Essay on "Inclusive Approach Reflecting a More Inclusive World"
Essay 5 pages (1549 words) Sources: 5
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Inclusive Approach Reflecting a More Inclusive WorldKwame Anthony Appiah resurrects the question aptly and ironically raised by Rodney King after race riots in Los Angeles nearly thirty years ago, "People, why can't we all just get along?" In our efforts to do that in which Mr. King alludes, we have tried studying class, gender, and race; and, indeed, in the past three decades since Mr. King posed the poignant question, there has been a wide expanse in research, literature, and popular attention to class, gender, and race (Appiah). However, we must not just embark upon our journey of understanding these social constructs in a separatist fashion or in a manner that focuses solely upon the content of each construct. A thorough understanding of these constructs necessarily involves exploring class, gender, and race according to their contexts, or, in more specific words, according to the time and place in which these constructs have been lived within society and our shared histories. In particular, in examining the histories of race, gender, and class within societies amongst societies, colonialist and post-colonialist work should not isolate these theories from the overlying social, economic, and political forces that come with imperialism. To do so, would deny the complexity of society and the histories of the persons living within said societies. We, as human beings, do not operate in isolated substrands of class or of gender or of race. Accordingly, in order to understand each other better, we cannot extrapolate notions of imperialism from race, gender, and class when looking back at colonialism and its impact upon individual nation-states, cultures, and identities.
Karl Ma
download full paper ⤓
Critics of Marx's unilaterally focused ideology might ask questions which expand notions of equality outside the realm of class and labor. Specifically, a more holistic set of questions might incorporate an analysis of gender and race along with class. Namely, how can mere redistribution of land in and of itself remedy deeply engrained inequities within society that had predominated for centuries? In particular, what about women who had been relegated to the domestic sphere for centuries? What about slaves who had been uprooted from their tribes and families and used as cheap labor and, thus, relegated to the social status of second-class citizen (if even that) in Europe? Indeed, more than just class inequity have postulated that Marx's view is shortsighted at best because a redistribution of wealth does not necessarily take into consideration the need to also level the field in the domains of gender as well as race.
Indeed, such criticism is well taken, however if we do that which these critics would have us do (e.g., analyze class, gender, and race in the context of the time), then Marx is not the near-sighted idealist that some would like to make him out to be. In fact, in a letter to a German newspaper at the time of the publication of the Manifesto, he notes that his Communist Manifesto was not intended to cure all of societies ills. Moreover, in examining the context in which he wrote the Manifesto, the bitter feuds within Europe were, indeed, precipitated by economic forces that lead to extreme wealth at the expense of the working class who could not even afford basic necessities of life such as bread and clean water. Thus, if we examine Marx's manifesto as a product of his time an his place and to the realm in which he wrote, economics, then his words continue to have import and are not shortsighted. While his study could be and later would be expanded into the realms of feminism and class, they are when examined as a historical document a truly direct representation of the economic underpinnings of the social and political conflict of his era.
In the century following Marx's Manifesto, feminist scholars such as Alice-Kessler-Herris author of "Social History" and Joan W. Scott author of "Gender: A Useful Category of Historiographical Analyses," linked the history of women and gender to previous areas of society which has predominantly been studied and analyzed excluding the perspective and experiences of women. In "Social History" by Kessler-Herris, she notes that beginning in the 1960's the study of history had seemed to reach a point where the voices of the excluded began to be examined and history included the social structures within it, thereby moving beyond a recollection of what it was like in "his" world and moving into an analysis of the social structures that coincided and intersected to create the reality of a particular time and place (Kessler-Herris within Foner 231-232). Furthermore, in Joan W. Scott's work, she asserts that while we have been moving in the right direction by trying to incorporate gender into a study of class systems, the approaches have not served to provide a clear picture of gender, class, and history. To Scott, a more inclusive approach should recognize gender as a critical component of social relationships based upon perceived notions of sex differences and, moreover, gender is a primary way of organizing power relationships (Scott 1067).
