Essay on "Mencius' View That Human Nature Is Good"

Essay 3 pages (1049 words) Sources: 0

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Mencius' view that Human Nature is Good with Hsun Tzu's theory that "Human Nature is Bad?

At first view, Mencius' theory that humans are intrinsically good and Hsun Tzu's theory that 'human nature is bad' seem irrevocably opposed one to the other. However, investigation of each shows them to share commonalties.

Mencius' perspective on the goodness of human nature comes with a proviso. Whilst he does believe that humans are innately good and like a plant possesses the innate potential to grow in a certain direction towards that goodness whilst also containing within its qualities the emotional resources to grip onto that ideal, he believes that environment and sensual propensities can corrupt that goodness (Lau, 1970).

Man has four Beginnings, (ren (humanness), li (observance of rites), and yi (propriety) and, zhi (wisdom) (Lau, 1970)) and he has these four Beginnings just as he has limbs. The right education in a positive environment will foster these limbs, the wrong will destruct them. In other words, these four predispositions or ethical attributes, ren, yi, li, and zhi have to be cultivated. They are simply 'sprouts' and can easily be damaged or they can grow to flourishing plants. It is in this way that Mencius probably placed zhi, heart / mind as the counterpoint (Shun, 1997). Zhi' requires the ability to follow affect or cognition according to one's best discretion, to balance the two, and to achieve a rational equilibrium in assessing situations and formulating decisions.

It is the senses, maintained Mencius that cause the 'plant' i.e. man's innate positive faculties to wilt, and here Mencius provides the example of King Xuan of the state of Qi who, in his passions for wealth, women, and egoism (desire to demonstrate his grandeur), led him to irrational and harsh government. In this way the king who could have by nature achieved tian ming, a fate granted by the skies (or Western correlated term God) the ability to rule well since de -- his praiseworthy qualities would have deserved the respect of the people, thwarted and perverted these good qualities so that he turned into a tyrant. The senses have a strong impulsion that can destruct the plant, but to counteract that, we have the heart / mind that potentially enables the plant to flourish. The senses operate automatically; as contrast, heart/mind has the ability to pull back, to reflect, and to help man move along in a more prudent direction (Shun, 1997).

Mencius also believes that man can be deluded by erroneous ethical doctrines such as the teachings of Hsun Tzu and of the Yangists (Shun, 1997) who advocated pandering to one's nature (to the natural laws), to one's natural inclinations in a way that is similar to hedonism.

Hsun Tzu is similar to Mencius in some ways. The differences originate from the polar manner in which each interprets Confucius' definition of tian -- Heaven. Whilst tian was first regarded in a neutral way as simply determining the predestination of man, the miseries and anarchy of the middle Zhou period caused individuals of that period to perceive tian and associated Ming with a jaundiced perspective. Tian wasn't… READ MORE

How to Reference "Mencius' View That Human Nature Is Good" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Human Nature Has Been a Subject Essay

Human nature has been a subject of debate amongst the classical Chinese philosophers. Please present your understanding of this concept by focusing on one or two Chinese philosophers' perspective.

When… read more

Essay 7 pages (2811 words) Sources: 11 Topic: Biology / Life

---

Human Nature Term Paper

Human Nature

Philosophers have contemplated the innate nature of mankind for many centuries, asserting that human nature is inherently good, evil or neutral. Mencius, a Chinese philosopher from the fourth… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (711 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Plato, Mencius, and Hsun Tzu on Human Term Paper

Plato, Mencius, And Hsun Tzu on Human Nature

Reading Response

Human beings have been faced with many challenges like war, power, and crime. These challenges have caused problems for mankind… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2092 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Mencius and Xunzi Term Paper

Mencius and Xunzi

Both these philosophers are part of the classical age of Chinese philosophy which occurred during the ending years of the Zhou or Chou dynasty. In Christian terms,… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (2204 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Philosophy / Logic / Reason

---

Good and Evil Term Paper

Good and Evil

Aristotle bases ethics on his view on the universe. He considers that the universe is a strictly defined hierarchy wherein everything fulfills a particular function. He states… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2990 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>