Case Study on "Innovation in Semco Organization"

Case Study 11 pages (3446 words) Sources: 20

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Innovation in Semco Organization

The new century is the century of advancements like never before. The world is changing at a rapid pace and individuals, communities and entire societies need to remain alert to all these changes and quickly answer the emergent requirements. While this necessity might not be as obvious for individuals, it has become a constant within organizational entities.

Economic agents are now faced with the necessity of continually monitoring the market place -- both national as well as international --, identifying the new elements and quickly adapting to them. For instance, they are required to better train and motivate the staff members and to better integrate them within the organizational context in order to best capitalize on their skills and intellectual capital. Additionally, economic agents need to continually assess the changing demands of customers and satisfy their modifying needs. To be one step ahead of the competition, it is even important that economic agents foresee customers' needs and satisfy them even before the very customers become aware of the existence of these needs.

At the level of the manufacturing process, it is required that the companies purchase and integrate the latest available machineries, which not only increase the efficiency of the operational processes, but also reduce the levels of waste and pollution in order to better protect the environment. The list of modern day requirements to which economic agents have to respond could go on for pages. Yet, the question at this stage refers to the very ability of individual companies to identify these needs and implement them. In other words, are economic agents able to implement innovation in order to consolidate their positions? The answer depends on the individual characteristics of each economic entity, but this current project focuses on answering the innovation question for Semco S.A.

2. Semco S.A.

Semco S.A. was founded in 1950 as a manufacturer of centrifuges for the oil industry. Throughout the years however, it has significantly diversified its operations and has expanded to the production of various other equipments. The company's growth strategy has included a series of mergers and acquisitions, but also partnerships with various global companies. Through this strategic approach, Semco has increased not only in size, but also in strength, expertise, skills or market coverage. The company takes great pride in the distinctive business model it implements. "Semco does not follow the standards of other companies with a predefined hierarchy and excessive formality. At Semco, people work with substantial freedom, without formalities and with a lot of respect. Everybody is treated equally, from high-ranking executives to the lowest ranked employees. This means the work of each person is given its true importance and everybody is much happier at work" (Semco Website, 2009).

The Brazilian manufacturing organization holds true to the following ten business principles and values:

(1) Dependability and reliability

(2) Honesty and transparency

(3) the seeking of a balance between short tern gains and long-term gains

(4) the offering of high quality products at affordable prices

(5) the provision with various customer services

(6) the encouragement of creativity

(7) the encouragement of employee participation

(8) the maintenance of an informal and pleasant working environment

(9) the maintenance of a safe working environment, and finally

(10) the ability to recognize the mistakes and the realization of future improvement possibilities (Website of the Semco S.A.).

Semco S.A. is currently run by Ricardo Semler, the chief executive officer of the organization and its main shareholder. Under his leadership, the company has evolved and has come to implement a model of open management. Through this business model, people are empowered and stimulated to play a more active role in business operations and decisions. In other words, the business model at Semco is focused on building creative teams which capitalize on individually and creativity. This is only possible due to the transformational characteristics of the managers. As a parenthesis, the Semco managers are transformational as they stimulate their subalterns to grow professionally and develop their skills, rather than obediently follow instructions.

While the business model at Semco would initially seem bold, daring and innovative, it is in fact complex and tedious, and it stifles creativity and innovation in a series of other aspects. The following section details on this issue.

3. Approach to Innovation at Semco

Given the modifications of the past few decades, innovation is often associated with the advent of technology, the creation and introduction of the internet or the development of numerous hi-tech applications. In this scenario, an idea was generalized according to which innovations became synonymous with technology. While this perception is understood in the context in which, during the recent years, innovations in the organizational context were indeed introduced through newer and better technologies, it remains false. In this order of ideas, innovation represents an act of improving an older action, element, system and so on by adding a new feature. The Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English defines innovation simply as "a new idea, method or invention; the introduction of new ideas or methods" (LDOCE Online, 2010).

