Term Paper on "Homeland Security the 21st Century"

Term Paper 7 pages (2503 words) Sources: 7

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Homeland Security

The 21st century has been a challenging time for the American society so far. The 9/11 events have proven that there are no more conventional threats and pointed out the vulnerabilities inside the U.S. security system. The terrorist phenomenon makes the daily headlines through violent and indiscriminate attacks, a constant presence which determines the convergence of all forces and initiatives towards identifying its source and preventing any further manifestations on American soil. The National Security Strategy is an obvious proof of the attention given to this new security issue.

However important this may be, the turn of the century also saw one of the most devastating natural disasters America has ever experienced, hurricane Katrina. On an estimative scale, "many reporters and critics have compared Katrina to September 11." (Brown, 2005) Nonetheless, this natural catastrophe did not entangle such national unity, but rather the human tragedies were overshadowed by the apparent lack of competence from the part of the authorities who, according to the general opinion, could have prevented the loss of human lives and the destruction of so many homes. Therefore, although the size of the natural disaster is still hard to grasp, more important for the future prevention of such tragedies is the analysis of what really went array and what needs to be done in order to prevent a replay.

There has been numerous criticism on the way in which the entire crisis was conducted. When the 911 tragedy occurred, a new structure that would encourage a better cooperation between the levels of government was set in place in order to allow the flow of financial, medical, and human resources to be more rapid and more efficient in states of emergency. In this respect, the signing of the Homeland Security Act in 2002 was cheered and hopes ran high because, at least in theory, a more efficient and flexible structure would make rescue operations deliver on their promises. Still, the events in the Katrina situation proved exactly the opposite. The weak response from the authorities, along with the several mix-ups and controversies are the obvious evidence that the U.S. lacks a proper agency that would be able to coordinate the aid relief in case of natural, biological or even terrorist catastrophe. There are several explanations given in this respect.

First, the matter of authority raised a serious problem that slowed down the relief efforts and the rapid distribution of assistance and resources. In most cases, the decentralized system of decision making leaves up to the local authorities to act in the eventuality of a natural crisis. As Arnold Howitt notes, "This "bottom-up" system of emergency management has a long history and continues to make sense in most circumstances. Because local governments are proximate to disaster sites and have at least some emergency capacity, they can respond quickly to initial alerts. They have detailed knowledge of local conditions, and in many cases have agreements for mutual aid to secure additional help rapidly from nearby jurisdictions." (Howitt & Leonard, 2005) However, in this case, it took a log time before the federal authorities decided to intervene, taking into account the fact that in the beginning Katrina was ranked a level one storm, and therefore did not need any special attention or any different measures to be take in preparing the population. According to weather reports, on August 25th, Katrina became for the first time a level one hurricane, "making serious wind damage unlikely. However, flooding was a major concern from the slow-moving storm." (CNN, 2005) in response, local authorities acted as in any hurricane situation, and according to news reports, "people were being told to take cover in their homes. Residents of low-lying areas, barrier islands and those living in mobile homes were urged to evacuate, though evacuations remained mostly voluntarily." (CNN, 2005) Still, by the time the situation worsen, the authorities responsible failed to evacuate the citizens and subsequently, when the hurricane was ultimately downgraded to a tropical storm level, the population in New Orleans was caught unprepared and the number of victims rose. Thus, while local authorities failed to take the precautionary action, the federal ones did not see the threat such a storm would pose, despite the fact that "the National weather Service issued a special statement in advance of Katrina's arrival outlining the damage that will likely be caused. If Hurricane Katrina makes landfall as strong as category 4 or category 5 storm, most of the area will be uninhabitable for weeks, perhaps longer. At least one-half of well-constructed homes will have roof and wall failure. All gabled roofs will fail, leaving those homes severely damaged or destroyed." (Moyen, 2005) Overall, there was a shortage of instructions and reactions from both sides, which eventually led to the escalation of the number of victims.