Women are not the only group that has been excluded from historical thought and analysis. In fact, as note by Kwame Anthony Appiah in his series of essays including "In My Father's House," the real history of Africa has all too often been misconstrued and misunderstood. In fact, he notes that this is not necessarily surprising given that primarily the history of Africa was not even written in the tongue of the Africans
themselves but in the tongues of the imperialist nations whom dominated Africa during colonialism (Appiah 3). In his writing, Appiah demonstrates the need to not allow notions of ethnocentric theories and writings to define what "race" means to the African by using the specific examples of Africans, such as his father, whom experienced different notions of "race" depending upon whether or not they were enslaved in the America's or in Europe. As summarized by Richard Fraser, the class problem of slavery became complicated and confused by the race question. The slaves, besides being an exploited social class, became, in the perverted thinking of the dominant society, an inferior race as well (Frasier 14). Specifically, when some slaves returned home to Africa, he explains how one's place and time define what race means. To the enslaved African in America who was mistreated and abused by the slave owner in a land where color was used to create separate and distinct classes, race became a means of division with extremely negative connotations of abuse of power. However, to the African who perhaps worked in Europe as a servant and married a European, his notion of race will not encompass such a bitter and hostile conception of the term. Accordingly, two… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Inclusive Approach Reflecting a More Inclusive World" Assignment:
In your response be attentive of the following:
1 A clearly written coherent historiographical essay. Consult the required *****"A Pocket Guide To Writing In History*****" Chapter 4; On how to write a proper historiographical essay.
2- An introduction with a thesis statement is requred as well as a decent conculision.
3- The soures to be consulted for this paper must be limited to the required material for this class which includes Postcolonialism, Post-structuralism, Feilds and Appiah*****'s articles on race, MacClintock*****'s Imperial Leather; *****"Houses of History*****"; Kessler-Harris on Social History; and Marx*****'s Communist Manifesto; Scott*****'s on Gender.
4- At least 5 different sources must be used in making your argument.
5- All quotes must be footnoted and must follow the style in *****"A Pocket Guide To Writing In History.*****"
6- A full bibliography.
7- Essay will be marked for information, analysis, presentation and style.
* Please note I will fax you the sources that I would like for you to use. *****
How to Reference "Inclusive Approach Reflecting a More Inclusive World" Essay in a Bibliography
“Inclusive Approach Reflecting a More Inclusive World.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2010, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/inclusive-approach-reflecting/9725042. Accessed 6 Jul 2024.
Related Essays:
Employee Motivation in a Pcba Contract Manufacturing Dissertation
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Employee motivation in a PCBA contract manufacturing industry -- an example of Plexus
Today many organizations are going through change due to globalization and ever changing technology. Organizations have to… read more
Dissertation 64 pages (17554 words) Sources: 72 Topic: Management / Organizations
Future of Cuba Term Paper
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Cuba After Castro
Cuba is an island nation some 90 miles from Florida, and proximity alone gives this country great importance in the thinking of American leaders. More than this,… read more
Term Paper 80 pages (20759 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: World History
Managing in an Inclusive Environment Discrimination Term Paper
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Inclusive Environment Managing
In the modern business world, diversity has become not only increasingly important, but also an increasingly prominent issue. The reasons for this are several. The Western social… read more
Term Paper 4 pages (1296 words) Sources: 5 Style: Chicago Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources
Different Preferences in Learning Between American and French Learners in a Multinational Corporate Setting Dissertation
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Preferences in Learning between American and French Learners in a Multinational Corporate Setting
The way training is delivered in a corporate environment has a tremendous effect on results. This study… read more
Dissertation 65 pages (23082 words) Sources: 65 Style: APA Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning
Barack Obama as Representative of a Deracialized Research Proposal
![Paper Icon](https://www.a1-termpaper.com/images/term-paper-3.png)
Barack Obama as Representative of a Deracialized, Post-Civil Rights Paradigm
The history of the United States is saturated with struggle, of which the civil rights movement is perhaps the most… read more
Research Proposal 6 pages (2143 words) Sources: 6 Style: MLA Topic: African-American / Black Studies
Sat, Jul 6, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!