Essay on "Dante's Quest for Revenge in the Count of Monte Cristo Is it Morally Just"

Essay 4 pages (1327 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Monte Cristo

The Justice of Vengeance in Monte Cristo

The Count of Monte Cristo is a tale of revenge. Dantes, wrongfully imprisoned, escapes and vows to destroy those who betrayed him. Dantes' quest for revenge is easily understandable: he is like vengeance personified -- the hand of God bringing justice to all those who have committed wrongs. This paper will analyze Dantes' quest for vengeance and show how it is depicted as morally just in two ways -- both because it represents God's divine justice and because it represents the Romantic vision of natural justice.

Vengeance is nothing new to the human condition -- and the most popular super heroes of today are possessed with a sense of righteousness which they manifest through acts of vengeance. Dantes' quest for revenge spells doom for many characters -- and while God, according to the Christian tradition, reserves the right to "repay" all for their actions, Dantes (in a way) represents this right and the idea that we are all repaid for the wrongs we commit. Heith Copes asserts as much when he states that "from the Count of Monte Cristo to Kill Bill, much popular writing has highlighted humanity's longing to dispense revenge for perceived wrongs. The popularity of such stories is likely due to the innate desire to enact justice" (362). This innate desire, which Copes identifies, is what is at the heart of Dumas' tale of revenge: Dantes' wrongful imprisonment serves as the catalyst for illustrating this desire.

The novel need not be considered an allegory for Christian teaching. After all, Dantes himself reckons that his revenge may be too extreme when the bodies begin to pile one atop another. However, he ultimately concludes that his vengeance is justified. Again, he manifests the human desire for justice: "In return for a slow, profound, eternal torture, I would give back the same, were it possible: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, as the Orientalists say" (Dumas 506). Dantes is not a representation of Christian mercy -- but of God's ultimate justice.

And yet Dantes may be viewed as a representation of humanity as well. Dantes does begin to doubt himself in his quest for vengeance. He shows scrupulosity early on, in fact: "I was awkward, and it is just that I should pay the penalty of my clumsiness" (Dumas 292). However, what Dantes realizes about himself is that his cause is just. Yet this period of doubt also allows him to come to a new wisdom as well: his vengeance may be tempered by mercy -- as he shows to Danglars.

Dantes' treatment of Danglars is a perfect example of the former's desire to take an eye for an eye. Danglars is subjected to the same kind of torture that Dantes underwent in prison. However, Dantes ultimately delivers Danglars himself and allows him to go free. This is done, though, only after Danglars confesses his crime and repents. Again, Dantes is carrying out justice: he has much in common with the super heroes of today, who bring criminals to justice -- punish them accordingly but also show a degree of mercy as well, proving that they are not as base as the criminals they confound.

Amelita Marinetti observes that Dantes represents Dumas' own "aspirations…to omniscience, social power, and the conquest of the impossible" (260). Marinetti's observation reveals some impressive insight to the character of Dantes and the way in which he may be viewed. He is not just a representation of Justice or of Revenge. Dantes also stands for a kind of Romantic vision of the 19th century. He is the archetypal innocent man. In the Romantic era, he may have been understood as modern man, carrying the burden of the tradition of original sin. In Dumas' tale, Dantes frees himself from this burden. In a way, the Count of Monte Cristo is not so much a tale of revenge and justice as it is a tale of self-acceptance.

But,… READ MORE

How to Reference "Dante's Quest for Revenge in the Count of Monte Cristo Is it Morally Just" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Count of Monte Cristo Essay

Monte Cristo

The Duality of Hope and Waiting in the Count of Monte Cristo

Hope can be a force capable of instilling greatness in its beholder. But it can just… read more

Essay 4 pages (1269 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas vs. The Count of Monte Cristo Movie Thesis

Count of Monte Cristo

Comparing the Counts of Monte Cristo

The Count of Monte Cristo is one of the most popular novels by the French writer Alexander Dumas of the… read more

Thesis 4 pages (1314 words) Sources: 1 Style: MLA Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

Count of Monte Cristo Essay

Monte Cristo

Hope and Patience in the Count of Monte Cristo

There is a distinction which may be useful to describe the protagonist of any important literary work that makes… read more

Essay 3 pages (1024 words) Sources: 1 Style: MLA Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Count of Monte Cristo: Edmond Dantes' Vengeance Essay

Count of Monte Cristo: Edmond Dantes' vengeance

"While I was in a dark wood wandering." The French author Alexander Dumas named the central character of his novel The Count of… read more

Essay 2 pages (761 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Count of Monte Cristo Theme the Importance of Hope Term Paper

Count of Monte Cristo Theme: The Importance of Hope

Hope is vital to Edmond Dante's survival in the epic work The Count of Monte Cristo. Hope is also the foundation… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1737 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>