Secondly, even when finally decisions were being taken, they were inadequate for the respective situation. Katrina was a special case with a particular impact, unlike any other ordinary annual storm, largely because of the geographical positioning of the city of New Orleans, the hardest hit by the storm. Many even pass the blame of the failed rescue attempts on the natural conditions of the city. Thus, according to the proponents of this theory, "conditions - on the ground along the Gulf Coast and in the New Orleans area when the storm hit - contributed significantly to the catastrophe. The partially successful but (inevitably) incomplete evacuation in advance of the storm - who had and who had not self-evacuated or been evacuated - coupled with the severity of the storm itself and its after-effects (principally, the overtopping of the St. Bernard's Parish levees and the breaching of the New Orleans levees) created a nightmare scenario." (Howitt & Leonard, 2005) in this context, the authorities that managed to come to the rescue of those who found refuge in the Super Bowl Stadium were unable to set aside personal and professional ambitions and issues of authority and help those in need. William Anderson gives an eloquent description for pointing out the exact situation that was on the ground. Thus, "immediately after the hurricane had stopped in New Orleans, for example, a Wal-Mart had brought a truckload of bottled water; FEMA officials turned the truck away, declaring that it was 'not needed'," all this despite the fact that people were left without electricity and other basic needs such as drinking water. (Anderson, 2005)

Thirdly, in dealing with the emerging crisis, those in charge failed to point out the exact issues at hand, and to consider a proper response given the special details that made this case particular. As stated before, indeed, Katrina was more than an average storm because of the place it hit, and due to the complexity of the response needed. However, the authorities were unable to see the priorities and the need to rescue those stranded on rooftops or those without possibility to move. In such conditions, the inefficient emergency management became obvious, especially when aid did not arrive until days later in New Orleans, although promises were being made constantly. Therefore, the despair of those isolated grew in intensity as the emergency units were struggling to coordinate their efforts. For instance, people were seen on their rooftops trying to avoid being taken by the high waters. Nonetheless, the National Guard took time before intervening to their rescue. Still, this was done rather successfully, as Lt. Col. Robert Horton of the Alabama Guard "We're making history again, never before have we supported so many state and federal missions." (Sappenfield, 2005)

Although the operations managed to save numerous lives, another question arises in connection to the distribution and use of forces in such cases. Therefore, the National Guard example is eloquent to point out the fact that indeed, there are little resources available for the authorities to intervene in cases of catastrophe. The reasons for this shortage are various. On the one hand, there are divergent opinions over the need to have permanent stand by forces, such as intervention units specially trained for such occasions, as pointed out, "it is a far more complex matter to address the need for reserve or "surge" capacity in large scale disasters, in which many kinds of emergency response functions, equipment, and personnel must be mobilized." (Howitt & Leonard, 2005) However, on the one hand, it is considered a "waste" of funds, while those supporting the idea consider it part of a preparedness strategy, which would even raise the awareness among the population about these sorts of possible disasters. The situation on the ground though clearly underlined the need for sufficient resources, both financial and human ones, to be at the disposal of the authorities. For instance, the evacuation actions undergone in order to save those unable to move or trapped in remote corners of New Orleans proved the fact that there were not enough transportation available and therefore the operations took longer, probably costing someone's life.

The soldiers called for duty in the Katrina case represent… READ MORE

How to Reference "Homeland Security the 21st Century" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Birth and Evolution of Homeland Security Research Paper

Homeland Security

The Birth and Evolution of Homeland Security

Homeland Security was brought to the forefront of political discourse in the wake of 9/11. Beginning as the Office of Homeland… read more

Research Paper 3 pages (943 words) Sources: 2 Style: Turabian Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

Policing: The 21st Century Term Paper

Policing:

The 21st Century has put policing in a different situation in which the causes of crime and criminal behavior usually lie outside the immediate community. As a result of… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (961 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Forensic Science in 21st Century Thesis

Criminal Justice - Forensics

TWENTIETH-CENTURY FORENSICS in CRIMINAL JUSTICE

Forensic Science in Policing and Criminal Investigations:

In terms of its full potential, 21st-century forensic science is still in its infancy;… read more

Thesis 3 pages (846 words) Sources: 2 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Security Aviation Security Pre and Post 911 Term Paper

Security

Aviation Security Pre and Post 911

The security in most airports did not used to be much of a problem for anyone. For many years before the events of… read more

Term Paper 30 pages (10540 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

Immigration in America: 19th Century to Present Essay

Immigration in America: 19th Century to Present

The millions of immigrants who have come to America over the past four hundred years have made America what it is today. The… read more

Essay 6 pages (2190 words) Sources: 3 Topic: American History / United States

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>