Methodology Chapter on "Mix-Methods School Reform Study Exploring Critical Indicators"

Methodology Chapter 10 pages (3003 words) Sources: 10

[EXCERPT] . . . .

mix-methods school reform study exploring critical indicators designed to assimilate the 21st century learner into the (p -- 16 / k - 20) education systems

While the P-16 and K-20 systems have been implemented to bridge the gap to the P-12 system so that students can seamlessly integrate into tertiary study, little research has been undertaken to address the actual effects of the system. And indeed, a gap still appears to exist as a result of several factors. Poor secondary preparedness, insufficient high school graduation rates, and a lack of accountability by administrators have been among the reasons cited for the problems still experienced by students transitioning from secondary to tertiary education.

Indeed, Schoenfeld (2005, p.1), in reviewing work on the P-16 program, mentions the basic lack of in-depth literature and constructive dialogue on the subject of the relationship between the preparedness of the secondary school student and his or her access to higher education. Instead, secondary education is dominated by issues of testing and meanings attached to the diploma obtained from such education, while higher education tends to be dedicated to issues of affirmative action. The popularization of such debates have somewhat ignored other pressing issues such as how to ensure that high school students are in fact ready to enter tertiary education.

Another barrier to implementing an effective P-16 or K-20 program is the existing paradigms among college staff, where the rewards system often dominates such thinking. Within a culture of "publish or perish" (Zhang, McInerney and Frechtling, 2010, p.2), such faculty staff are often more concerned with their own professional survival than forming partnerships with other entities that could lead to a more effective and student-centered tertiary education paradigm. Handel and Montoya (2009, p.24) also note the importance of partnerships among tertiary and secondary institutions in order to help the United States reach its goal of an optimal workforce. The authors cite a report stating that the country needs to dramatically increase its production of bachelor's and associate degrees if it is to meet the growing needs of its workforce. In particular, underrepresented ethnic groups such as African-Americans, American Indians, and Hispanic-Americans need to form a substantial part of such a plan.

Leskes (2003, p.34) again addresses the problem in a practical way -- current reform systems are based upon the correct ideological goals, but seldom meet these in reality. Students need the ability not only to pass certain tests to indicate their preparedness for college, but also the ability to in fact apply their knowledge in practice to solve complex problems. This, according to the author, should be the focus of P-16 reform programs.

This chapter will then be a mixed-methods study, integrating both qualitative and quantitative data in order to determine the critical indicators that will ensure the successful integration of the 21st century student into the P-16/K-20 education systems.

Problem Statement

From responses by a variety of state higher education executive officers (SHEEOs), E.J. Walsh (2009, p.31) found that several shortcomings are identified in implementing P-16 policy. There is for example a gap between planning and implementation when it comes to relevant policies. SHEEO's can for example describe plans and goals for their respective states, but few indicated the presence of actual P-16 policy. The lack of clear policy affects the implementation of plans and goals. There is a need for closer scrutiny of barriers such as historical divides between state education governance structures, as well as the cultural divide, as mentioned above. Cross-sector collaboration is also important in this regard.

A second problem is that no state finance incentive is in place to promote P-16 alignment (Walsh, 2009, p.32). Indeed, paradigms like the above-mentioned rigid ideals of tenure at tertiary level often override collaboration efforts to ensure service to students and ultimately to the future of the American workforce. Walsh (p.33) also indicates that state policy procedures could have important implications in this regard, although research in the area remains inconclusive. This is an important consideration for the present study.

According to Leskes (2003, p.34), the main ideal of teaching lies not only in preparing high school students for tertiary education, but also in how teachers are trained in the first place. The author notes that the competence of teaching graduates to lead a diverse body of students to success is a critical factor in implementing the reforms necessary to bridge the gap between high school and a successful college career. These teaching students therefore need to be exposed not only to a wide body of diverse knowledge, but also how to practically impart this knowledge to a wide variety of students in a single classroom. The author suggests not so much a standardized curricular design to accomplish this, but rather a standardized set of outcomes against which faculty members can gauge their success.

It is emphasized that, like the future student body in high schools, teaching students are as diverse as the individuality of each, and hence no two will respond the same to curricular design. This is why collaboration within university campuses is also vital in order to identify learning needs and to meet these to the best of the faculty's ability. Integration is therefore not only necessary among teaching institutions, but also among faculties within single campuses, both at high school and tertiary level.

