Essay on "Thinking as a Hobby and on Various Kinds of Thinking Compare and Contrast"

Essay 3 pages (1114 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

hobby and on various Kinds of thinking Compare / Contrast

Differing thoughts on the subject of thinking -- William Golding vs. Robinson

James Harvey Robinson's essay entitled "On various kinds of thinking" begins with the author expressing his mistrust of the history of abstract philosophy: "The truest and most profound observations on Intelligence have in the past been made by the poets and, in recent times, by story-writers," he writes, not by philosophers. However, he does not introduce personal experience or anecdotes into his argument that thinking cannot be detached from human experience. His main problem with philosophy is not that it is abstract, but that it is located in bad science and bad psychology. Philosophy has emphasized a mind/body distinction that does not acknowledge "bodily processes, animal impulses, savage traditions, infantile impressions, conventional reactions, and traditional knowledge," and subconscious as well as conscious thought. Robinson's essay seems heavily influenced by Freud's theory of the subconscious, and the degree to which personal experience influences thinking: "All thought that is not more or less laboriously controlled and directed will inevitably circle about the beloved Ego."

In contrast, to Robinson's abstractions William Golding opens up his essay "Thinking as a hobby" with a humorous example of his first encounter of a representation of Venus of Milo, which he first thought was a woman in a towel. While Robinson makes a general comment like: "the first thing that we notice is that our thought moves with such incredible rapidity that it is almost impossible to arrest any specimen of it long enough to have a look at it…On inspection we shall find that even if we are not downright ashamed of a great part of our spontaneous thinking it is far too intimate, personal, ignoble or trivial to permit us to reveal more than a small part of it," Golding offers a specific example this quality of thinking. For example, he cites the thought processes evidenced by his supposedly thoughtful teacher: "Mr. Houghton was given to high-minded monologues about the good life, sexless and full of duty. Yet in the middle of one of these monologues, if a girl passed the window, tapping along on her neat little feet, he would interrupt his discourse, his neck would turn of itself and he would watch her out of sight. In this instance, he seemed to me ruled not by thought but by an invisible and irresistible spring in his nape." The overcoming of rational thought with the emotional, primal, and unconscious emotions described by Robinson is literally depicted in this scene of Golding's -- no matter how strong Mr. Houghton's articulated philosophy, his neck betrays him and he turns to look at a pretty girl.

Golding and Robinson thus both emphasize the power of the unconscious mind, and stress that the mind is not separate from the impulses of the body. Yet Golding is less interested on taking on a philosophical debate of the mind/body question, and tends to deploy a more colloquial definition of thinking, and uses more haphazard, humorous, and self-depreciating examples to make his argument. When Golding deals with questions such as: "What were you thinking?" which people cried quite frequently when he was growing up, he fluidly switches from one definition of the word 'thinking' in English to another, without concern for scrupulously using the… READ MORE

How to Reference "Thinking as a Hobby and on Various Kinds of Thinking Compare and Contrast" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Thomas Jefferson and His Views of Education Term Paper

Thomas Jefferson: A Pioneer in Education

JEFFERSON and EDUCATION

Thomas Jefferson's life experiences shaped his views on education. His attitudes towards education -- radical as they were for his time… read more

Term Paper 18 pages (5416 words) Sources: 15 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Military Employee Stress Thesis

Military Employee Stress

The objective of this work is to compare, contrast and synthesize and evaluate the principles of societal development including an evaluation of the workplace and resulting family… read more

Thesis 66 pages (18029 words) Sources: 56 Style: APA Topic: Military / Army / Navy / Marines

---

Art and Mathematics Are Related Research Paper

art and mathematics are related and that this relation could be used to the advantage of educators to overcome student anxiety regarding mathematics and, in particular, difficult geometry concepts

Outline… read more

Research Paper 10 pages (2688 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Mathematics / Statistics

---

Improve Reading Skills Case Study

Improving Reading Skills

Reading and ESL Students

Multiculturalism in the Curriculum

Ahmad

Writing Assessment

Fry Graph

Instructional Implications

Lesson Plans

Scholarly Justifications

Reading and ESL Students - the way humans… read more

Case Study 30 pages (8772 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Strokes and There Causes Research Paper

Strokes and Their Causes

Stroke is defined as the abrupt death of cells inside a definite part of the brain owing to insufficient blood flow. It is also known as… read more

Research Paper 5 pages (2130 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Disease / Virus / Disorder / Injury

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>