In terms of Semco then, the assessment of their innovation approach is pegged not only to the integration of technology, but also includes other elements, such as management control, problem solving, decision making or communications. A discussion of these organizational elements is revealed throughout the following paragraphs:

3.1. Management control

An important element to be noted about the managerial act at Semco is that each board member is given equal right and power to vote on organizational propositions and endeavors. While this system is highly democratic, it is also highly inefficient as it often delays the decision making process. In some instances, this has materialized in the loss of business opportunities.

Throughout the organization, the actual implication of the managerial team remains limited. The executives at the Brazilian Semco S.A. encourage their staff members to manage themselves. The managers even set their own salaries and the employees make their own working schedules. They do not have assistants and all the staff members share in the profit distribution; everybody knows how much the other earns.

In terms of managerial structures and hierarchies, Semler removed the large majority of them; there were twelve managerial layers initially (Thompson and Martin, 2009). Today, Semco S.A. reveals three layers of managerial structures and a chief executive officer. The organizational managers do not have executive titles and the company has renounced the job titles. The organizational leaders are selected through vote by the employees and they are continually evaluated. This model of apparent chaos was implemented in the beginning of the 1980s decade, when the Brazilian organization was facing major difficulties in production levels and competitive edge (Semler, 2001). All in all, the managerial act and the managerial control at Semco are limited in comparison to most organizations, and the philosophy behind them seems to be: "give people the freedom to do what they want, and over the long haul their successes will outnumber their failures" (a Great Supervisor, 2005).

At a general level, the managerial model implemented by Semco is by all accounts interesting, yet, it can then be stated that it lacks in innovative elements.

3.2. Decision making

As it has been mentioned throughout the previous sections, the business model at Semco S.A. is open and focused on employee empowerment and participation. At the level of the board, the decision making process is tedious as it implies the agreement of several managers. At the level of the employees, the process is tedious and complex as well, but it is also risky as not all employees are as able as the board members to make decisions. In other words, innovation is indeed implemented in the decision making process at Semco S.A., but the selected innovation is not adequate as it generates several disadvantages and limitations.

Some of the shortcomings of the collective decision making process at Semco S.A. relate to the following:

The process is "time-consuming […and it] may limit create inefficiency and limit management's ability top respond quickly to a situation

Social pressures to conform can squash disagreement and promote conformity

Domination of the group by one person or a few individuals may decrease effectiveness, and Responsibility is ambiguous" (Freeman, 1999).

Due to this style of decision making, coupled with the permissive approach to employee management, the creativity graph is impacted. At a first component of idea birth, a multitude of ideas exist. At the second level of idea growth and implementation, few ideas are actually implemented due to the required consensus. Finally, in the third stage of the creativity graph -- the death of the idea -- few lessons are learnt from the passing of the creativity component.

3.3. Problem Solving

Similar to decision making, the problem solving mechanisms at Semco S.A. are constructed on the principles of employee empowerment and participation. This often leads to deepened arguments and an inability to resolve disputes as agreements and common solutions cannot always be reached. Through the new business model implemented by Semler, the… READ MORE

How to Reference "Innovation in Semco Organization" Case Study in a Bibliography

Related Papers:

Organizational Theory 'There Is a Thin Line Term Paper

Organizational Theory

'There is a thin line between innovation and imitation in entrepreneurship.' Discuss this statement using perspectives from organization theory.

Innovation and imitation are both important propellers of economic… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1832 words) Sources: 8 Style: MLA Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organizational Change and Development Essay

Organizational Change and Development

The critical enterprise consists, ideally, of three aspects: (1) explanation and critique of current systems and the historical currents that have given rise to them, (2)… read more

Essay 10 pages (2653 words) Sources: 12 Style: APA Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organizational Structure One Belief I Have Accepted Term Paper

Organizational Structure

One belief I have accepted in my life is the structure of many organizations. I believed that the layering of management in organizations was the right way to… read more

Term Paper 1 pages (339 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organizational Diagnosis Burke and Litwin Model Essay

Organizational Diagnosis

Burke & Litwin Model

There is a linkage that has been suggested by the Burke & Litwin Model or the Causal Model of Organizational Performance and Change. Hypothesis… read more

Essay 4 pages (1469 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>