatly extended human life-spans and it is now possible to sustain life for indefinite periods through artificial means. A closely related issue is whether it is ethical for physicians to assist in their patients' suicide in order to relieve their pain and suffering. Seemingly weighty arguments have been advanced both for and against the issue, but the debate still remains unresolved. A closer scrutiny of the pro and con arguments, however, reveals that the case against physician-assisted suicide does not carry sufficient weight and it is, in fact, a humane act which should be allowed in all civilized societies. In this essay, I shall explain why I believe so.
To start with, it would be appropriate to differentiate between certain closely related "euthanasia" terms. "Physician-assisted suicide" (PAS) is the act of providing a patient with the information, guidance, and means to take his or her own life by a physician, with the last act, i.e., taking a lethal injection or medicine being performed by the patient herself. In "active euthanasia," the last act of putting a person to death is performed by another person; albeit with his/her consent. Both these acts are considered to be illegal except in certain places such as the Netherlands and in the State of Oregon in the U.S. On the other hand, withdrawing life-sustaining medication or turning off life-prolonging equipment with the consent of a patient or his/her proxy, usually called "passive euthanasia," is considered to be acceptable in most countries
download full paper ⤓
Now let us look at some of the arguments against physician-assisted suicide and to what extent they are valid? Perhaps the most oft-repeated argument against PAS is that it is contrary to the historical traditions in medicine and the Hippocratic Oath "to do no harm"; assisting their patients in suicide would, therefore, be a violation of the oath and amount to murder (Braddock and Tonelli). This is strange logic, since withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment at the patient's request, which is arguably a more definitive act than PAS, is generally accepted by the society and has been upheld by several U.S. courts as legal (Dombrink and Hillyard, 9-10). How can acceding to a request by a patient to help in bringing a humane end to her pain and suffering, when all other efforts to do so have been exhausted, be considered illegal or contrary to the Hippocratic oath? On the contrary, the refusal to help a patient in such a situation, to my mind, would be a cruel act. Thus, any physician who accedes to a request of a patient and prescribes appropriate medication to bring the dying process to a merciful end is, in fact, entirely in line with the Hippocratic tradition.
Another common argument against physician-assisted suicide is that once it is made legal, it would put us on a "moral slippery slope" leading to more severe forms of euthanasia and targeting of vulnerable groups of people; it would be used as a "cost cutting solution" by doctors who would put pressure on the elderly and patients without health insurance to request death against their wishes; or even lead to a situation similar to the one experienced in Nazi Germany when mentally deranged and 'undesirable' people were put to death. Such alleged psychological inevitability of moving from voluntary physician-assisted suicide to non-voluntary euthanasia is not supported by credible evidence. The example of Hitler's Germany is irrelevant because what the Nazis practiced was eugenics, which is quite different from PAS or euthanasia. Evidence from the Netherlands (where PAS and euthanasia are legal) is more relevant and serious studies on the subject reveal that there has been no slide on the "slippery slope" there (Young). In Oregon, the only U.S. State where physician-assisted suicide is allowed, no such feared "victimization" of the poor and the uninsured has taken place; nor has there been a precipitous rush by Oregonians to embrace assisted suicide, which seems to suggest that the "slippery slope" apprehension is largely unfounded (Rogatz, 32).
People who oppose physician-assisted suicide also opine that depression, often accompanying chronic and terminal diseases, is a major cause of requests for assisted suicide, and most people, after… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Pro-Physician Assisted Suicide" Assignment:
Researched Argumentative Essay
Assignment Sheet
Read the following information very carefully. Your grade depends on it!
PURPOSE:
To effectively argue a position on a controversial, debatable issue.
To learn, understand, and use MLA methods of documentation.
GRADE: Worth 20% of your semester average.
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:
The paper must be a minimum of four-and-a-half typed pages (maximum is five and a half), double-spaced, with one-inch margins on the top, bottom, and sides. This length requirement is NOT including the Works Cited page. The Works Cited will be an additional page. Use 12-point font, Arial or similar.
