Term Paper on "Marxist Criticism of the Great Gatsby"

Term Paper 6 pages (1740 words) Sources: 3

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Marxist Reading of the Great Gatsby

Works of literature can be read through a Marxist lens because the work says something about the real conditions and prevailing attitudes of the time. These are the real conditions that were determinative for social interactions which Marx referred to in his key statement: "The sum total of these relations of production constitutes the economic structure of society, the real foundation, on which rises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite forms of social consciousness" (Marx, preface). From this material base of production rise the social distinction of classes and all their ideologies and form of consciousness. The text represents the values that culturally produced it. Therefore, it can be explored for the social relations it describes, which are based on the material realities of production described within it. F. Scott Fitzgerald's realistic novel The Great Gatsby (1925) is thus a good choice for analysis.

The important underlying assumptions of a Marxist criticism rise from Marx's statement. For one thing, Marxist criticism focuses on the economic systems that influence human experience and interaction. It grounds itself on an analysis of the material (socioeconomic) forces that shape the behavior of characters, as well as on the hidden ideological superstructure that reinforces those material conditions. Another assumption is that economic power is the motive for all social activity. That means that a person designs their relationships and behaviors so that they will possess, maintain, or increase their own power. This striving for power produces the historical situation or ideological atmosphere that aims at perpetuating those material conditions. A Marxist analysis looks at the power dynamics that inhere in socioeconomic class structures. It believes in clear class distinctions based on work and wealth. In addition, there are many ideologies (such as rugged individualism, the American dream, religion) that are consumed, according to Marxism, in a way that serves the interests of the ruling (aristocratic) class. Ideology is a deceptive means of social control in which the relations are material production (wealth) are conceived. These are hidden, absorbed unconsciously, and presented falsely as innate. Their effect is false consciousness and alienation.

When Marxism approaches a text, it is these relations of power, class, and ideology that it attends to in the characters. Tyson writes, "Marxism works to make us constantly aware of all the ways in which we are products of material/historical circumstances and of the repressive ideologies that serve to blind us to this fact in order to keep us subservient to the ruling power system" (Tyson 57). It looks at how unnatural relationships between human are portrayed as static and naturalized. It is the goal of Marxist criticism to uncover the ideologies and social relations in the text and to analyze how they undergird or support the material modes of production and power structures. This includes analyzing consumerism. According to Tyson, "From a Marxist perspective, because the survival of capitalism, which is a market economy, depends on consumerism, it promotes sign-exchange value as our primary mode of relating to the world around us" (Tyson 62). That is, instead of use or exchange value, it stresses symbolic value that is not material and not inherent in the object. It is seen only as social status, or symbolic capital. This social capital is used to promote the values and interests of the propertied classes and to maintain social class distinction.

This paper will argue that far from subverting the prevailing ideology of the class system and its productive relations, Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby affirms it. This is evident in the fate of the upstart Gatsby, who despite his best efforts to enter the aristocratic world finds himself unable to achieve his aims. His relationships with other characters are shallow, manipulative, and ultimately devastating. Meanwhile, Tom and Daisy come out of the conflict unscathed, thus showing how their class power retains its authoritative and untouchable status. This paper will also make the case that women in the text are little more than sites of contested power between men. In Myrtle's case, she dreams of the rich life, but is exploited and run down because she is poor and powerless. In Daisy's case, the men fight over her through references to economic and social power. The men engage in a system of status and social power at their expense. There is little in this novel that is socially redeemable from a Marxist perspective.

The status of Jay Gatsby revolves around his desire to attain love with Daisy, which he attempts by adopting the ideology of wealth. When he returns from war, Daisy has abandoned him and married the wealthy Tom, who has inherited his vast fortune. The disappointment, defined by Gatsby's lower class poverty creates the drive behind Gatsby's every move. Obsessed with reclaiming his lost love, Gatsby devises a plan that involves the material production of wealth and the complete assimilation of the ideology that affluence can buy love. While his underlying motive is love, he uses material means to enable this reclamation.

