Term Paper on "John Stuart Mill Did Mill Place Any Limits on His Notion of Liberty"

Term Paper 4 pages (1324 words) Sources: 0

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Mill place any limits on his notion of liberty?

In his foundational treatise on the notion of liberty, John Stuart Mill opened Pandora's box for debate about the nature and limitations On Liberty. His defense of the fundamental democratic ideal forces scholars into two camps: the first heralds the writer as the true defender of freedom and civil liberty, the others arguing that his service was as no great defender, but instead as the consistent utilitarian. Steadily the political son of de Tocqueville, Mill's 1859 disquisition was immediately noted for its justification of the freedom of the individual in the face of a state imposition of control, from its inception a classic libertarian premise. However, Mill's idea of liberty was not boundless; while the first danger to liberty, he argued, is the threat of state control, its second danger is that to which most democracies are known, the "tyranny of the majority."

The political scientist microscopically examines the social system in which liberty might thrive best by posturing that in which it might be least threatened. In the face of pointed disagreement over the validity of his position, Mill is attributed a "a position which may be designated, for lack of a better term, as a doctrinaire liberalism." Mill's limits upon that numinous political ideal is limned by a conversation of elementary boundaries, but is otherwise a doctrine of complete freedom of thought and speech as an absolute and universal rule for society, shaped around the "Art of Life" expounded in System of Logic.

In System of Logic, Mill defines the three departments of the Art of life as morality, prudence, and aesthetics, in each case distinguishing the beautiful and noble aspects of judgment. Utilitarianism followed, surmounting a thesis of utilitarianism in which moral obligations are unable to be judged in any direct manner; Gray elaborates.

The plausibility of the substantive doctrines defended in these two essays thus depends in part upon the cogency of the conceptual analysis of Mill's Logic... Indeed, the subject matter of utility is not the moral rightness or wrongness of actions at all. Rather as an axiological princple specifying happiness as the only desirable end, quite distinct from any substantive moral disciple, Mill's utility principle is conceived as 'the test of all conduct.'"

This split level of morality and moral obligation defines the version of liberty Mill invasions; dubiously, some scholars, Gray among them, see this sanctity of obligation as proof that Mill believes firmly in the Enforcement of Morality. This "critical morality" extends directly to the Harm Principle, the source of inherent limitation witnessed in On Liberty.

Mill's conviction to moral wrongs are necessarily distinguished from what Gray calls "inexpedient actions," and that the punishment of that which is morally wrong is, ultimately, maximally expedient. On Liberty develops this correlation between wrong and recompense through the relationship of liberty and morality via the principle of self-protection. In On Liberty, liberty should be viewed as that "sole end for which mankind are warranted, individually or collectively, in interfering with the liberty or action of any other number."

Brown argues that Mill concludes through this phrase that unless "harm to others" can be prevented, there is no reason for any limitation upon liberty. "By giving this necessary condition for the existence of restriction, it rules out as irrelevant absolutely everything but the protection of harm to others." He continues, "This sharp and unequivocal denial is the cutting edge of Mill's essay." Brown correctly argues that liberty should be extend freely, but Mill further allows that limitations should be placed upon the extension of this liberty when it induces harm to others.

As such, the categorization of "harm to others" has been the source of repeated scholarly and political treatment, searching for the lines and ramifications by which this harm to others might be either acknowledged or prevented. The revisionists have supposed an action of self-protection and a distinction of self-regarding characteristics. Stephens argues this is inherently… READ MORE

How to Reference "John Stuart Mill Did Mill Place Any Limits on His Notion of Liberty" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

John Stuart Mill and Sigmund Freud Essay

SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY and the PERSPECTIVES of FREUD vs. MILL

The relationship between man and society has interested philosophers for millennia. On one hand, the structure and institutions of civil society… read more

Essay 7 pages (1940 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

John Stewart Mill Term Paper

John Stuart Mill

The 19th century witnessed the contributions of many philosophers, and one of the leading among them was J.S. Mill. His place of birth was London in the… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2516 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

John Stuart Mill on Liberty Book Report

John Stuart Mill and "Majority" Rule

John Stuart Mill's usage of the concept of "tyranny of the majority" comes, of course, from Alexis de Tocqueville, the Frenchman who examined the… read more

Book Report 2 pages (714 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics

---

Thomas Carlyle's Views on the Limits of Personal Liberty in His Book Past and Present Term Paper

personal freedom and also the limits of that freedom have been key in Western civilization for centuries. The problems raised were addressed by various writes and ethical theorists, including the… read more

Term Paper 12 pages (3796 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Violence: For God or Liberty the Social Essay

Violence: For God or Liberty

The social and political ideals of the modern Western world are founded on a notion of liberty, expressed dissimilarly (and with varying degrees of approbation)… read more

Essay 7 pages (2300 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>