Handel and Montoya (2008/9, p. 26) indicate that the root of the problems lies in the interaction level between secondary and tertiary education institutions. The problem is that, despite the P-16 and K-20 program attempts, there is still a relatively small proportion of high school students that 1) successfully transfer to four-year tertiary institutions, and 2) successfully complete their studies at these institutions. It is therefore implied that the basic problem lies much deeper than a simple interaction paradigm among the institutions. In remedy, the authors suggest the building of a "transfer pipeline," wherein colleges and four-year institutions build address the needs of transferred students by environmental means.

One important factor is to distinguish among the needs of diverse students. Handel and Montoya for example note that community colleges often attract students that differ from "traditional" freshmen, in that they tend to be somewhat older, support families, and study on a part-time basis. It is therefore important to implement environmental support systems to ensure the success of such students. Orientation, tutorial, and mentoring programs are among the suggestions the authors make in this regard. In addition, academic skills such as study habits, and academic planning are also vital factors that can be promoted by means of environmental support systems.

In summary, the main problem then focuses upon the ability of secondary students to integrate into tertiary programs on the basis of the skills and abilities developed during their high school careers. In addition, there is a basic lack of support within tertiary institutions themselves to ensure the success of students that enter them. Finally, there is also a significant gap in terms of collaboration among tertiary and secondary institutions, with faculty members more often concerned with the reward of tenure than with supporting the students in their care.

These problems will be investigated and suggestions made regarding how policy and other paradigms can be used towards a remedy that will promote not only the well-being of individual students who enter tertiary programs, but also the collective workforce of the country.

Research Questions and Hypotheses

Questions and hypotheses will center upon the issues discussed above in order to reach the goals of the study, which is to identify the critical indicators that will allow the seamless integration of students today into tertiary study programs from their secondary school careers. In order to accomplish this, qualitative and quantitative questions must be formulated.

The research will then aim to answer the following qualitative questions

1) What policies are in place to support the integration of students from secondary to tertiary study?

2) What support systems are in place to help students at tertiary level succeed?

3) Are any programs in place to help secondary students prepare for the academic rigors of tertiary study?

4) How do secondary and tertiary students feel about their prospects of success at college and university level?

The research will aim to answer the following quantitative questions

1) How many students have successfully been integrated into tertiary programs from secondary school level?

2) What is the percentage of failure for students who enter tertiary programs directly from secondary schools?

3) What is the percentage of failure for students who enter community colleges from a disadvantaged, older demographic?

Hypotheses that relate to these questions are as follows:

1) Policy today is insufficient to seamlessly integrate secondary students at tertiary level.

2) Support systems are insufficient to meet the needs of students at tertiary or indeed at secondary level.

3) it is likely that most secondary and freshman-level tertiary students would be uncertain about the future of their studies and resulting careers.

4) it is likely that a fairly low percentage of students have been… READ MORE

How to Reference "Mix-Methods School Reform Study Exploring Critical Indicators" Methodology Chapter in a Bibliography

Related Methodology Chapters:

Overarching Goal Essay

overarching goal of this study was to develop an improved understanding concerning assessing and developing the survey research methodology within an educational setting in general and the use of the… read more

Essay 75 pages (18833 words) Sources: 40 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Students With Disabilities Who Did Not Complete Dissertation

Students With Disabilities Who Did Not Complete High School

Richard Wieringo

This case study explores the experiences of students with disabilities who have dropped out of high school, so as… read more

Dissertation 60 pages (17241 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Improving the High School Dropout Rate in Bermuda Thesis

Reduction of the High School Dropout Rate in Bermuda

The value of a high school education over the course of an individual's lifetime has been well documented, but many high… read more

Thesis 40 pages (10887 words) Sources: 25 Style: APA Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator MBTI Term Paper

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator is one of the most widely used tests in the world for assessing personality characteristics for general non-psychiatric populations. The authors state that it is a self-report… read more

Term Paper 18 pages (5698 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

International Procurement Dissertation

School of Engineering and Design

Science in [your course title goes here]

This study investigates the circumstances in which buying materials and components from foreign suppliers can offer benefits to… read more

Dissertation 56 pages (15360 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>