Significantly, since he is from the lower class, he must manufacture wealth through unsavory means. Gatsby's wealth is built on illegal activities spawned by 1920s prohibition. This requires secrecy -- no one is quite sure where his money comes from. Mystery is the pervasive aura surrounding him. At his elaborate parties, designed only to flaunt wealth, he is virtually unseen, just a shadowy figure with a murky past. Nick sees him "standing alone on the marble steps and looking from one group to another with approving eyes" (50, Chapter 3). Rumors swirl about his having killed someone or being a spy. Nick thinks, "It was testimony to the romantic speculation he inspired that there were whispers about him" (44, Chapter 3). The material production for his lavish and conspicuous displays comes at the price of remaining alone, isolated, and unknown. That is Gatsby's consciousness. In other words, Gatsby is alienated from himself and from others because of the ideology he has assumed. He is almost impersonal and incapable of real relation. This detachment is imposed on him by capitalistic conditions in which making an honest living could not enable him to achieve the wealth he needs to entice Daisy back.

Gatsby's self-alienation and orientation toward symbolic capital from material wealth is clear in his pursuit of Daisy. Gatsby believes that "Her voice is full of money" (120, Chapter 7). Because Daisy wants wealth, she becomes the source of his illusion. He cannot relate to her outside of the demonstration of his economic image. When he reintroduces himself to Daisy, his whole goal is to tantalize her with his material success. He tours her through his mansion, which he keeps "always full of interesting people, night and day" (90, Chapter 5). His relation to her is commodified, placed at the level of the symbolic display of wealth. It reaches an absurd climax when she collapses on his imported English shirts, sobbing, "It makes me sad because I've never seen such -- such beautiful shirts before" (92, Chapter 5). The scene demonstrates Gatsby's internalization of an ideological illusion. He believes that material wealth equals persuasive power, which Daisy perpetuates. Gatsby's image comes from his desire to attain social status.

This ideology leads Gatsby to manipulate Nick. Gatsby does not treat him as a human being so much as a tool that he can use to draw Daisy to him. Nick is commodified in this way. Gatsby uses Nick's relationship with Jordan to arrange a meeting with Daisy at his house. Nick sees through Gatsby. He realizes how deluded he is: "There must have been moments even that afternoon when Daisy tumbled short of his dreams -- not through her own fault, but because of the colossal vitality of his illusion" (95-96, Chapter 5). As soon as the affair is begun, Nick vanishes. He is forgotten and says, "Gatsby didn't know me now at all" (96, Chapter 5). There is no real relation between the two men outside of dehumanized social relations.

Nick's approach to Gatsby shows the affirmation of the class system. Nick is neither lured into dishonesty, nor does he care about wealth. He says, "I took dinner usually at the Yale Club -- for some reason it was the gloomiest event of my day -- and then I went upstairs to the library and studied investments and securities for a conscientious hour" (56, Chapter 3). In this sense, he represents the man who has imbibed the middle class work ethic, the ideology that honest work is virtue, which is neither resistant to the system nor challenging to it. In addition, Nick comes to despise Gatsby. From the honest social underside, he comes to see Gatsby as a fiend. At the end he says, "It was the only compliment I ever gave him, because I disapproved of him from beginning to end" (154, Chapter 8). He holds no particular reverence for Gatsby's ethic, wealth, or status since he himself is relatively poor. Overall, his… READ MORE

How to Reference "Marxist Criticism of the Great Gatsby" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Marxist Criticism of the Characters in Richard Wright's Native Son Essay

Marxist Criticism "Native Son"

A Marxist Interpretation of Richard Wright's Native Son

In Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, it is stated that history is a series of class struggles over the… read more

Essay 8 pages (2152 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald Was Born Research Paper

Great Gatsby

F. Scott Fitzgerald was born in Minnesota in 1896, a descendent of the author of "The Star Spangled Banner," hence the name "Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald." Fitzgerald attended… read more

Research Paper 6 pages (2143 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Great Gatsby: The Moral Journey of Nick Essay

Great Gatsby: The Moral Journey of Nick Caraway

Brief overview of the novel.

What Gatsby represents

To society at large

To Nick Carraway, the narrator

Exposition: The values of the… read more

Essay 3 pages (834 words) Sources: 0 Style: MLA Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Great Gatsby, Acknowledged as a Principal Work Term Paper

Great Gatsby, acknowledged as a principal work of fiction during its time, contains in its thematic core the ideal of upward social and economic mobility, dubbed the American Dream. Evidence… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (920 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Great Gatsby the Prevailing Theme Term Paper

Great Gatsby

The prevailing theme in the Great Gatsby is the quest for the American Dream and, more importantly, how the American Dream is unattainable. It is a tale full… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (802 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>