Term Paper on "Generalized Anxiety Disorder"

Term Paper 10 pages (2885 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Generalized Anxiety Disorder

Ever since Mick Jagger wrote about "mother's little helpers,' much of the population has viewed medications as the instant cure for such modern-day maladies as Generalized Anxiety Disorder. It is undeniable that the prevalence of GAD is expanding as the world becomes more complex, global, difficult to comprehend and, one might argue, more mechanistic and less humanistic. Recent studies have shown that, despite the current overwhelming allegiance to medication, cognitive-behavioral interventions are more effective for GAD. Several major investigations and a recent small empirical study confirm that cognitive-behavioral counseling works better and more rapidly than medication intervention without attendant therapy.

Introduction

The National Institutes of Mental Health (NIMH) shows that anxiety disorders are the most common mental illnesses in the United States, with more than 23 million people affected each year (Public Health Reports 2005). Within this population, several varieties of anxiety disorder appear, including panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, phobias, post-traumatic stress disorder and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD). NIMH defines as "chronic or exaggerated worry and tension; almost always anticipating disaster even though nothing seems to provoke it. Worrying is often accompanied by physical symptoms, like trembling, muscle tension, headache and nausea" (Public Health Reports 2005). This is an adequate definition for the current study.

NIMH also notes that there are several forms of effective treatment for anxiety disorder, among them medication, specific forms of psychotherapy known as behavioral therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy, or a combination of medication and the non-medication therapies.

Medication, for the purposes of this study, will be taken to mean "any psychotropic drug used to treat anxiety or any drug developed for other purposes that has been found useful in treating some psychiatric conditions, such as the antihistamines that have been found useful for some generalized anxiety disorder patients.

Hypothesis: In Maverick County, generalized anxiety disorder patients function better without medication than with it, if medication is the only or main aspect of treatment.

In order to prove the validity of this assertion, two groups were studied. One group was provided with appropriate medication and minimal therapy of any sort; the second group was provided with no medication but did participate in a well-tested cognitive-behavioral regiment based on the Rational-Emotive therapy of Dr. Albert Ellis, as found in his book (which they were asked to read), a Guide to Rational Living.

Procedure/Method

To ascertain the relative value of medication combined with traditional group therapy vs. cognitive therapies alone in treating generalized anxiety disorder, two groups of young to middle-aged groups were initiated. Each group began with four members, drawn from clients of an Employee Assistance Program; all had developed generalized anxiety disorder after being transferred or otherwise coming under the supervision of various types of ineffective, antisocial, overbearing or micromanaging bosses. All of the participants were looking for other employment, but all had to cope with the situation as is in the meantime; with a soft job market, none expected to be able to wait it out without help and also, many had expressed a need to overcome the anxiety to make the job search possible.

Group a was the group that had agreed to medication. The medications were prescribed according to each patient's needs; no single medication was used by all. Among the medications were:

Antihistamines such as Vistaril ™ and Atarax ™ especially for those who hyperventilated (Schmetzer 2003).

Hydroxyzine for those whose major expression of anxiety was insomnia (Schmetzer 2003).

Inderal ™ was used for those with anticipatory anxiety, for instance, those who had symptoms prior to planned encounters with the problematical supervisor (Schmetzer 2003).

This group met once a week, and began each session with generalized statements about their experience of anxiety during the previous week and whether their anxiety had increased or decreased.

The group met for only an hour each week; during that time, the counselor chose the most common response among the group members and commented on an appropriate emotional response to the issue raised. The group members then commented concerning their own experience with the issue; what their response was and what it would be next time.

At the end of the session, the counselor avoided giving the group an 'assignment' for next week. The group members each maintained two journals, however, one concerning the specifics of their job search and the other containing the specifics of their mental, emotional and physical reactions to their situation.

Group B. took no medication and met for two hours each week. This group was approached through a variety of cognitive methods, with Rational-Emotive Therapy being the major framework of their treatment. At the beginning session, each was taught the 'dispute' method of handling their anxieties developed primarily by Dr. Albert Ellis (ADD HIS BOOK HERE). Each was asked to think about two goals before the next session. The first goal concerned concrete steps they needed to take in their job search. The second goal was to be a benchmark for anxiety reduction, for example, reducing hyperventilation in situations in which they anticipated an unpleasant encounter with the supervisor.

By week six, Group a was reporting diminished physical symptoms of generalized anxiety; however, emotional responses to the triggers were not significantly reduced, at least according to observation and the self-reporting the group did. None had found a new job; only one had begun sending out resumes.

