Research Proposal on "Cultural Masculinity Issues in Criminal Behavior"

Research Proposal 12 pages (3714 words) Sources: 8 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Messerschmidt

That the prisons in the United States are bursting at the seams comes as no surprise, considering that more violent crimes occur here than any other industrialized country and incarceration has become the customary way of punishment for a wide range of crimes (INTERPOL). In 2007, 75.8% of all persons arrested were male, 81.8% of persons arrested for violent crime were male, and 66.6% of persons arrested for property crime were male (U.S. Department of Justice, 2009). This is nothing new, nor is it unusual for most countries around the world. Perhaps, this is why not many studies have been done on what makes men more crime-oriented. According to Hagedorn (1998), for whatever reason, within the realm of the social sciences, research has analyzed characteristics of women and how they relate to men rather than on the men, themselves. Because men have long been more prone to committing crime, this characteristic has somehow been ignored. Recently, academicians in the field of criminology, such as James Messerschmidt, have questioned the validity of the stereotypes that based on biology where "women are good, men are bad, plain and simple. And it is this essential badness that leads to patriarchy and violence against women" (Messerschmidt, 1993, p. 43). Instead, it is relevant to look also look at cultural factors, where males are socialized very early in their lives into what is culturally deemed masculine and recognize that if they do not conform to this norm, they will be ostracized.

Despite the dearth of studies on masculinity, the subject of what denotes "manliness" has long been addressed throughout human history. The Greek had the term thumos, for example, which was to explain the animal-like spirit of humans that makes them fight back when threatened. All human beings share this essence of thumos regardless of their background.

However, those who are considered manly have a great deal more of it and sometimes to an extreme amount, as noted: "It is the energy and initiative in their nature that may make them uncivilized'." I said; "if you treat it properly it should make them brave, but if you overstrain it turns them tough and uncouth, as you would expect.'" (Republic, ln. 410)

The debate about Nietzsche's underlying belief regarding gender, and women in general, will most likely continue ad infinitum. Was he truly a sexist and misogynist, a product of his German culture, or actually stating many of his anti-feminist comments tongue-in-cheek? Regardless which of these are actually true, in book five of the Gay Science, (2001, p. 227), Nietzche writes about "our faith in the masculinities of Europe" and how the "classic age of war" made "man in Europe to become the master over the businessman and the philistine -- perhaps even over 'woman,' who has been spoiled by Christianity and the enthusiastic spirit of the eighteenth century, and even more by 'modern ideas.'"

The first true advancement toward modern analysis of masculinity was seen in the works of Freudian psychoanalysis, which showed that adult character was not only biological and determined by the body, but also built through emotional relationships to others, in a chaotic growth process. Later, anthropologists, such as Malinowsky and Mead stressed the cultural distinctions and the importance of social norms (Connell, 1994). Similarly, from the viewpoint of role theory, Parsons (1968) called the sex roles of men, "instrumental," and women, "expressive." He also stated that young children learned and internalized these roles, which conveniently continued the established division of labor and the formed societal structure over time.

Betty Friedan's Feminine Mystique (1963) is often thought of initiating the women's movement that led the way to not only an emphasis on the females' function in society, but of the subsequent "male studies." Yet, ten years before this, Mira Komarovsky redefined Parsons' theory by instead stressing dysfunction, conflict, and change. She saw how the American woman's role radically changed After World War II. After the support they offered the troops by working in the factories at home and nursing in the battlefields in Europe, the women were immediately ousted away from these jobs and relegated back to the role of wife and mother to live in the suburbs and to wonder "what is wrong with me that home and family are not enough?"(1953, p. 77). As a professor at Barnard College, Komarovsky told all her female students to be prepared for careers. She also supported universally available nursery schools, so women could go back into the job market, and urged men to accept their fair share of domestic work. Ironically, she was still pushing for this last goal in 1985.

It has only been in the past several decades, and especially since the turn of the century, that a significant number of studies have been conducted on men and masculinity, with the social sciences having produced the predominance of research. It was in the 1970s that the topic of masculinity had begun to be seriously studied. It came about as part of the women's movement and the emphasis on breaking away from the confines of the patriarchal society that males had conveniently established to keep females in their defined roles.

With the development of the "Men's Movement," masculinity research began to be seen in greater numbers. Tolson (the Limits of Masculinity, 1976) emphasized that masculinity was not any more uni-dimensional than femininity, and it existed for more reasons beyond the continuation of the patriarchal society. For the first time, it was noted that masculinity should not be recognized as basic essence but a product of cultural and historical force.

