Research Proposal on "Effects of PBS Against Bullying Students With Disabilities in a Second Grade Classroom"

Research Proposal 8 pages (3022 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

PBS against Bullying Students with Disabilities in a second grade classroom setting

Managing children's behavior is a common problem for educators (Anderson & Kincaid, 2005) particularly if there are some aggressive students in the class who intimidate or victimize others. The problem is aggravated when victims are individuals who are mentally or physically handicapped. The impact of bullying on the individual is never good in any situation, but when applied to targets with special challenges, ramifications can occur where reinforcing messages can impact the target's self-esteem and worsen the challenge, aside from reducing the individual's psychological ability to deal with his or her challenge (Weiten, 2010). Most general and special education teachers report difficulty in restraining and managing aggressive behavior of young children (Fox et al., 2002).

School-wide positive behavior supports (SWPBS) is a behavioral-based program that is structured to deal with aggressive, bullying behavior on the part of young children in a positive and interventional manner (Sugai & Horner, 2006). SWPBS uses the concepts of positive behavior supports (PBS) that rely on empirical research, evidenced and positive outcomes, and environmental as well as procedural change to alter the problem behavior (ibid). The three elements of SWPBS are: (1) preventions, (2) evidence-based research, and (3) implementation of this research. SWPBS has been consistently used to help teachers mitigate the bullying and aggressive behavior on the parts of certain students (e.g. Sugai & Horner, 2006).

Integral to SWPBS is the philosophy of PBS (Fairbanks et al., 2007), which promotes positive behavior and endeavors to model and reinforce a value system of prosocial behaviors in those children that evidence social aggressiveness (Hieneman et al., 2005). PBS works strongly on recognition of positive traits in both classmates and in the problematic students themselves and with both students and teachers acknowledging and dwelling on these positive traits. Increasing the student's awareness of the positive traits of his peers has a rebound effect with the target individual's esteem being reinforced rather than depressed; with the bullying student more apt to see positive points in other situations as well as individuals; with the teacher praising the bullying individual for small positive incremental changes in his or her behavior; and, ideally, with this praise increasing the probability that students will engage in desired prosocial conduct. With the entire class participating and with the focus placed on what is called 'tootling' rather than 'tattling' (Skinner, 2002), awareness and practice of prosocial behavior on the part of problematic individuals can be increased and their engagement in antisocial behaviors decreased.

'Tootling' is a term coined by Skinner (2002) to describe the recognition and reporting of classmates' prosocial behaviors. Prosocial behaviors include examples such as raising one's hand, sharing one's lunch with another, opening the door for teacher and so forth. Students then report these positive acts to their teacher, either by writing it on a card and handing it to the teacher or by verbally announcing it in class (Skinner, 2000). Educators then reinforce these behaviors by adding their own praise.

There have been few studies on the effects of tootling, but those that there are show positive results. However, each also has noted experimental limitations. Skinner (2000) found an increase in prosocial behaviors with the introduction of tootling. However, an unplanned procedure implemented during the study may have confounded results. Cashwell et al. (2001) replicated Skinner's study, but both he and Skinner et al. (2000) failed to monitor the results of tootling on reduction of student's antisocial conduct.

Cihak, Kirk, and Boon (2009) examined the use of tooling in reducing the number of disruptive behaviors in a third-grade elementary classroom. Nineteen elementary students including four students with disabilities were taught how to report their classmates' positive behaviors using the 'tootling' intervention. They combined this with a group contingency procedure. Results showed that the use of the 'tootling' intervention integrated with the group contingency procedure decreased the students' disruptive behavior. Limitations, however, included the facts that student age, abilities, and grade levels were small as well as that details of tootles (the number of tootles reported daily, the distribution of tootles amongst students with and without disunities, the distribution of tootles amongst students with and without behavioral problems, and the quality of tootles) were ignored. Most importantly, the research of Skinner et al. (2000), Cashwell et al. (2001), and Cihak, Kirk, and Boon (2009) were conducted on generally disruptive behavior and prosocial conduct in general. It would be interesting to assess the result of tootling on bullying and aggressive conduct on the part of some individuals to specific peers and to assess whether the tootling interventions allows significant reduction in the problematic behavior.

The purpose of this study, therefore, is to extend the research in positive peer reporting (I.e. tootling) to investigating its impact on children's bullying levels and to correct for some of the limitations inherent in Cihak, Kirk, and Boon's (2009) study, more specially by noting the number of tootles reported daily, the distribution of tootles amongst students with and without disabilities, the distribution of tootles amongst students with and without behavioral problems, and the quality of tootles. In all, the effects of tootling on reducing specific students' bullying behavior will be investigated, as well the classroom teacher's opinions regarding the effect of tootling on their classroom environment as a whole.

