Term Paper on "Kona Files"

Term Paper 10 pages (3344 words) Sources: 1 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

HP Pretexting Scandal

The Hewlett-Packard Ethical Dilemma

ETHICAL SCANDAL UPDATE

When looking into how a big corporation should properly conduct its business behind its own brick and mortar walls a good place to begin would be to examine what mistakes have been made by big corporate players. And no better place to begin than by studying and investigating the drama that continues to unfold at the Hewlett-Packard Company.

Indeed, the ongoing power and legal struggles associated with the Hewlett-Packard scandal in Silicon Valley has had ripple effects at Hewlett-Packard and around the corporate world - and some of those ripples are having a positive consequences, according to an article in CNET News.COM (www.news.com).The well-known and star-crossed 2005-2006 investigation into boardroom leaks has turned out to be a "wake-up call" that has "prompted a shakeup in the company's operations" (Broache 2007). The current ethics and compliance officer for Hewlett-Packard, Jonathan Hoak, said there is a "silver lining" to the PR nightmare that this scandal has become. Hoak was quoted by journalist Anne Broache as saying that a host of "tighter processes and controls" are now in place" at Hewlett-Packard (HP).

Moreover, HP has a policy now of more carefully screening outside investigative firms prior to hiring them to launch inquiries "into allegations of misconduct by employees or board members," according to Broache's article. One of the key changes that HP has adopted is that investigating professionals will not be allowed to use "pretexting" - which is the act of pretending to be someone else - posing as someone besides who you really are - in order to obtain phone records. In this case, there was indeed pretexting at HP, and the use of this unethical, illegal procedure allowed certain persons to obtain phone records of reporters and board members who were possible suspects in the leading of inside HP information to the media.

Subsequent to the disclosure that investigators were basically spying on executives and board members by snooping in their private mail ("pretexting"), the U.S. Congress has passed legislation - and its been signed by the president - that makes the use of pretexting a criminal act. It is called the Telephone Records and Privacy Protection Act of 2006; persons convicted of using fraudulent tactics to persuade phone companies to turn over confidential phone records can be sent to prison for up to ten years.

HP had, prior to the embarrassing scandal, achieved a reputation for "high ethical standards," according to HP's Chief Privacy Officer Scott Taylor. This pretexting strategy was "not consistent with decades of ethical behavior," Taylor told CNET's reporter, Broache. And so now that the word is out about HP and pretexting, will that special new scrutiny prevent future leaks, investigations, and scandals? "In the end, you can't always prevent someone from being a cowboy," said Hoak. "You're always going to have people who are trying to cut corners," he continued, and hence, vigilance is the watchword at HP.

Meanwhile, in a March 1, 2007 article (Fried 2007) in the online technology news service CNET News.com, evidence of just how dirty this morass of ethical missteps has become continues to unfold. A former HP employee, Karl Kamb, who was sued by HP in 2005 for allegedly stealing trade secrets, claims HP improperly obtained his phone records through pretexting. Moreover, Kamb alleges that he had been instructed by HP to spy on DELL, a computer company rival to HP. The company continues to deny that it pretexted Kamb, but admits that it did indeed attempt to obtain "the phone records of more than a dozen people including current and former directors, employees and journalists, including three CNET News.com reporters," Fried reported. So what is now coming out of the scandal, more than just charges and counter-charges, are the slow but steady revelations that will shape how HP and other corporations conduct their ethical business in the future.

Pretexting has by now emerged as an infamous concept; so much so that now that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has gotten into the act. The FTC has asked a U.S. district court (for the Middle District of Florida) to "permanently halt operations that engage in telephone record pretexting" (Sandoval 2007). The principals named in the FTC complaint, who are implicated in the HP scandal, are data brokers Matthew DePante and Bryan Wagner; the two were allegedly part of HP's attempt to find out who leaked key information

THE NEW YORKER ARTICLE: HP BEHAVIORS DURING THIS MESS:

The true background of this confusing and twisted tale of corporate ethical lapses is becoming a must-read for students in Ethics classes around the country. Indeed, when David Packard and Bill Hewlett launched HP in a Palo Alto garage in 1957, little did either of those men realize what a giant and powerful technology corporation HP would turn out to be - with revenues in excess of $90 billion annually.

