Term Paper on "Imperial Russia"

Term Paper 4 pages (1067 words) Sources: 0

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Mongol Origins of Muscovite Political Institutions

There have for centuries existed arguments both for and against the effect of the Mongols on the Muscovite Political Institutions on the 13-16 centuries. Arguments exist which support the effect of Mongol khans on Muscovy yet there are some who believe that the effects which are attributed to the Mongols come into effect far to late to be considered truly attributable to Mongol origins and instead represent some sort of modernization or alteration of Byzantine Practices. In his article, The Mongol Origins of Muscovite Political Institutions" Donald Ostrowski puts forth a compelling argument regarding what he believes to be the extensive effect of the Mongols on Muscovy and the resultant development and derivation of Russian political institutions.

From the beginning it is probably important to say that by no means in Ostrowski an absolutist in his theories. He takes great pains to explain that he has no significantly vested interest in the influence of Mongols upon the sociopolitical bent of Muscovy and instead emphasizes that his theories are based upon conclusions which he has drawn after careful study and also, that the conclusions are made in the absence of any other absolute information. There is a remarkable paucity of historical records from this time, and Ostrowski bases his opinions on comparisons between the Mongol and Muscovite political institutions. He appears open to the fact that someone may come in at any time and raise other ideas which may at any time invalidate his argument or at least modify what he feels to be some of the essential truths of the sociopolitical text of the time. Some of his comparisons and constructs are quite interesting, however, and seem to make more sense than those put forward by other historians studying the period.

Ostrowski agrees that there is no significant consensus among historians as to when and where the most influential timing of Mongol on Muscovy occurred. It is interesting to note that according to the records which exist, there appears to be evidence of the Mongol influence on Muscovy in cases which show its effect only after the Muscovites were fully released from Mongolian influence and somewhat emancipated. Ostrowski explains this phenomenon in two ways; one which has been put forward by the historian Vedansky in which the Mongolian influence appears to be one caused mostly by some form of delayed action which is not clearly defined. In another case, Ostrowski refers to the possibility of an "institutional time bomb" which exerted a delayed effect upon the sociopolitical climate of Muscovy. Ostrowski is clearly willing to accept the fact that the spatial and temporal differences in the apparent influences of the Mongols on the Muscovite princes may cause many to reject the idea that Muscovy borrowed heavily from the Mongols, and is willing to consider the fact that it would appear somewhat ridiculous for a 16th century dynasty which is essentially a successful conqueror state to adopt the sociopolitical aspects of a system which it had just conquered. Nonetheless, Ostrowski is able to tie this all up neatly in several ways. He remarks upon the fact that many of the Muscovite rulers where in some ways… READ MORE

How to Reference "Imperial Russia" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Imperial Russia Term Paper

Imperial Russia

IVAN THE TERRIBLE:

THE RENAISSANCE PRINCE PRESENTED BY PERRIE AND PAVLOV

The image of the "Terrible Tsar" has resonated profoundly in both popular historical imagination and the hearts… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2163 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Asian History / Asia

---

Revolution in Russia Essay

Bolshevik Revolution in Russia

The "History of Soviet Russia and the Soviet Union" takes into account the period of great change for Russia and the rest of the world. The… read more

Essay 3 pages (1042 words) Sources: 1 Topic: World History

---

Russian History 1900-1989 Term Paper

Russia/USSR

There are certain events in the history of the world that had a defining impact on the way in which events developed and in which the world evolved to… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2392 words) Sources: 6 Style: Chicago Topic: World History

---

Military Reform in 1874 Term Paper

Military Reforms of 1861-74

It's generally agreed today that state of army truly reflects the standards of living in the country and the attitude of the citizens towards their country.… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3105 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

Ivan the Terrible Term Paper

Ivan the Terrible

Ivan IV, remembered for his cruelty and the excessive punishments, is awarded the epithet, "Groznyi," meaning "Terrible," and according to popular legend, he was born during a… read more

Term Paper 14 pages (4848 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>