In the 1980s, Connell (1987) established the term hegemonic masculinity to explain the hierarchical relationship between several masculinities and the way some males make it seem normal and critical that they dominate most women and other men. In the construct of gender relations, hegemonic masculinity is about the actual system and the structure in place that acts to procreate masculine domination. Connell drew many of his insights from feminist researchers who examined how gender relationships mold social structures. His hoped to show not only how some men were able to easily establish their dominant position, but also why other women and men allowed themselves to be oppressed by these individuals and the means by which hegemonic masculinity can be diminished to promote gender equality and improve societal circumstances.

Connell (1985) argued that there is no one overriding form of masculinity or femininity in Western industrialized countries and that these change according to history. Masculinity, despite being a concept related very closely with femininity, is wrongly established as its opposite. Connell identified four separate ways to view the masculinity concept.

Essentialist, where one masculinity characteristic is given more importance, but there is no agreement to that characteristic. (for example, men are aggressive); 2) positivist, founded on what men do as men, but no thought is given to how the cultural context make these different (for instance, male/female psychological testing; 3) Normative, or what men are told they should or should not do, which is built into the symbolic representations about the ideal man (for example, male sport stars); and 4) Semiotic, or what masculinity includes and femininity does not: "The phallus is master-signifier and femininity is symbolically define by lack." (Connell,1985, p.70).

According to Connell and Messerschmidt (2005) this concept of hegemonic masculinity was applied to research in the field of education to better understand the activities taking place in the classroom for such behaviors as resistance and bullying among boys. The hegemonic theory also helped to better understand the curriculum and the problems with gender-neutral pedagogy (Martino 1995), as well as teacher planning. It further provided help in theorizing the relationship among masculinities and a variety of crimes (Messerschmidt, 1993) in addition to research on specific crimes committed by boys and men.

Connell and Messerschmidt (2005) also write of the influence that the hegemonic masculinity theory has had on studying media representations of men, such as the interconnection between sports and war imagery. As a result, media researchers started looking at the relations among representations of different masculinities. "Commercial sports are a focus of media representations of masculinity, and the developing field of sports sociology also found significant use for the concept of hegemonic masculinity" (Messner, 1992). The hegemonic theory was therefore utilized to better understand the popularity of body-contact confrontational sports, such as football and hockey, that function as an continually revived symbol of masculinity. It also helped to better comprehend the violence and homophobia frequently found in sporting milieus. Violence has also been an integral part of movies and television, and, most recently, electronic gaming.

Also in the 1980s and 1990s, social scientists began to extend the understanding of masculinity and femininity in society by looking at the connection between gender and crime. Some of these thoughts were based on Parsons (1968), who argued that masculinity was internalized during adolescence and encouraged boys to participate in more delinquent behavior than girls. Similarly, Cloward and Ohlin (1960) suggested the differential opportunity… READ MORE

How to Reference "Cultural Masculinity Issues in Criminal Behavior" Research Proposal in a Bibliography

Related Research Proposals:

Criminal Behavior Theories That Relate to Armed Robbery Thesis

Armed Robbery and Criminal Behavior Theories

There are well-documented theories in the field of criminology to help researchers understand why incidents of armed robbery take place -- but many questions… read more

Thesis 5 pages (1735 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Violent Criminal Behavior Research Paper

Violent Criminal Behavior

Uniqueness of Rape as a Crime

Behavioral Identification and Classification of Rape as a Crime

Characteristics of Victims

Modus Operandi (MO) and Signatures

Disorganized Asocial Offender

Organized… read more

Research Paper 7 pages (2324 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Hollywood Does Not Glorify Criminal Behavior Research Paper

Hollywood movies do not glorify criminal behavior. On the contrary, the industry glorifies the hero and stigmatizes the criminal for his behavior and crimes against society. American gangster movies' initial… read more

Research Paper 11 pages (3605 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

Diversity in a Police Force Police Departments Research Proposal

Diversity in a Police Force

Police departments in the 21st century enjoy a level of technology that would make Dick Tracy envious, but they are also faced with several challenges… read more

Research Proposal 30 pages (8386 words) Sources: 30 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Gender Socialization and Criminal Inclination Differential Capstone Project

Gender Socialization and Criminal Inclination

Differential Socialization Based on Gender in Western Society

One of the most universal issues in human socialization is the degree to which males and females… read more

Capstone Project 2 pages (610 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>