Research Paper on "Moral and Ethical Dilemma in Occupational Therapy"

Research Paper 10 pages (3625 words) Sources: 5

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Moral and Ethical Dilemma in Occupational Therapy

It is a generally accepted fact that the aged population across the world in increasing as a result of better general health consciousness and technology to prevent, treat and cure illnesses that would have caused death just a few years ago. The phenomenon of greater longevity is however not without inherent problems of its own. Indeed, it has created an increasing amount of problems, not least in terms of the burden upon national health care for those in need of it.

In more specific terms, the phenomenon of elderly care in occupational therapy is also not without its problems. Many ethical dilemmas are for example created, where there is a sense of conflict between a carer's personal code of ethics and values, legal codes and requirements, and the institutional code of conduct. This is the case with Mrs. DN, the case study of focus in this discussion.

Although Mrs. DN is clearly in need of health care, her devoted visits to her husband's institution violates the Medicare requirement of being mostly homebound. It is also however a fact that these visits places severe strain on her health to the detriment of her own recovery process. Several alternatives therefore need to be considered before a final decision can be made regarding the continued provision of care to Mrs. DN.

In order to do this, several viewpoints regarding ethical theories will be considered, including utilitarianism, community ethics, and deontology. In order to provide Mrs. DN with the optimal care that she needs, it may be not only possible, but also necessary for the carer to revise her personal set of ethical and moral codes, while attempting to bring these in line with institutional values while also not abandoning Mrs. DN to her fate.

Ethical dilemmas are inherent in all the caring professions. Sometimes legal issues and ethical issues can simply not find any common ground, in which case a compromised by both sides becomes necessary. The argument however remains that it is indeed possible to provide both optimal care to clients who need it while also adhering to a set of regulations that are put in place for the benefit of both clients and institutions.

INFORMATION NEEDED FOR ANALYSIS AND RESOLUTION

In order to analyze the problem, it is necessary to consider various different views on ethics, while also considering the legal issues attached to the case. Research of written work can for example provide valuable insight not only into the specific problem, but also into the issues surrounding it.

Nalette (2010) for example goes to the very heart of the problem with the assertion that managed care practitioners often have to find a balance between their own sense of commitment to their patients and problems, while also remaining committed to their employers in terms of fiscal and institutional accountability. When considering the wider perspective of the countrywide health care system, however, the author also states that the U.S. system particularly has been shown to be ineffective. This is said to be the result of unjust resource distribution. In other words, while the United States has sufficient resources to support the health care needs of its citizens, the system is not applying this funding in such a way as to optimize care for those who need it most. This is particularly so in what the author refers to as "conventional practice," where health care paradigms, norms and regulations are no longer sufficient to handle the changing demographic to which it is required to cater.

In order to consider the problem in terms of specific situations, Nalette (2010) includes various ethical considerations. These may also be used to apply to the case study in question. Firstly, for example, the author considers the attempt to balance ethics with institutional efficiency in terms of human relationships, and particularly the moral nature of the relationship between a carer and a client. Secondly, the author pays attention to the fact that health care resources are by nature limited, and an ethics of constraint is applied. Thirdly, the author considers the practitioner's responsibilities in terms of both these apparently divergent concerns within the profession.

In terms of an ethical relationship with clients, the physician is to concern him- or herself with the responsibility of helping the client to overcome health conditions in terms of the specific requirements and concerns of the client. At all times, the general professional code of ethics requires the carer to do the greatest good possible while doing the least possible harm. In short, human relationships must be seen in terms of "mutual respectfulness, helpfulness, and truthfulness" (Nalette, 2010). In terms of occupational therapy, or any other kind of caring profession, the practice is then to be based upon the carer's sense of the patient's humanity, while operating from a basis of compassion.

The problem is however that this compassionate practice needs funding in order to operate effectively. Health care resources are not infinite. Hence the inclusion of rules and regulations that determine the allocation of funding for certain types of care. There are several levels of constraint at both the general social and individual organizational level. The problem is then that a lack of resources means a lack of care availability. This translates to eventual harm to patients, which is a violation of one of the fundamental health care paradigms.

