Term Paper on "Hospice and Under Utilization by Minorities"

Term Paper 10 pages (3079 words) Sources: 12

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Hospice and Underutilization by Minorities

Improving end of life care is an important healthcare concern and improving access to hospice services and utilization is a national prerogative. Socioeconomic, cultural and systemic factors affect hospice enrollment leading to a distinct under utilization of hospice services by the minority communities. Educational interventions to create awareness and remove misconceptions, improved insurance coverage, and effective cultural integration of migrant population are key social factors. Delivering culturally sensitive healthcare is a key to addressing the disparity in hospice utilization. Increasing cultural diversity among the Hospice staff could be a first step in the right direction.

Introduction

Hospice care involves care provision to comfort terminally ill patients in their day-to-day routine with services including - pain management, psychosocial and spiritual counseling, diet management, bereavement counseling for family, etc. Pioneered by Dr. Dame Cicely Saunders in 1967, the Hospice setting focuses on care rather than cure and strives to provide a natural and peaceful end of life care for the dying people. Though popularized in the U.S. with inclusion in the national Medicare program, hospice services remain largely underused. This can be verified by the fact that only 20% -- 25% of the national population of terminally ill people utilize hospice care. [Albert J. Finestone, (2008)] Within the U.S. population, there exists a distinct disparity in the utilization of hospice programs with the minority population being underserved in hospice settings. Studies focusing on the issue have put forth several causes for this racial disparity in hospice utilization including social, economic, cultural factors that act as barriers to enrollment in hospice care. The following literature review serves to highlight these important issues and the inferences drawn could be useful in formulating interventions to reverse the trend.

Literature Review

Jennifer et.al (2007) focused on whether hospice care utilization was influenced by the composition of a particular census area. Data for the study was obtained from the SEER database for people who were diagnosed with terminal cancer (breast, lung, prostate or colorectal cancer) between 1990 and 1999. A total of The results from the study revealed that 46% of the cancer patients utilized hospice services during the last year of their lives. It was also found that the percentage of hospice use in regions with high African-American and Hispanic population was less (35%) compared to the hospice utilization in low minority regions (47%). For instance, almost 43.2% of African-Americans and 47.8% of Hispanics utilized hospice services in low minority regions. Even in regions where there is high African-American and Hispanic population, there was no significant difference in hospice usage among the white population (44.1%). These figures suggest a clear disparity in utilization of hospice services in high minority regions. The study concluded that improving medical infrastructure allocation and removing the misperceptions about hospice care are central to improving the utilization of hospice care among the minority populations. [Jennifer et.al (2007)]

Givens et.al (2010) is one recent research that studied the racial and ethnic differences among heart patients seeking hospice care. The researchers used the Medicare denominator file for 2001 to gather data pertaining to Medicare beneficiaries for the period. The national death index was also consulted to confirm the date of death. A total of 603, 128 beneficiaries fitted the criteria from which the researchers separated 98,258 cases that were diagnosed with heart failure. The study authors also gathered information related to severity of heart failure from the Medicare inpatient files for 2000 which stored data pertaining to the number of emergency visits and the time period of stay in the ICU. Couple of geographic variables for urbanicity and hospice intensity was also included. Among the study population of 98,258, 88.3% were white, 8.5% black, 1.4% Hispanic and 1.8% others. Of the entire study population, only 3.9% used hospice services for the year 2001. Statistical analysis of the data further revealed that after adjusting for DCG scores (that reflect patient morbidity), urbanicity and hospice intensity factors, the hospice utilization rate was lowest for the Hispanics (adjusted odds ratio [OR], 0.49 [95% confidence interval {CI}, 0.37 -- 0.66) compared with Whites. The utilization rate for African-Americans (adjusted OR, 0.59 [95% CI, 0.47 -- 0.73]) and other non-white groups adjusted OR, 0.64 [95% CI, 0.52 -- 0.80]) also remained significantly lower.

In other words, Hispanics were 51% less likely and African-Americans were 41% less likely to use hospice services compared to whites. This study clearly attests to the findings from previous studies claiming under utilization of hospice services by the minority population. Even after adjusting for the two geographic variables in the study, the underutilization of hospice services among the minority population was starkly evident. This clearly indicates the influence of other factors including racial and cultural differences in understanding and accepting palliative care. The study authors concluded that more research into the impact of cultural factors on the utilization of hospice care is urgently required to implement effective interventions to promote hospice use among the minority population. [Givens et.al (2010)]

