Term Paper on "Naturalist Claims About the Universe"

Term Paper 4 pages (1140 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Philosophy

Traditional Naturalist Claims: The Problems Therein

Naturalism is the philosophical position most often advocated by humanists, scientists, and -- obviously -- naturalists. They would have us believe, in the spirit of the 7th century Greek philosopher Thales, that the "natural world [is] a realm of insensate matter and impersonal forces that operate independently of human or supernatural volition" (Prado par. 3-4). The naturalist worldview posits that all phenomena in the universe exist only materially and their functioning can always be explained in mechanistic terms. All philosophers and individuals that put stock in an immaterial world, whether that world is spiritual or otherwise, champion an opposing position. An examination of the traditional claims of naturalism will reveal that the naturalist position is lacking, chiefly because naturalism is a philosophical position not an empirical one. Thus, it is no more deserving of individual faith than a person's belief in the supernatural.

Naturalism believes that the world is constructed and ordered in purely material terms, but there is little evidence to suggest that this is the whole story. For the naturalist, nature is the source of everything in the universe and all rational explanations for phenomena can only be constructed in natural, or material, terms (Dubray par. 1). This position has its value, certainly, because it allows us to analyze phenomena and make reasoned conclusions about the way in which parts of the universe are ordered together. From a material perspective, then, the naturalist position is aptly suited to produce reasonable explanations. However, the staunch naturalist does not simply want to provide material explanations for material phenomena, but instead to insist that there can only be material explanations and material phenomena. Karl Popper, a scientist and critic of this kind of inductive reasoning, explains:

naturalistic methodology (sometimes called an "inductive theory of science") has its value, no doubt. [...] I reject the naturalistic view: It is uncritical. Its upholders fail to notice that whenever they believe to have discovered a fact, they have only proposed a convention. Hence the convention is liable to turn into a dogma. This criticism of the naturalistic view applies not only to its criterion of meaning, but also to its idea of science, and consequently to its idea of scientific method. (Popper 31)

In other words, and importantly, naturalism fails because it presupposes that the explanations is provides are applicable in all situations, before even understanding individual situations. As Popper points out, this is an "uncritical" stance.

In the same vein, naturalists imagine that all situations and circumstances in the universe have a mechanical explanation; i.e., it is possible to provide a natural explanation of every phenomenon (Dubray par. 3). Worse, this obviously ideological position is not supported by anything but the naturalist's wishful thinking. For example, though evolution is the source of heated debate, no self-respecting scientist would argue that contradictory evidence or poor understanding is a challenge to the eventual discovery of the mechanisms of evolution (Johnson par. 8). There is never a doubt in the head of the naturalist that evolution, or any other complex and poorly understood subject, has a natural explanation that can be reasoned out through an examination of possible natural mechanisms. but, of course, this position is not a function of empirical fact, and it would be a stretch to definitely state that macroevolution is well documented at the empirical level. Rather, the faith in evolution as a mechanism of… READ MORE

How to Reference "Naturalist Claims About the Universe" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Philosophy Challenging Naturalist Critiques of Free Will Term Paper

Philosophy

Challenging Naturalist Critiques of Free Will

Naturalists have long held that we cannot demonstrate the existence of free will.

They suggest, in the spirit of the Enlightenment philosopher Baron… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1231 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

Daoism Philosophy Essay

We should visit a park or any green space often. I go for a morning walk and I feel the calmness residing inside me. The greenery and freshness of the… read more

Essay 6 pages (2169 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Biology / Life

---

Islamization of Knowledge Essay

Islamization of Knowledge

This work seeks to examine the question of 'what is curriculum' in terms of the historical background and curriculum process and to identify effective strategies for transforming… read more

Essay 20 pages (5650 words) Sources: 20 Style: APA Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Metaphysics Versus Psychology Dissertation

METAPHYSICS vs. PSYCHOLOGY

Metaphysics and Psychology have historically been at odds with one another in what is an unnatural although real separation from a somewhat new science and its mother… read more

Dissertation 40 pages (13675 words) Sources: 30 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Respond to Hj Mccloskey Term Paper

Atheist" by H.J. McCloskey and answer the following questions using "Philosophy of Religion-Thinking About Faith" second edition by C.Stephens Evans & R. Zacharary Manis and the article "The Absurdity of… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2573 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>