For this reason, there is a need not so much to increase resources, but to apply resources in such a way that patient care and benefit are optimized. There are two possibilities to ensure this: either revise institutional standards and requirements in order to allocate sources in a more efficient way, or change the care paradigm itself. This will be considered in more detail when discussing the case study itself.

Carroll (2007, p. 143-144) for example suggests a careful scrutiny of the possible discrepancies between the laws and rules of the profession and the personal moral and ethical values held by medical professionals. It is important to maintain a set of rules and policies to ensure that health care resources are allocated fairly. However, in the absence of fairness, these should be modified.

When not modifying rules and policies where these result in inefficient care to those who need better services, the author suggests a supplementation of pro bono services instead. When including this type of service in the clinical setup, physicians enable efficient care to those who need it, while adhering to the institutional drive for financial survival as well.

Again, this can be offered at two levels; by referring the patient to a free clinic, or at another level, to provide pro bono services within the institution itself. This is particularly helpful when considering the very specific and specialized care that some patients need, along with building a relationship between a specific carer and client. This becomes possible at the institutional level when patients receive specialized care at a reduced price or for free.

In this, it is also important to distinguish between ethical codes and theories. Codes of ethics may be based upon ethical theories, but vary according to individuals, institutions, and their view of what is important in terms of human relationships and professional considerations. For an individual, for example, an ethical code would include maintaining honesty in his or her communications, while institutions may consider it ethical practice to provide optimal care at a certain amount of compensation, or for free to certain deserving individuals.

Ethical theories have been constructed by philosophers and thinkers over the centuries in response to what they observed as important during their respective lifetimes. These are often used to construct individual or institutional codes of ethics. When considering ethical dilemmas, it is therefore often helpful to first refer to the original ethical theories upon which institutional and individual ethical codes came to be based.

Bevir and O'Brien (2003, p. 10) mention John Macmurray's ethical theory as an example, where he defined ethics in terms of relationships among people and constructed a community-based ethical theory, as opposed to an ethical code based upon ideas such as the common good. In the health care profession, the most applicable ethical theory should then rather focus upon communal relations rather than upon ideological ideals, because health care considers human well-being.

De Sousa e Brito (2008, p. 20) takes this a step further by suggesting that the carer place him- or herself in the place of the client to determine the best course of action in terms of preference. This then also bases the ethical code not so much on ideology as upon the human relationships involved in the caring process. It is as it were the "duty" of the health care professional to care for the well-being and preferences of those in his or her care.

This can also be said to apply to the aged population, many of whom prefer to remain independent for as long as possible after their retirement. Kerridge, Lowe and McPhee (2009, p. 306) for… READ MORE

How to Reference "Moral and Ethical Dilemma in Occupational Therapy" Research Paper in a Bibliography

Related Research Papers:

Biomedical Technology Term Paper

Biomedical Technology

The field of Biomedical Technology has been growing by leaps and over the past half-century. At the beginning of that time many research scientists and their funding corporations… read more

Term Paper 9 pages (3146 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Genetics / DNA / Genes / Heredity

---

Biotechnology Business Focused on Charles River Laboratories Term Paper

Biotechnology Business Focused on Charles River Laboratories

The biotechnology industry is relatively new, but is has been responsible for some of the most important scientific discoveries that have benefited humanity… read more

Term Paper 20 pages (5076 words) Sources: 8 Style: APA Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Cystic Fibrosis Imaging of the Disease Term Paper

Cystic Fibrosis in the Modern Era disease that steals a childhood, adolescence and adulthood in an assault on the lungs and other vital organs that cause every living action to… read more

Term Paper 30 pages (8608 words) Sources: 60 Style: Harvard Topic: Disease / Virus / Disorder / Injury

---

Psychology Testing: Psychometric Emotional Intelligence (Eq) Durrenmatt Term Paper

Psychology Testing: Psychometric Emotional Intelligence (EQ)

Durrenmatt (1996) may have had it right when he said, "Emotions have no place in business, unless you do business with them." Or perhaps,… read more

Term Paper 45 pages (12427 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>