Your topic must be a present day, controversial, two-sided issue that has been approved by your instructor. Your assignment is to argue one side of the issue.
The paper must cite a minimum of FOUR outside sources using proper MLA format. These sources cannot be a Kingwood College textbook, a general encyclopedia or dictionary. Your information should come from a variety of research sources *****“ at least one book, journal and magazine articles, reputable Web sites, etc. When using electronic sources, follow the documentation guidelines in Trimmer. You must use and document ALL four sources.
No title page is necessary. Follow the MLA design format described in Trimmer (377). You will need to include a creative, appropriate title. The Works Cited page will be the last page. You must follow the proper MLA format shown in Trimmer (362-76).
Photocopy and highlight passages you actually use in your paper. Be sure to clearly label all photocopies, so I can distinguish your sources. You must turn in photocopies of all source information (whether paraphrased or directly quoted) actually used in your paper. Place the photocopies to the back of your paper after the Works Cited page. Place all of your work in a folder.
If a quotation runs more than four typed lines, follow the procedure for blocking as shown in Trimmer (359). You should have no more than one long quotation in your paper. (You are not required to have a long quotation.)
Begin your paper with a clear explanation of the controversy. Define any specialized terms. Your argumentative thesis is certainly an opinion, but do not write *****I think***** or *****I believe.*****
Maintain an objective, formal tone throughout the paper. Do not use contractions, slang, idioms, clichés, or excessively colloquial language.
Develop the body of your paper with the reasons why you support this position. Use appropriate facts, statistics, quotations, paraphrases, etc. However, remember that this is your paper. You should use the data to support a strong, deductively or inductively reasoned argument.
You will need to identify and address the opposing position. Do so in a controlled manner. Do not use adversarial, confrontational language. You want your readers to view you as a reliable, credible, and reasonable person who has considered all sides of the issue.
Do not begin paragraphs with quotations. Your thesis, topic sentences, and closing sentences must be your own, not facts or quotations from your research. Incorporate quotations grammatically into your sentences. Lead into them; do not let them stand alone. After you quote a source, do not summarize it; instead, comment on and analyze it. Remember that quotations support your argument; do not let them dominate your essay.
Close your paper by echoing the assertions made in the introduction and by making a prediction for the future and/or suggesting a remedy for the problem.
Proofread carefully!
How to Reference "Pro-Physician Assisted Suicide" Term Paper in a Bibliography
“Pro-Physician Assisted Suicide.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2007, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/physician-assisted-suicide-euthanasia/9687917. Accessed 4 Oct 2024.
Related Term Papers:
Cons of Pro-Assisted Suicide Perspective Research Paper
Against Assisted Suicide
There are few topics in medicine today as controversial as the issue of assisted suicide. Though there are perhaps fewer headlines regarding the subject than during Dr.… read more
Research Paper 6 pages (1904 words) Sources: 6 Style: APA Topic: Ethics / Morality
Pros and Cons of Assisted Suicide Term Paper
Assisted Suicide
The fright of continuing endless agony, of remaining captive by medical devices, of waning physical reliability and individual self-esteem and being a cause of emotional and monetary depletion… read more
Term Paper 4 pages (1923 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Aging / Death / Gerontology
To End a Suffering Term Paper
Euthanasia (pro)
Debates regarding the ethical validity of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide date back to ancient times. However, it is reasonably safe to say that little progress has been made… read more
Term Paper 10 pages (3344 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Aging / Death / Gerontology
Legal Implications of Assisted Suicide Book Report
Legal Implications of Assisted Suicide
The way people think about assisted suicide or euthanasia is often determined by their religious beliefs about life and death. However issues regarding the right… read more
Book Report 3 pages (988 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Aging / Death / Gerontology
Healthcare -- Legal Issues Medical Ethics Term Paper
Healthcare -- Legal Issues
MEDICAL ETHICS and Management ISSUES
The National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) collects information regarding the professional competence and conduct of physicians, dentists, and other health care… read more
Term Paper 7 pages (2029 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA Topic: Management / Organizations
Fri, Oct 4, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!