Method

Participants are * 19 second-grade students (* males, * females) enrolled in a * elementary school within the * USA. Of the *19 students, two are identified as bullying others, particularly tending to bully two students with disabilities, one who has an LD for reading, and the other one who may have some cognitive deficit problems. The classroom teacher was a certified elementary teacher with * years of teaching experience. All aspects of this study occurred in the students' second-grade primary classroom setting.

Materials

The students will use 4 by 6 inches index cards to record positive observations of their peers. The definition of 'tootling' will be slightly modified in this study to extend from prosocial behavior, in specific, to all positive and praise-worthy variables that were recognized in another. It wall also be emphasized that students will have to include each individual in the class. Students will place the cards in a clear container that is kept on the teacher's desk. A poster displayed in front of the classroom provides feedback to the students regarding the daily number of 'tootles' that their peers will report and the total number of 'tootle's required to reach their collective goal. An incentive, particularly attractive to all, especially to the problematic students, can be offered at the end of the duration of the month depending on whether the required amount of 'tootles' has been achieved. The teacher will, occasionally, provide verbal feedback on the students' performance and on the number of 'tootle's still to be achieved. In an unobtrusive manner, the teacher will specifically reinforce the problem students for any slight positive addendum in their behavior.

Variables and Data Collection

The dependent variable will be the number of bullying behaviors performed by the problematic students. These are defined as * teasing, name-calling, ridiculing, and physically hurting. The teacher will make a note in her notebook, next to the name of that student, whenever one of these antisocial, aggressive behaviors will occur. The victims will also be encouraged to report aggressive incidents to the teacher. To the reverse, eth teacher will also report discrete details of positive, prosocial behaviors that these problematic students engaged in. The whole will be described in a tabular format. The independent variable will be the reporting of peers' prosocial behaviors by tootling.

Design

An ABAB research design (see Fig. 1) will be used to investigate the efficacy of using the tootling intervention to reduce bullying behavior. The ABAB design will assess conditions at baseline, will implement the tootling procedure, will compare the effects of tootling procedure to baseline conditions, and will evaluate effects on the two problematic students in particular and on the class in general. The study, therefore, will have four stages: (1) baseline, (2) implementation of tootling procedure, (3) comparison to baseline and, (4) intra-comparisons of tootling procedure.

Procedure

Baseline: for 2 weeks prior to study, the teacher will record all the bullying behaviors on the part of the two students as well as the specific bullying behaviors that they engage in. Their bullying behaviors will be categorized into three or more categories (maximum five) and notations placed next to each according to the amount of times that the problematic students perform these specific aggressive actions. Care will be taken, too, to notice whether the problematic students extend their bullying behavior to other individuals of the classroom setting. Data will be collected for two weeks until a stable baseline has been affected. This will be for the two students in general. In order to make the study more scientific so that it can generalized and applicable to a wider audience, it has to have a larger sample. The class is not… READ MORE

How to Reference "Effects of PBS Against Bullying Students With Disabilities in a Second Grade Classroom" Research Proposal in a Bibliography

Related Research Proposals:

Students With Disabilities Who Did Not Complete Dissertation

Students With Disabilities Who Did Not Complete High School

Richard Wieringo

This case study explores the experiences of students with disabilities who have dropped out of high school, so as… read more

Dissertation 60 pages (17241 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Student With Disability Essay

Students With Disabilities

One of the great challenges of teaching today is successfully including a wide diversity of students in the classroom. Especially at elementary and high school level, the… read more

Essay 4 pages (1300 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Student Profile John Is a Seventh-Grade Term Paper

Student Profile

John is a seventh-grade student who is presently included in general education classes with some limited accommodations and supports. There are some concerns being expressed by a number… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1152 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Students With Disabilities in General Education Classrooms Research Paper

Students With Disabilities in General Education Classrooms

What is the role of the school counselor? According to an article in Urban Education the school counselor is an advocate, "champion of… read more

Research Paper 6 pages (1985 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Effect on Positive Peer Interaction When Mainstreaming Students Who Are in a Self-Contained Classroom Literature Review

Inclusion

EFFECT of POSITIVE PEER INTERACTION WHEN MAINSTREAMING STUDENTS WHO ARE in a SELF-CONTAINED CLASSROOM

The literature in this work examines the effect of positive peer interactions when mainstreaming students… read more

Literature Review 5 pages (1448 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>