Essay on "Outcome of Anatomy of a Murder"

Essay 4 pages (1307 words) Sources: 1

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Irresistible impulses:" Robert Traver's Anatomy of a Murder

Given the sympathetic circumstances regarding the murder that takes place in Robert Traver's courtroom drama novel Anatomy of a Murder, it seems unsurprising that the defendant Lieutenant Manion is found' not guilty.' At the end of the novel, Manion is said to be innocent of the crime of murdering Barney Quill in cold blood, despite the fact that Manion admits he pulled the trigger. Quill is apparently a criminal himself: the bar owner committed the unspeakable crime of raping Manion's wife Laura. The jury, over the course of the trial, is presented with a mounting array of evidence that is not legally persuasive in terms of Manion's legal innocence, but the facts still make the Lieutenant a more sympathetic individual in the eyes of the jurors -- thus he is acquitted. Quill was widely disliked in the town, and few were surprised he came to a violent end. The sense that Quill 'got what he deserved' clearly influences the verdict, particularly since the trial's venue was not changed and took place in the midst of a community where many individuals had suffered run-ins with Quill. Manion's case symbolic reflects Traver's belief that the American justice system is based less upon truth than upon emotions and the skills of lawyers.

"I've known for years, of course, as you doubtless have, that murder juries invariably 'try' the victim as well as the killer," says the judge of the case (Traver 431). Traver's narrative suggests that the law is not above human emotions: jurors are more apt to believe that a defendant is temporarily insane if the reasons for his supposed insanity seem heroic and chivalrous. The case pits a living member of the armed forces against a dead barkeeper who lives in a trailer park. All-too-human jurors believe that the defendant is the nobler of the two individuals.

From the standpoint of legal analysis, Manion's actions were not committed in the heat of passion and his murder is not defensible like 'killing the iceman' or killing a woman's lover when a pair are unexpectedly found in a tryst. But while the standard for the insanity defense is usually based upon knowing right from wrong, at the time, in Michigan, there was also a legal addendum to the insanity defense of an "irresistible impulse." This idea suggests that even though the defendant could tell right from wrong, he was subject to the duress of a mental illness at the time of the killing. The 'illness' is responsible for the crime as the defendant has "lost the power to choose between right and wrong" and "his free agency was at the time destroyed" (Phelps 2006). Thus, "the alleged crime was so connected with such mental disease, in the relation of cause and effect, as to have been the product of it [the mental illness] solely" and thus the defendant is innocent (Phelps 2006).

However, some of the details of the crime do not seem to be consistent with defense attorney Biegler's description of Manion being in a dissociative state. After committing the crime in the trailer park where Quill lived, Manion calmly and rationally turned the gun over to the park attendant and waited for the police. Even more damming to the case of the defense is the degree to which Biegler seems to influence Manion's recollections of what transpired. At first, even Manion does not believe that the 'irresistible impulse' concept applies to his situation, until Biegler suggests it to him. "You mean you want to find a way to give the jurors some decently plausible legal peg to hand their verdict on so they might let me go - and still save face" finally asks Manion, naively innocent of the nature of the legal system (Traver 43). The calculated nature by which Biegler shapes Manion's recollections of what transpired is one of the more shocking… READ MORE

How to Reference "Outcome of Anatomy of a Murder" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Wrongful Convictions Term Paper

Wrongful Convictions

Within the past decades in the U.S., about 183 people have been absolved basing on the new evidence because of DNA testing. This reality gives unquestionable scientific testimony… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2640 words) Sources: 6 Style: MLA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Meagans Law Meagan's Law Questions and Answers Essay

Meagans Law

Meagan's law

Questions and Answers: Meagan's law

Questions and Answers: Meagan's law

Interviewing children requires a unique set of skills to accurately assess but at the same time,… read more

Essay 14 pages (5402 words) Sources: 28 Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

European Renaissance Term Paper

European Renaissance and the Birth of Science

The Western World has gone through many stages of development and growth over the course of the last two millennia. From the times… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1858 words) Sources: 3 Topic: World History

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>