Group B. had experienced significant success in coping with the triggers. They particularly liked the idea that "although it is nice for everyone to like me and treat me well, I won't die if they don't" -- a paraphrase of a Dr. Ellis technique that they had been taught. The physical symptoms had virtually disappeared for this group. One member had actually been so successful at 'disputing' that she had come to an accommodation with her boss through a frank discussion, and was planning on keeping her job, which she liked otherwise very much. The other five members had all begun a job search, and two had had interviews.

All had come to grips with the situation at hand, at least well enough to go to work each day and go home each night to prepare resumes and do other job-hunting tasks. Self-reports also indicated that those with families were having an easier time, as were their families. One member of Group B. had taught her equally overwhelmed husband some of the techniques she had learned.

Review of the Literature

LaTorre (2001) conducted a survey of the possibilities in treating anxiety disorders and concluded that although psychotropic medication often is considered and can be helpful in many cases, it is merely one of a number of interventions possible. Practitioners not limited by this can use equally effective non-pharmacological methods alone or in combination and achieve good results. She noted that studies had shown that cognitive behavioral approaches, similar to the Rational-Emotive therapy described earlier, "allow for an active focus on the client's current problems, while enhancing coping skills" (LaTorre 2001). While La Torre's study did not offer any groundbreaking insights, it is extremely valuable in that it pointed out the advantages not only of combining standard therapeutic techniques, but of using other disciplines as well if they were effective. Among the ones she mentioned were relaxation techniques such as guided imagery and breathing exercises, as well as visualizations and even music therapy to promote change.

Two other interesting studies proceed along similar paths. Nesse (1999) studied the evolution of hope and despair, two emotional conditions that can certainly be considered fellow travelers in respect to generalized anxiety disorder. Nesse wrote:

Events that indicate that our efforts will succeed arouse hope. Events that suggest that our efforts are futile foster despair. We experience hope and despair, not at the beginning or end, but in the midst of our long-term efforts (1999).

While it seems a Pollyanna attitude, Nesse notes that people prefer hope to despair, and also that people prefer it for others (1999), one explanation for people to engage in counseling professions.

Larson and Larson extend beyond hope and despair to investigate the potential of spirituality in emotional health. They suggest that "For a large proportion of either medically ill or mental health patients, spirituality/religion may provide coping resources, enhance pain management, improve surgical outcomes, protect against depression, and reduce risk of substance abuse and suicide" (2003). In other words, it would seem to be possibly highly useful in generalized anxiety disorder treatment, which has elements of depression. They are careful to point out to counselors, however, that "misuse of spirituality/religion to harshly manipulate is linked with mental health harm " (Larson & Larson 2003).

Bowman et al. (1997) investigated the outcomes of adults with generalized anxiety disorder in either self-examination therapy or delayed treatment. "Analyses indicated that participants in self-examination therapy had significantly fewer symptoms of anxiety than did participants in the delayed-treatment group on the outcome measures of this study, which included ratings by trained clinicians and participants" (Bowman et al. 1997).

For the self-examination group, benefits were maintained for three… READ MORE

How to Reference "Generalized Anxiety Disorder" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Anxiety Disorder and Subjective Distress Term Paper

Pathologizing Anxiety: When is it Healthy to be Anxious?

Psychiatry and psychology have a history of confusing normal behavior that is outside of the average with pathology. Anyone with any… read more

Term Paper 4 pages (1401 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

Anxiety Disorders Term Paper

Anxiety Disorders

Studies showed that one out of 8 Americans between the ages of 18 and 54, or more than 19 million Americans, suffer from some form of anxiety disorder… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1425 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Nursing / Doctor / Physician

---

Anxiety Is Most Common Associated With Feelings Research Paper

Anxiety is most common associated with feelings of fear. Arachnophobia, fear of heights, fear of public speaking, all these are in its range. However, while fear is the key word… read more

Research Paper 9 pages (3294 words) Sources: 9 Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

Anxiety Disorders Thesis

anxiety disorders have been increasingly cited by healthcare practitioners as being one of the most serious health problems, exceeding even physical medical conditions, facing adolescents and young adults in the… read more

Thesis 14 pages (4060 words) Sources: 15 Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

Separation Anxiety Disorder Thesis

Separation Anxiety Disorder

Separation anxiety is a very natural reaction and very much a part of the normal cognitive development of a child. However, separation anxiety disorder is an abnormal… read more

Thesis 10 pages (2722 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>