Another recent national level study by Amber et.al (2009) explored the differences in end of life care preferences among people from different races. This study also gathered extensive information including education level, financial situation, social networks, health status, perceptions about mechanical ventilation, etc. The study population was the national sample of Medicare beneficiaries (aged 65 and above) obtained from the Medicare denominator file for 2003. This study was conducted by a multi-modal approach involving both telephonic and mail-based survey. Only 2,847 subjects of the eligible 4,610 beneficiaries responded to the survey. Of these, non-Hispanic Whites constituted 85%, 4.6% Hispanics, 6.3% blacks and 4.2% belonged to other race. Analysis of the gathered information revealed some distinct facts. More African-Americans (18%) and Hispanics (15%) tended to prefer dying in the hospital compared to Whites (8%). There is also a clear preference between the African-American (28%) and the Hispanic patients (21.2%) in their choice for life prolonging interventions even at the risk of increased side effects compared to the white patients (15%). Also more African-American (24%) and Hispanic patients (22%) preferred the use of Mechanical Ventilation for prolonging life by a week or a month compared to the white patients (13%).

Statistical analysis clearly indicate that black race was an interdependent predictor for greater use of life saving and potentially hurtful interventions [1.9 (1.4 -- 2.6)], MV for 1 week [2.3 (1.6 -- 3.3)] while the Hispanic race was an independent predictor of preference for dying at the hospital [2.2 (1.3 -- 4.0)] and reduced preference [0.5 (0.3 -- 0.7)] for accepting the use of palliative drugs that could shorten life. Overall the study showed that African-Americans (p<.0001) and Hispanics (p=0.009) expressed greater belief in the effectiveness of endstage interventions and were more positive about prolongation of life. The study authors conclude that there is an increased preference among the minority population to persist with aggressive interventions in lieu of hospice care. Prevailing mistrust in the healthcare system, and Medicare stipulations that require foregoing curative interventions maybe misperceived by the minority population. Also culturally minorities have different attitudes towards end of life care. [Amber et.al (2009)]

Lilian (2008) was a systematic review of studies relating to the disparities in hospice care. The author used medical databases (Cochran, Pubmed, Medline, Psych info, etc.,) for articles published from 1980 to 2006 using appropriate keywords such as 'Hospice Use', 'Hospice utilization', 'racial disparities', 'palliative care' etc. A total of 13 articles published between 1998 and 2006 were finally selected after pruning the articles based on the study criteria. Twelve of these thirteen studies reported disparities in hospice service utilization among the minorities compared to Whites. Among these studies, Ngo-Metzger et.al (2003) is particularly significant as it highlights differences in hospice utilization between Asian-Americans born in America and those who migrated. This study focused on Medicare beneficiaries who died between 1988 and 1998 due to colorectal, breast, lung, prostate, liver and gastric cancers and studied their hospice utilization trend. From a total sample of 184,081 subjects, 5% were Asian-Americans and among this group 45% were foreign born. This retrospective study revealed that hospice utilization was the lowest among foreign-born Asian-Americans with Odds ration foreign-born [OR _0.90; 95% CI: 0.86 -- 0.94]). The study also showed that U.S. born Asian-Americans were also less likely than non-Hispanic whites to use hospice services [odds ratio {OR} _ 0.67; 95% confidence interval {CI}: 0.62 -- 0.73];

Another older but significant study included in the Lilian (2008) review is the research by Cox (1998). This study is important as it focuses on hospice utilization by Persons with AIDS. (PWA). This study analyzed 957 hospice services in the U.S. And Puerto Rico. It was found that PWAs were more likely to be African-Americans (p _ 0.0001) or Hispanics (p _ 0.05). Analysis of the national data also indicated that though African-Americans represented 31% of the AIDS cases in the country they were grossly underrepresented in the hospice services with only 24% of PWAs placed under Hospice care. Similarly, Hispanics who make up 17% of… READ MORE

How to Reference "Hospice and Under Utilization by Minorities" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Hospice Utilization Open the Powerpoint Essay

From the perspective of career nurses enrolled in an advanced practice degree program, patient and family-associated barriers are on their minds the most.

Slide 18

The 24 career nurses that… read more

Essay 7 pages (2034 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Nursing / Doctor / Physician

---

Hospice View of Death and Dying as a Natural Event Term Paper

Hospice View of Death and Dying as a Natural Event

Some diseases prove to be too strong for medical science to eradicate within the body.

The popular treatment for terminally… read more

Term Paper 11 pages (3442 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

Hospice Care Term Paper

Hospice

Death and dying are concerns that every human being must deal with at some point in their lives (Jennings et al., 2003). Hospice care is a practice that assists… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3035 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Hospice Care Research Paper

Hospice care refers to the end-of-life care that is provided by both health care professionals and volunteers. It includes medical, spiritual and psychological support whose goal is for the patient… read more

Research Paper 8 pages (2699 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Hospice Grief Term Paper

Hospice Care

Providing quality healthcare is one of the top healthcare priorities and over the last many years, healthcare has evolved considerably not only in the treatment of illness and… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1089 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>