Term Paper on "Health Policy and Bioethics"

Term Paper 4 pages (1481 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Health Policy and Bioethics

The United States was in an uproar in the late twentieth century over whether medical care was or ought to be a business. The prestigious New England Journal of Medicine made the Health Policy Advisory Center's earlier warning about the rise of a "medical-industrial complex" a mainstream concern (Relman, 1980). Political scientist James Morone advised that medicine was suddenly and rapidly becoming a "corporate enterprise organized and run along business principles." (Morone, 1997). Group practices, promoted for decades as progressive reform, took on a new business identity as health maintenance organizations (HMOs) in what sociologist Donald Light called perhaps the "greatest rhetorical reversal in the history of American health care" (Light, pp. 46-63). HMO and other managed care supporters declared that the cottage industry of medicine was finally having its industrial revolution (Eisenberg & Kabcenell, 1988).

Introduction

Identifying cottage industry as the problem mandated an industrial and corporate development as the solution. So-called market reformers sought to transform medicine into a "modern corporate system, featuring the sophisticated financial and managerial controls associated with big business" (Battistella, 1985). They advised that such a system offered economies of scale and scope through mass production manufacturing techniques. Critics pugnaciously described the same developments as an "invasion of commerce into medical care" and an epic clash of cultures between commercial and professional traditions. Medical care did reproduce industrial, corporate, and commercial models of organization, but it was not so sudden. Ray Lyman Wilbur defined medicine as an industry when he was chairman of the 1927-1932 Committee on the Costs of Medical Care (CCMC). The committee defined its purview in terms of reforming the economic organization of medicine, defining it as the methods of producing and financing medical services.

In rejecting the hypothesis that doctors at that time looked to business for their organizational strategies, historian Donald Madison held that the immediate commercial interests of medical practitioners steered them on an opposing course, leading them toward individualistic rather than bureaucratic organization. This patently successful continuation of individual entrepreneurial practice led historian Thomas Goebel to reject the pertinence of organizational synthesis to medicine, even as he acknowledged that the rise of specialties and bureaucratically managed, large-scale institutions reconfigured American medicine. Conventional medical as well as historical explanations of medical care organization and its therapeutics have assumed that both are driven by scientific and/or technologic development. Two spectacularly successful approaches to fighting disease, immunization and antibiotics, supported a positive view of scientific and technologic progress in medicine. Investigators increasingly questioned, however, the extent to which medicine was a structure shaped by an inexorable and laudable accretion of scientific insight, as historian Charles Rosenberg put it. Much that twentieth-century medicine had to offer was not nearly so effective as immunization and antibiotics. Experts acknowledged the inadequacy of evidence to support existing intervention levels and that the evidence that was available sometimes contradicted practice patterns. Joseph Califano, former secretary of the U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, answered "certainly" to his 1988 query, "Is it possible that in this era of high-tech medicine we just don't know with any precision whether many procedures truly affect the medical outcome?" (Califano, 1988).

My first thesis proposes that many medical care developments and reforms throughout the twentieth century applied contemporary elements of economic organization to the structure of medical care. In examining this thesis, I use health administration scholar Avedis Donabedian's framework defining structure in terms of characteristics of medical providers, their tools, and their organizational settings. The thesis does not merely draw an analogy between business and medicine; it examines how medical occupations and institutions incorporated elements of business organization into the foundation of medical care. This process created institution-based specialties, academic medical centers, and (somewhat later) multi-hospital regional systems. Medicine did not exactly "escape" the corporation prior to 1965, as Paul Starr maintained in The Social Transformation of American Medicine, using the prevalence of organized groups as his measure medicine became the corporation. This first thesis stands alone: medicine did apply business models; the second thesis builds on the first.

My second thesis links the economic organization of medicine to its clinical content, practice, or what Donabedian called "process," the sets of diagnostic, treatment, and interpersonal interventions that providers use on patients. The business elements built into medical care had a powerful impact on shaping its clinical interventions. Without denying that clinical process development also entailed many other factors, this thesis means that the economic… READ MORE

How to Reference "Health Policy and Bioethics" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Policy Analysis on the Oregon Death With Dignity Act Term Paper

Policy Analysis of Oregon's Death With Dignity Act

David Gil's writings have helped the public understand the true scope of the new Oregon Assisted Suicide law, and as a result,… read more

Term Paper 25 pages (8143 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Health Exploring the Tuskegee Syphilis Study Term Paper

Health

Exploring the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

The Tuskegee Study was intended to examine the long-term side effects of untreated syphilis. It tracked a group of 600 poor African-American men in… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2669 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Resuscitate (DNR) as a National Healthcare Mandate Thesis

Resuscitate (DNR) as a National Healthcare Mandate

Background on DNR

Do not resuscitate (DNR) is a choice that has long been available to patients and families who are faced with… read more

Thesis 8 pages (2548 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

End-Of-Life Issues: Futile Care Research Paper

Futile Care Policy for Hospitals

Futile care is that medical care given at such a time when the administration of such care has very little degree of good outcome; resuscitation… read more

Research Paper 3 pages (1108 words) Sources: 2 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues Compare Essay

Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues

Compare and contrast the different types of moral reasoning (moral absolutism, moral objectivism, etc.). What are the benefits and burdens of each? Which is closest… read more

Essay 8 pages (2355 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>