Essay on "Philosophy of Science"
Essay 3 pages (1074 words) Sources: 1
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Philosophy of Science: Hempel vs. HolismIt is a shame that in scientific debate philosophies of holism and reductionism have been considered mutually exclusive, when a combined approach is plausible and even logical. Hempel himself admits to subjectivity concerns with his treatment of hypothesis, but no one would argue that an approach to holism is possible without a thorough understanding of the elements of a holistic system. The virtue of reductionism is in its elementary utility, it is a paradigm easily applicable with clear-cut causal definitions: if H. then I; not I; not H. Through reductionism modern science has been built, brick by brick, from the ancient Greeks, to Copernicus and Galileo who melded into Newton, and finally to relativity, quantum mechanics and string theory. However, utility and tradition are not synonymous with truth. From a positivist viewpoint, it is necessary to accept holism -- and has been at least since Heisenberg proposed his Uncertainty Principle. Like Newtonian mechanics, Hempel's theories suffer from generalized application: on the level of barometers and mountain-tops there is causal continuity, but in more complex systems the approach breaks down. Simple, reducible hypothesis elude many fields to this day -- notably economics, where no two experts yet agree on the precise phenomena leading to this past decade's recession. While understanding the reduced elements -- sub-prime mortgages and credit swaps -- contribute to understanding of the whole, there is an interaction still un-described occurring in the interstitial spaces; a ghost in the machine.
Hempel's argument for radicalism in the selection of hypothesis is too narrow to encompass
download full paper ⤓
In the case of wave function collapse we also have one instance of a higher-complexity layer of a system affecting the state of a lower-complexity, reductionist element. If the holistic layer -- the backdrop against which the electrons splash and are observed -- is able to interact with the reductionist layer -- the electrons themselves -- we arrive at a failure in Hempel's theory. The double-slit experiment cannot be fully described by understanding only electron motion.
Another telling and interesting example appeared in the April 2010 issue of Discover Magazine. In an article titled "Back From the Future" by Zeeya Merali, an American physicist, Jeff Tollaksen, reports that… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Philosophy of Science" Assignment:
The paper will focus on this question:
*****"What problem does holism pose for Hempel*****'s theory of science? What is Hempel*****'s response? Is his response adequate? Why or why not?*****"
The instruction:
Be sure to answer all of the elements of the question given above. Be specific and concrete. Take a stand and argue for it, presenting good reasons for your position. All the papers are expected to be argumentative and analytical. You will be graded on how clearly, succinctly and accurately you can formulate the positions of the authors read, and how well you define the philosophical issues involved. You will be graded on how persuasive the argument is.
I will send more resources about the holism. *****
How to Reference "Philosophy of Science" Essay in a Bibliography
“Philosophy of Science.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2010, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/philosophy-science-hempel/56371. Accessed 28 Sep 2024.
Related Essays:
Philosophy of Science Kuhn Essay
Philosophy of Science
Kuhn does not consider himself to be a relativist. Relativism has to do with our beliefs as individuals and the value and importance we place on those… read more
Essay 3 pages (978 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason
Science and Culture Essay
Science Making Us More Ignorant," Austin Dacey points out that while we may be more scientifically informed those generations in the past, we are still not grasping certain larger issues… read more
Essay 2 pages (720 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason
Philosophy and Theoretical Frameworks Fit Questionnaire
The ability to make others comfortable and allow them to talk and share honest responses through personality traits is important as well. The quantitative researcher must talk with people, gather… read more
Questionnaire 7 pages (2109 words) Sources: 0 Style: APA Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason
Science vs. Philosophy: Return to Unity Term Paper
Relationship/Science-Philosophy
The Relationship Between Science and Philosophy: Return to Unity is predicated on the concept that the dichotomy between the two disciplines was artificially created in order to achieve various… read more
Term Paper 13 pages (4240 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason
Philosophy Socrates to Sartre and Beyond Term Paper
Philosophy
Socrates to Sartre and Beyond: A History of Philosophy
In Socrates to Sartre and Beyond: A History of Philosophy Samuel Enoch Stumpf and his co-author James Fieser might seem… read more
Term Paper 7 pages (2412 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason
Sat, Sep 28, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!