Nor did they, or could they, have known that corporate leaks from power-hungry insiders would lead to an embarrassing and very public scandal in 2005 and 2006. Certainly they couldn't know that the corruption inside HP would be so serious and have such enormous implications for the company (and the technology world) that it would require congressional hearings to delve into its mysterious and evil plots and subplots, along with the willing and innocent participants.

An article in the New Yorker magazine recently went into great detail as to all the actions leading up to, contributing to, and following the scandal. "A serious of damaging leaks" let to stories published about the then-CEO, and indeed, those leaks put an end to the "tumultuous stewardship" of Carly Fiorina, formerly the CEO of HP, according to journalist James B. Stewart. That incident was the first in an ongoing series of deviant acts of behavior that go against all company policies; to wit, employees all sign a pledge when they are hired to not share with the outside world any of what is said or done inside the walls of the corporate structure.

To begin with, Fiorina, who was at the time said to be the most visible CEO of an American corporation - partly because she was a woman in what had been primarily a man's world - was fired after "unauthorized disclosures to the press" raised serious questions about the company. Soon thereafter former board member Mark Hurd was appointed CEO and Patricia Dunn was appointed as chairman of the HP board. Both, it was hoped, would right the ship and stave off any future embarrassment.

But that was not to be, Steward writes. An email to Dunn's computer in January 2006 brought the emerging reality of bad news - it was an article from CNET titled "HP Outlines Long-Term Strategy." The article was ripe with insider information that someone from HP had obviously leaked to the media. It was about deviance, too, because someone had given over to CNET information that was shared in-house at a retreat HP had held. In the leaked corporate material, readers of CNET now knew what HP's strategies were about Intel chips, future sales campaigns, "and possible acquisitions," Steward continues. "Clearly, someone at the retreat had leaked proprietary information," and the new board chair, Dunn, "was determined to get to the bottom of the problem."

As a start to her investigation, Dunn emailed the CNET article to the board of directors, including Tom Perkins, the 74-year-old venture capitalist who was the most powerful individual on the board. Perkins' resume as a venture capitalist is very impressive; he funded technology start-ups like Sun Microsystems, AOL, and Amazon.com, so he obviously is a heavy-hitter in this sector of the technology industry. He is fabulously wealthy, and arrogant, to go along with the enormous power he exerts whenever he needs to. He owns mansions and expensive / rare sports cars, and writes novels that include trashy sexually graphic scenes, a strange way for a power broker in a corporation the size of HP to express himself on a public level.

While Perkins didn't see the article in the same negative light as Dunn (who believed it was very harmful to the company), the need was there to try to find out who was leaking this information.

At this point in his article Stewart of the New Yorker delves into some background, to help the reader gain a grasp into the power brokers, the corporate structure and the heavyweights within that structure, and the special relationships that existed at HP at the time of these extraordinary events. Stewart described Fiorina as having been a rising star in the corporate world, and when she was hired at CEO, her "good looks and her stylish attire drew attention," along with her attendance at high-visibility events such as the opening of "Mission: Space" at Disney World and the Academy Awards show. But after she talked her corporate colleagues into purchasing Compaq computers in 2001 - which wasn't an easy sell in the company, and caused friction… READ MORE

How to Reference "Kona Files" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Create a Network That Houses Storage File Services Case Study

network that houses the storage file server(s) keeping all files related to contract transactions between all divisions and their clients. Your task is to design only this segment of the… read more

Case Study 4 pages (1247 words) Sources: 1 Style: APA Topic: Computers / IT / Internet

---

Illegal File Sharing Essay

Illegal File-Sharing

It seems so easy -- like a victimless crime, hence its commonality. However, if this is the case, then why have so many musical artists known for their… read more

Essay 4 pages (1387 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Copyright / Trademark / Patent

---

File Sharing Essay

Sharing

The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has long contended that Internet file-sharing of music has suppressed its revenues. The RIAA claims that sales of compact discs have declined… read more

Essay 4 pages (1390 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Computers / IT / Internet

---

Illegal File Sharing Essay

Sharing

The issue of illegal file sharing is complicated. Many different issues come into play. One that has not received a lot of attention is with regards to the prosecution… read more

Essay 4 pages (1381 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Copyright / Trademark / Patent

---

Business of Law Term Paper

AT&T Files Patent Lawsuit Against Vonage

Vonage Holding Corp. suffered another blow since at&T Inc. filed suit, which claimed they were violating a single patent that lets users access an… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (666 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Copyright / Trademark / Patent

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>