A-Level Coursework on "Diversity in Organizations"

A-Level Coursework 4 pages (1160 words) Sources: 4

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Human Resources -- Diversity in Organizations

The business case for diversity and the perverse practice of matching employees to customers by Bendick, Egan and Lanier explores the vital differences between a shortsighted application of "diversity" and a thoughtful plan of "inclusion." While "diversity" is a current catchword for workplace equality, "inclusion" captures the true spirit of equality. Applying the authors' conclusions to the Tesco test case, the reader can see that a well-intentioned inclusion/diversity plan can be simultaneously admirable yet poorly drawn.

Business Case for Diversity Made by Bendick, Egan, and Lanier

The authors begin with a general discussion of workforce diversity, explaining the advancement of business objectives of productivity and profitability through diversity (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). Though they mention the three key benefits of access to a broader employment pool, the ability to relate to a diverse community of customers and greater productivity, the authors focus on diversity's supporting argument that employee diversity increases a business' ability to serve diverse customers (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). While this argument seems tenable, the authors assert that the application of that concept is often detrimental to minority employees, particularly when simplistically applied by line managers (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). According to the authors, the simplistic and shortsighted use of race only is documented in numerous industries (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010).

The article then goes on to document how "Neighborhood Stores," an alias for a Fortune 500 company, touts its diversity policies while engaging in an "all minorities are alike" system of assigning African-American store managers to lower income, lower education, even non-African-American neighborhoods to which these managers are poorly matched (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). Furthermore, the intention of increasing minority sales by matching employees with minority populations is not effective, as consumers apparently are not very concerned with the racial makeup of the retailers' managers (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). Furthermore, the limitation of diversity to a single trait ignores the fact that diversity is comprised of "a set of differences of individual traits" comprising different individuals (Panaccio & Waxin, 2010). In addition, through its shortsighted use of its diverse labor pool, the retailer is forfeiting possible advantages of diversity, including optimum use of its diverse talent and a beneficial blend of its diverse workforce (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). Finally, assigning minority workers to these "minority" stores significantly harms the careers of these managers by forcing them to work in smaller, underperforming, stressful environments in which they are paid less due to lower sales volumes and higher "inventory shrinkage" from theft, are so overworked that they cannot participate in career-advancement training as much as their counterparts, are notably less likely to be promoted to more powerful decision-making positions, and tend to quit their jobs more often than do their counterparts (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). All these detrimental practices constitute a "diversity revolving door" in which African-Americans were aggressively hired, yet used ineffectively and to their detriment.

The advertising industry reportedly also suffers from short-sighted hiring and use of African-Americans. Relying on the belief that "all blacks know blacks and nothing else," advertising agencies tend to hire African-Americans for niche advertising to the black community, while white people are employed for presumed wide-ranging abilities (Bendick, Egan, & Lanier, 2010). As a result, African-American employees are not used as effectively, are not paid as well, are not allowed to contribute to the wealth of diversity that could exist by more readily intermingling employees of different races,… READ MORE

How to Reference "Diversity in Organizations" A-Level Coursework in a Bibliography

Related A-Level Courseworks:

Perceived Diversity and Organizational Performance," University Research Paper

Perceived Diversity and Organizational Performance," University of Tennessee at Chattanooga researchers Allen, Dawson, Wheatley and White report on their study investigating the relationships between perceived diversity and perceived organizational performance… read more

Research Paper 4 pages (1366 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organizational Management -- Concepts and Terminology Essay

Organizational Management -- Concepts and Terminology

Organizational Culture and Behavior

Organizational culture refers to the collective attitudes and values that characterize business organizations. Organizational behavior refers to the manner in… read more

Essay 3 pages (727 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organizational Behavior - Terminology and Concepts Term Paper

Organizational Behavior - Terminology and Concepts

Organizational Behavior: The field of organizational behavior has assumed increasing significance in the light of a rapidly changing, global business environment. This is because… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (826 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Organization Business Strategy the Organization Will Choose Questionnaire

Organization Business Strategy

The organization will choose to develop rather than acquire talent. By developing talent, the organization will be able to save on costs incurred to acquire talent while… read more

Questionnaire 5 pages (1450 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Diversity in the Workplace Research Paper

Studies show that in various organizations there are individuals of ethnic groups with minority representation. Workers like to associate with members of their ethnicity since they can share their experiences… read more

Research Paper 11 pages (3384 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Management / Organizations

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>