Essay on "Import of the Exclusionary Rule"

Essay 4 pages (1344 words) Sources: 4

[EXCERPT] . . . .

import of the Exclusionary Rule.

The exclusionary rule is often known as the 'fruit of the poisonous tree' doctrine. It prevents the government from benefiting from illegally-gathered evidence by excluding such evidence from the defendant's trial. "It applies to evidence gained from an unreasonable search or seizure in violation of the Fourth Amendment...to improperly elicited self-incriminatory statements gathered in violation of the Fifth Amendment...and to evidence gained in situations where the government violated defendants' Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel....The rule does not apply to civil cases, including deportation hearings" (Exclusionary rule, 2011, Cornell University).

The use of the exclusionary rule is extremely unpopular amongst the public, who are often frustrated when an obviously guilty criminal is set free, simply because the evidence supporting his conviction was obtained improperly by law enforcement personnel. However, without the exclusionary rule, there is no incentive for representatives of the law to enforce suspects' constitutional rights. "When agents of the executive branch (the police) disregard the terms of search warrants, or attempt to bypass the warrant-issuing process altogether, the judicial branch can and should respond by 'checking' such misbehavior. The most opportune time to check such unconstitutional behavior is when prosecutors attempt to introduce illegally-seized evidence in court" (Lynch 1998). Additionally, numerous exceptions to the exclusionary rule exist, such as the 'good faith' exemption (when a police officer believes, erroneously, that a warrant had been issued and conducts a search), and the 'plain view' exception, when an object is visible in plain view.

Q2. Define "reasonable suspicion" and give an example of same.

Reasonable suspicion, as defined by the law is a standard, "more than a hunch but considerably below preponderance of the evidence, which justifies an officer's investigative stop of an individual upon the articulable and particularized belief that criminal activity is afoot" (Probable cause, reasonable suspicion, and reasonableness 2006, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence). In other words, searches conducted with reasonable suspicion do not have to meet the standards of proof of convicting a defendant during a trial. They must be more than arbitrary searches based on gut feelings, as this could easily be open to abuse (and result in the targeting of members of minority groups). As defined by the Fourth Amendment reasonableness is that point at which the government's interest as "advanced by a particular search or seizure outweighs the loss of individual privacy or freedom of movement that attends the government's action," and the doctrine thus strives to balance the rights of the individual with the rights of the government to guard the public's safety (Probable cause, reasonable suspicion, and reasonableness 2006, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence).

One of the challenges of the reasonable suspicion standard is that it is not hard and fast, but rather based upon subjective, professional impressions -- a "fluid" concept, in the words of one justice (Probable cause, reasonable suspicion, and reasonableness, 2006, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence). Reasonable suspicion is most often used to justify less intrusive searches and seizures -- for example, a 'pat down' of a suspect when the officer has a reasonable suspicion that the suspect was armed and dangerous (Reasonable suspicion, 2011, Cornell University).

Q3. What facts should a judge take into consideration when setting the amount of bail in a particular case?

When setting bail, a judge typically considers whether the accused has a past criminal record. Whether the defendant poses a danger to the community is one of the primary considerations the judge will evaluate when setting bail or if the judge decides to grant bail at all (and in what form). The judge also evaluates the defendant's status as a flight risk, including the accused person's financial resources, connections abroad, and ties to the community. "In the event that the individual is deemed to be a high flight risk, the judge will set the bail at a higher amount. This is because when the person does not show up to court, the court will get the full amount of the bail money. As such, the higher bail… READ MORE

How to Reference "Import of the Exclusionary Rule" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Terry vs. Ohio Term Paper

Terry vs. Ohio:

police officer saw two doubtful men standing in a street corner in October of 1963. One of the persons was Terry. He had never noticed the men… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1773 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Criminal Justice Process Essay

Criminal Justice Process

Considerable attention has been devoted to law, both substantive and procedural on the justice process. The criminal justice system is a legal system. How does the law… read more

Essay 14 pages (5190 words) Sources: 7 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Pri and Carlos Salinas Term Paper

Salinas PRI

Carlos Salinas de Gortari and the turning Point for Mexico and the PRI

Mexico is a nation long embattled by poverty, political corruption and exploitation by powers foreign… read more

Term Paper 22 pages (6480 words) Sources: 11 Topic: Government / Politics

---

Illegal Immigrants in the U.S Term Paper

illegal immigrants in the U.S. And the possibility of legalizing their status. The article shows: how illegal immigration is currently being dealt with, the views of people on the issue… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2196 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA Topic: American History / United States

---

Kashmir Is a Territory Located Research Paper

Kashmir is a territory located in the upper northwestern section of Southern Asia. As a country, Kashmir has a long and bitter history as several countries continue to assert their… read more

Research Paper 2 pages (604 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Asian History / Asia

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>