Essay on "Marx Weber Politics, Economy and Philosophy"

Essay 3 pages (1208 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Marx Weber

Politics, Economy and Philosophy

At the core of Marxist principle is the idea that individual experience is formed upon one's response to institutional and social parameters. Marx understands individuals as being largely molded by the environs which surround them. Therefore, his conception of man as inherently driven by necessity for survival denotes a society driven by labor. All men are simultaneously responsible for themselves and, as an extension of this, for a role within the socioeconomic scheme. Here, Marx notes that "it is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness." (Tucker, 4) the moral order, the sense of devotion to authority and the submission to such forces as a capitalist economy will occur upon the basis of man's conscience not as an independently functioning thing but as a channel for society's ideals, leading to sense of interdependence that inherently inclines a division of labor. The attainment of freedom is in such a system, Marx would argue, illusory. Indeed, Marx argues that the materialist imperatives foisted upon man by class divisions and their resultant spectrum of needs, have contributed to a devolution of equality.

Materialism, for Weber, to the contrary, would be considered a defensible moral approach to economic and political organization simultaneously. A telling doctrine to the early frankness of capitalist imbalance, Weber's essay work is rife with endorsements of many principles which would be considered morally reprehensible, at least explicitly and by policy, to most sitting governments in the industrialized world. It is thus that the social scientist produces an understanding for the ideological underpinnings of the unique Protestant dominance of the global economy through its natural ascension to capitalism. The natural order of demographic superiority adopted by this group would tie directly into the ethical justification of its otherwise grotesque approach to economic organization. The Gerth text notes to this end that "throughout his life, Weber was a nationalist and wished his nation to qualify as Herrenvolk yet at the same time he fought for individual freedom and, with analytic detachment, characterized the ideas of nationalism and racism as justificatory ideologies used by the ruling class, and their hireling publicists, to beat their impositions into weaker members of the polity." (Gerth et al., 25) to Weber, the entitlement toward ruthlessness that justified such governmental behavior and which had an historical impact of forcing its authority and rightness through the mechanisms of feudalism had served as a precursor for market capitalism.

In this regard, we can see that Weber viewed as inherent the transition into a materialist-defined freedom as is perpetuated by the United States and other capitalist economies. Differing from Marx, who instead understood labor as preeminent in defining social opportunity, Weber would contribute to the work of Adam Smith. Adam Smith, in his landmark composition on capitalism, would identify free market economic opportunity as tantamount to individual liberties. In the ensuing years, this has become a centerpiece of American identity, corresponding with the vision held by the framers of the Constitution. In their creation of a government at the Constitutional Convention, the framer's would betray a desire to retain a distinct socioeconomic caste system while promoting the rhetoric of individual liberty.

It is perhaps the work of Hegel, who served as a mentor for Marx, which ties this concise discussion together by suggesting that the 'idea' of a specific society is reciprocated by the conscience of its people. Hegel indicates that as a reflection of man's collective consciousness, 'society' will become this tangible and manifest force in the interwoven lives of all men. Thus, Marx would… READ MORE

How to Reference "Marx Weber Politics, Economy and Philosophy" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Hannah Arendt and Karl Jaspers Term Paper

Hannah Arendt and Karl Jaspers have very similar ideas on Totalitarian.

The human trait that leads to the destruction of the society is the struggle for power. This is due… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2765 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Government / Politics

---

Classical Social Theory and Donald Trump Term Paper

As Royce summarizes Weber's analysis

The encroachment of bureaucracy constrains the decision-making authority of economic and political leaders, limiting the potential for rejuvenating social change and the periodic disruption of… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2156 words) Sources: 4 Topic:

---

Max Weber's Protestant Ethic Term Paper

Protestant Ethic" and the Evolution of Capitalism

Maximilian Weber was one of the most influential German political economists and sociologists. He began his career at the University of Berlin and… read more

Term Paper 23 pages (7228 words) Sources: 7 Style: Chicago Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

Social Theory the Wide Diversity of Human Term Paper

Social Theory

The wide diversity of human behavior in a social setting for thousands of years makes it imperative to study these societies to better understand their properties. What are… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1801 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Rule of Law Today in China Research Paper

China and the Rule of Law

A kind of democratic transformation is underway in Communist China, and that is thanks in no small part to China's race toward modernity. Such… read more

Research Paper 16 pages (4898 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>